Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1148 Spoilers Discussion

[Kōri no kokyū]

Technically roger pirates and HKs should be on same side in GV.

What no.
Marines has job of defending CD.
Holyknights doesn't have the job of protecting CD.
How many Hokyknights were Deployed during reverie? Zero!

CD probably fought whoever they saw.

Roger and Garp vs Xebec
Whitebeard vs Garling
Sommers vs Gaban

 

[FlyFlower]

Killingham and Sommers?

http://imgur.com/a/rusAi0U

Gaban beat up a teenager?

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

@Fujishiro explain it to me like I’m 5:

If we see restrained Swordzaru fight with Rayleigh, and Gaban is =< Rayleigh, how does that not directly hype Swordzaru as >= Gaban as well?

Gaban is slightly above old Ray anyway.

 

[soupongo]

Do y'all really think Sommers is gonna react like that to supposedly permanent injury/damage?

Am I missing something in the full summary? What do you mean?

 

[Kōri no kokyū]

Gaban beat up a teenager?

Given Sommers reaction , he likely won lol

 

[Zufolobelisk]

Killingham and Sommers?

http://imgur.com/a/rusAi0U

The one on top might be Killingham due to the mask, but there's no way Sommers is either of them.

 

[MonsterKaido]

What no.
Marines has job of defending CD.
Holyknights doesn't have the job of protecting CD.
How many Hokyknights were Deployed during reverie? Zero!

CD probably fought whoever they saw.

Roger and Garp vs Xebec
Whitebeard vs Garling
Sommers vs Gaban

Roger joined Garp meaning they sided with marines. There is garling vs WB fight also. I do believe HKs also fought against rocks pirates.

 

[Zufolobelisk]

Fodder

We know nothing about them yet.

Post automatically merged: May 6, 2025

Roger joined Garp meaning they sided with marines. There is garling vs WB fight also. I do believe HKs also fought against rocks pirates.

The God's Knights absolutely fought against the Rocks Pirates. Someone had to protect the Celestial Dragons who were non-combatants.

 

[ShinichiMugi]

WABAN

 

[Zufolobelisk]

Am I missing something in the full summary? What do you mean?

To be fair, what we were shown wasn't the full full summary. There's a whole lot of information we weren't given.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Am I missing something in the full summary? What do you mean?

He got his hand chopped off and simply said "Long time no see Gaban!"

 

[Rumble]

Am I missing something in the full summary? What do you mean?

Apparently Sommers acknowledges Gaban on arrival by name on some "long time no see" shit after he gets his hand cut off.

If Sommers is so used to being immortal and regenerating, don't you find that an odd reaction to permanent injury/damage?

Of course that's assuming it is permanent, which is the point I'm getting at. I think it's too soon to make any judgments on the regen.

 

[Kōri no kokyū]

Roger joined Garp meaning they sided with marines. There is garling vs WB fight also. I do believe HKs also fought against rocks pirates.

I don't see Holyknights falling that low.
They consider human insects.

Holyknights were probably fighting whoever they found first

 

[soupongo]

Apparently Sommers acknowledges Gaban on arrival by name on some "long time no see shit" after he gets his hand cut off.

If Sommers is so used to being immortal and regenerating, don't you find that an odd reaction to permanent injury/damage?

Of course that's assuming it is permanent, which is the point I'm getting at. I think it's too soon to make any judgments on the regen.

I think it's as simple as him acknowledging Gabans presence, but this is a fair point

 

[Woozles]

I don't see Holyknights falling that low.
They consider human insects.

Holyknights were probably fighting whoever they found first

I think people are so agenda brained/deep in the "Roger defended slaves" angle

That they don't even consider the more likely option that the entirety of God's Valley was just a complete battle royal with no definitive alliances.

 

[Zufolobelisk]

I don't see Holyknights falling that low.
They consider human insects.

Holyknights were probably fighting whoever they found first

The humans that made up the Rocks Pirates weren't exactly "insects" (not to mention most of them aren't even considered human in-universe), so I'm sure the Holy Knights did, indeed, fall that low.

 

[ElderOnitar]

Is Sommers the 2nd character to beat the TAC curse?? Admiral twerkers were clowning on him earlier, but now we know Sommers was rivals with Prime Gaban and doesn’t even care about his arm being chopped off

Linyagi before vs after the full summary

@EmperorKinyagi

Guernica got the "strongest CP0" statement right after @TheAncientCenturion started stanning him.

 

[Rumble]

Just because the Roger Pirates and Garp's Marines worked together doesn't mean the Knights were a part of that alliance.

I imagine the fighting took place all over the island and there were areas where Roger and Garp and their underlings worked together, and areas where pirates, Marines and Knights were scrapping out indiscriminately.

 

[Zufolobelisk]

I think people are so agenda brained/deep in the "Roger defended slaves" angle

That they don't even consider the more likely option that the entirety of God's Valley was just a complete battle royal with no definitive alliances.

Until Oda finally depicts what really happened between the pirates, the Marines, and the Celestial Dragons on God Valley, everything everyone says about it will continue to be pure speculation.

 

[Jackteo]

Sommers is fine, Gaban achieved nothing