Powers & Abilities Roger isn’t a swordsman

#1
"But he loved his sword so much"
"Why does he has supreme blade then"

You don't become a swordsman by picking up a sword when you're 25+ years old in your journey!
Just like Linlin who picked up her sword for the sake of it, Roger didn't pick up Ace cause he was a swordsman, it was just for the sake of it.


You really think Oden would boast himself having the strongest sword style if Roger was a swordsman? If Roger had the strongest sword style?

Roger doesn't even attack like a swordsman. His attacks aren't traditional cutting/slashing moves!
He prefer overpowering than cutting someone down!

No swordsman in this story became a swordsman when they're old or during prime!
All of them started swordmanship when they were kids : Law, Ryuma, Mihawk, Vista, Oden, Zoro, Tashigi, etc...

Oda usually hype swordsman with cutting feats :
Ryuma cutting a dragon, Law cutting a mountain, Zoro cutting Golem Pica, Mihawk cutting the iceberg, Oden cutting (scarring) Kaido and the mountain boar etc...
These feats are hyped in Zoro novels or sbs or magazines. And these guys clearly claim being swordsman or Oda clearly states it in the manga/sbs (sometimes novels/databooks)

Where's Roger's cutting feat them?
What's his sword style?
Who told you he was trained or trained himself in swordmanship?

you dont got from brawler to Swordsman /sniper
Every admiral know swordmanship yet they aren't swordsmen
Most people use swords yet they aren't swordmen

Being a swordsman is when one consider themselves to be one and are trained in swordmanship

Roger is like Linlin : didn't train swordmanship, they just picked up elbaf techniques ("divine" moves are from elbaf, skypean or lunarian tribes) and other moves to suit themselves. **(This also explains why Shanks loves elbaf a lot, Roger provably used to hang there a lot too)**
Both Roger and Linlin only picked up weapons to channel their haki and that's it.

Stop your lame agenda,
Roger is a sword user who could brawl and use guns, Oden was the strongest swordsman who had the strongest swordmanship back then.

@RayanOO @Sentinel @Playa4321 @Jiihad @Reborn
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
#3
You can't just pick up a supreme grade sword noodle you brainlet.
You need to master it. Thats why fat meme doesn't even have a meito.
This guy really said why does he have a saijo like it proves he's not a swordman lmfao
Post automatically merged:

Oda gotta explain it
To those without a brain he can't explain it any more than he has.
 
#8
Zoro: "Carrying a Sword isn't same as using a Sword Style"
We already had our Answer since Syrup Village Arc, when Zoro said this

So anyone who carries a Sword (Blade, not like Caesar's Sword) & uses a Named Sword Attack, is automatically a Swordsman.
Haki & DF can both be used to Enhance such Techniques.

Tashigi? T-Bone? Fujitora? Swordsmen
Brook? Law? Drake? Cavendish? Swordsmen
Scabbards (Most)? Hyogoro? Oden? Zombie Ryuma? Swordsmen
Big Mom? Roger? Shanks? Swordsmen
Cracker? Streusen? Dorry? Hyouzou? Hatchan? Swordsmen
Kaku? Kyros? Diamante? Wanda? Swordsmen
... etc

Characters who haven't shown any Sword Style include:

Kizaru, Aokiji, King, Queen, Jack, Pica, Moria, Sasaki, Baby 5 ... etc
These Characters haven't shown any Sword-Style Techniques, so it's safe to exclude them from Swordsmen until Proven otherwise.
While Characters like Rayligh, Shiryu, Vista, Bogard ... etc are obviously Swordsmen, We simply awaiting to see their Signature Moves

And as for the Claim of WSS Mihawk > Swordsmen, it means that Any Technique that Any Swordsman can Pull, Mihawk can use a Stronger Technique, a Greater Feat.

Streusen's Technique cut entire Whole Cake Chateau? Mihawk can do Better
Oden's Technique gave Kaidou a Permanant Scar? Mihawk can do Better
Roger's Technique sent Oden flying very far? Mihawk can do Better
Shanks's Technique One-Shot Kid/Killer? Mihawk can do Better
Big Mom's Technique traveled entire Onigashima & much Farther? Mihawk can do Better
Inurashi's Technique Defeated Jack? Mihawk can do Better
And same goes for Zoro's Feats ... etc

So it's all about Sword (Blade Only) Techniques, if you have a Named Attack or Sword Style, then you're Officially a Swordsman.
And anything included in these Attacks/Techniques, Mihawk can do better, as simple as that
 
Top