Questions & Mysteries Who do you consider more evil, Hisoka or Chrollo?

[Flower]

Chrollo literally took part in the slaughter of innocent people (The Kurta Clan). Hisoka hasn‘t killed innocents as far as we‘re aware, so how is that even a debate lol. I would say most people he killed were also killers themselves even when he killed the Hunter candidates early on, so he only kills those who are willing to kill themselves.

Also in what world are Shal and Kortopi innocents lol. Shal helped massacre the Kurtas and Kortopi helped with the shit in Yorknew.

 

[kekaro]

Chrollo is NE, Hisoka CE

 

[Flower]

Chrollo is NE, Hisoka CE

Hisoka is Chaotic Neutral. Literally the embodiment of that alignment. Chrollo is Chaotic Evil.

 

[Roo]

Hisoka is Chaotic Neutral. Literally the embodiment of that alignment. Chrollo is Chaotic Evil.

Killing people for fun is pretty evil

 

[MonochromeYoru]

How is this even a question?

It's Hisoka

Chrollo does evil as a means to an end

The clown is evil for lols

 

[Roo]

How is this even a question?

It's Hisoka

Chrollo does evil as a means to an end

The clown is evil for lols

Exactly

I think people just view evil for fun less than killing as a means to an end?

honestly the best outcome for society is both spiders and hisoka take each other

 

[Flower]

How is this even a question?

It's Hisoka

Chrollo does evil as a means to an end

The clown is evil for lols

Chrollo literally slaughtered kids and old people from the Kurta Clan. How is that less evil than killing people who also kill people themselves?

 

[SkySanji]

They're both evil and will kill pretty much anyone, but Hisoka is legitimately a pedophile on top of that, and Chrollo kills for the money whereas Hisoka does it for the enjoyment, both those reasons clearly make Hisoka the worst of the two.

 

[Roo]

Chrollo literally slaughtered kids and old people from the Kurta Clan. How is that less evil than killing people who also kill people themselves?

the only reason he lets gon live is because he has potential to be strong lol

so hisoka is not above killing kids

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Chrollo literally slaughtered kids and old people from the Kurta Clan. How is that less evil than killing people who also kill people themselves?

Kurta massacre had it's reasons

The troupe were trying to find Sarasa's killer. It's pretty much gonna end up being Tserry, who has the eyes now. So that will all connect back.

And also it was business too for them. Killing people for money is not worse than killing people for fun imo.

 

[Flower]

Kurta massacre had it's reasons

The troupe were trying to find Sarasa's killer. It's pretty much gonna end up being Tserry, who has the eyes now. So that will all connect back.

And also it was business too for them. Killing people for money is not worse than killing people for fun imo.

Yeah, sure, killing kids and old people who couldn’t have even killed her and making them suffer so much they made them turn their eyes red are such good reasons.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Yeah, sure, killing kids and old people who couldn’t have even killed her and making them suffer so much they made them turn their eyes red are such good reasons.

I did not say they were good reasons lol

Just reasons

Also, eyes turning red is a kurta clan ability. Not a consequence of the massacre solely

 

[Flower]

I did not say they were good reasons lol

Just reasons

Also, eyes turning red is a kurta clan ability. Not a consequence of the massacre solely

The eyes turn red when they are enraged. They intentionally made them suffer so much their eyes turned red all while slaughtering innocent people. The difference between the Troupe and Hisoka is the same as when a buff guy only fights and kills other buff guys or when a buff guy kills or fights everyone even when they don’t even stand a ghost of a chance. You wouldn’t ever call the former worse than the latter.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

The eyes turn red when they are enraged. They intentionally made them suffer so much their eyes turned red all while slaughtering innocent people. The difference between the Troupe and Hisoka is the same as when a buff guy only fights and kills other buff guys or when a buff guy kills or fights everyone even when they don’t even stand a ghost of a chance. You wouldn’t ever call the former worse than the latter.

The eyes turn red when they are emotionally agitated. It's not specific to genocide only lol

Also, hisoka has murdered plenty of innocents and weak people. He is not some saint who only kills powerful bad guys.

 

[soupongo]

How is this even a question?

It's Hisoka

Chrollo does evil as a means to an end

The clown is evil for lols

Because the trouper probably has more casualties, so it's like
Intent vs overall actions

 

[Roo]

Because the trouper probably has more casualties, so it's like
Intent vs overall actions

hisoka literally got called a serial killer, so he likely has a huge body count as well

 

[Killerj]

The dude who did more evil is more evil.....
And thats Chrolo
Man used the heavenly arena spectators, kids old people, randoms etc as weapons, killed hundreds(and thats lowballing) only in that fight
Hisoka doesnt have that body count in all manga.
Whos more evil a dude with 10 people killed on screen or another with 1000, think.

 

[Kung-Fu Dugong]

IMO, it's obviously Hisoka. Although the troupe is certainly more destructive than Hisoka could ever be and may kill innocents as a collateral, Chrollo does have a reason for his actions. If you take a good look, so far (on panel) the troupe never messed with anyone innocent... they basically just targeted mafia (or dictatorships, in the case of the Kakin Royal Family, which is pretty much mafiosi too).

Chrollo and the PT are considerably worse. Remember the auction house massacre plus the mass torture / pretty much genocide of a whole ethnic group. The "nice" and "sympathetic" moments they get isn't something that actually redeems their actions.

Chrollo literally took part in the slaughter of innocent people (The Kurta Clan). Hisoka hasn‘t killed innocents as far as we‘re aware, so how is that even a debate lol. I would say most people he killed were also killers themselves even when he killed the Hunter candidates early on, so he only kills those who are willing to kill themselves.

Also in what world are Shal and Kortopi innocents lol. Shal helped massacre the Kurtas and Kortopi helped with the shit in Yorknew.

What if the Kurta Clan isn't that innocent? There are some theories that the Kurta Clan was evil and had shady businesses with the mafia or they did something against Sheila.

Idk how people can watch Chrollo nonchalantly using the audience as a weapon at Heaven’s Arena and think he’s not more evil

Well, it seems that the Heavens Arena allow these kind of rules, as even the judge was killed, so the spectators probably know the risks beforehand.

 

[Flower]

What if the Kurta Clan isn't that innocent? There are some theories that the Kurta Clan was evil and had shady businesses with the mafia or they did something against Sheila.

Oh right, just because one member or two might have done something the entire Clan is automatically guilty even children like Kurapika and his friend who obviously never did something to them . Actually astonishing how some people here say the Troupe is less evil than a guy who doesn’t harm anyone who can’t defend themselves.

 

[Kung-Fu Dugong]

Oh right, just because one member or two might have done something the entire Clan is automatically guilty even children like Kurapika and his friend who obviously never did something to them . Actually astonishing how some people here say the Troupe is less evil than a guy who doesn’t harm anyone who can’t defend themselves.

Well, as I said, innocents might die too. I never said that the troupe was good or morally grey or anything like that, I just said that Hisoka is more evil. However, the Kurta Clan was feared by the nearby town at least, so they mostly certainly did bad things in the past (not just one member or two).

Spoiler: Kurapika's Memories: Part Two