Why there is this theory of Catarina Devon being actually Bonney. Ok, I get that some Blackbeard pirates got on Egghead (we can see their ship) and even if we don't take in consideration the defence system and take it for granted they succeded in sneaking on the island, why there is this rumor of Davon being Bonney?
A lot of people I saw, take this panel as a proof in chapter 1090. A way to insinuate Bonney is acting strange because she is, in reality, another person. I get it, Luffy is noticing the "change of attitude" by Bonney and so Bonney seems like she is hiding something right? Yes, but not in the way a lot of people are thinking.
The same people maybe forgot that Bonney entered in Kuma's "bubble" and so she revived the memories of her father. She saw something we didn't see, or at least not completely, that's why she seems "changed" and not why she is in reality another person.
The last time we see Bonney ( without considering Sabo's flashback in Marijoa before 1090 is in chapter 1078), she seems devastated from what she saw. That's the moment when she changed her beahviour, she understood it is not Vegapunk's fault for her father actual condition, or at least not completely.
Back in chapter 1090, Luffy even said he saw her crying which is something true as we saw her in 1078, maybe she continued for a good amount of time, and she replied angry at Luffy. To me she seems like the original Bonney, nothing more and nothing less.
A lot of people I saw, take this panel as a proof in chapter 1090. A way to insinuate Bonney is acting strange because she is, in reality, another person. I get it, Luffy is noticing the "change of attitude" by Bonney and so Bonney seems like she is hiding something right? Yes, but not in the way a lot of people are thinking.
The same people maybe forgot that Bonney entered in Kuma's "bubble" and so she revived the memories of her father. She saw something we didn't see, or at least not completely, that's why she seems "changed" and not why she is in reality another person.
The last time we see Bonney ( without considering Sabo's flashback in Marijoa before 1090 is in chapter 1078), she seems devastated from what she saw. That's the moment when she changed her beahviour, she understood it is not Vegapunk's fault for her father actual condition, or at least not completely.
Back in chapter 1090, Luffy even said he saw her crying which is something true as we saw her in 1078, maybe she continued for a good amount of time, and she replied angry at Luffy. To me she seems like the original Bonney, nothing more and nothing less.
Last edited:
