News Volume 112 - Discussion Thread (July 4th, 2025)

[Shiroyru]

Oda considers him a Roger Pirate main members is just the core crew. It’s like saying Rockstar is not a red haired pirate.


Of course he’s yonko level? When did I ever say he wasn’t

Are you trying to push Gaban being PK level then?

 

[Shiroyru]

Yasheen just desperately wants Oden to be included in Oimo's statement so he can force Gaban > Oden, purely agenda.

Gaban upscale is Sanji upscale by proxy, and Yasheen firmly believes Croc is Sanji’s EoS opponent. It’s just been Croc wank in disguise all along lol

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Are you trying to push Gaban being PK level then?

Gaban and Ray are just all above the yonko

 

[Fujishiro]

Oda considers him a Roger Pirate main members is just the core crew. It’s like saying Rockstar is not a red haired pirate.

Yeah so why isnt core member Oden not named with Gaban and Rayleigh lol.

Gaban can still be > Oden, but those two + Rayleigh are clearly in the same ballpark. Oden can range anywhere from slightly stronger than Ray to slightly weaker than Gaban

Yeah they are comparable, people just got wild with the Oden downplay lmfao.

 

[SkySanji]

Gaban upscale is Sanji upscale by proxy, and Yasheen firmly believes Croc is Sanji’s EoS opponent. It’s just been Croc wank in disguise all along lol

You're probably right about that, the agendas of some people go way too deep.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Yasheen just desperately wants Oden to be included in Oimo's statement so he can force Gaban > Oden, purely agenda.

Only in worstgen would saying a character introduced as a Roger Pirate is included in a statement About the Roger pirates is desperate

 

[Shiroyru]

You're probably right about that, the agendas of some people go way too deep.

Literally all of Yasheen’s opinions are designed to wank Croc by proxy as much as possible lol. One of the most shameless agenda posters on this site

 

[soupongo]

Yeah so why isnt core member Oden not named with Gaban and Rayleigh lol.


Yeah they are comparable, people just got wild with the Oden downplay lmfao.

same reason Sunbell, Buggy and Shanks aren't. Not every Roger pirates needs to be named, or had a roll in the crew, I guess.

 

[Shiroyru]

Only in worstgen would saying a character introduced as a Roger Pirate is included in a statement About the Roger pirates is desperate

Oda included Crocus but not Oden bro. He’s not a main Roger Pirate. He’s at best a half-fledged crew member

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Yeah so why isnt core member Oden not named with Gaban and Rayleigh lol.


Yeah they are comparable, people just got wild with the Oden downplay lmfao.

Cause Gaban and Ray are literally Roger’s two main members and have been for 2 decades.

Oden is still a member. Canonically he’s a member of the Roger Pirates

 

[Fujishiro]

same reason Sunbell isn't. Not every Roger pirates needs to be named, or had a roll in the crew, I guess.

Sunbell was named in a SBS, Oden is extremely relevant. Like hes the most known guy that voyaged with Roger bar Rayleigh and now Gaban lmfao, and he was not named.

Cause Gaban and Ray are literally Roger’s two main members and have been for 2 decades.

Oden is still a member. Canonically he’s a member of the Roger Pirates

Oden would be third, why wasnt he named :)

Even Akainu and Sengoku talked about WBs commander lol.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Oda included Crocus but not Oden bro. He’s not a main Roger Pirate. He’s at best a half-fledged crew member

Crocus has a dedicated role on the ship as doctor.

Y’all trying too hard to do a bunch of mental gymnastics here when oda already called oda a Roger pirate in manga multiple times. Odens yonko level but he’s still only Roger’s 3rd strongest subordinate. Nothing wrong with that

 

[Fujishiro]

Crocus has a dedicated role on the ship as doctor.

Y’all trying too hard to do a bunch of mental gymnastics here when oda already called oda a Roger pirate in manga multiple times. Odens yonko level but he’s still only Roger’s 3rd strongest subordinate. Nothing wrong with that

You lost bro. A dude that has a role of torturer was named but not Oden lmfao.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Sunbell was named in a SBS, Oden is extremely relevant. Like hes the most known guy that voyaged with Roger bar Rayleigh and now Gaban lmfao, and he was not named.

Oden would be third, why wasnt he named :)

Even Akainu and Sengoku talked about WBs commander lol.

Cause we’re talking importance not strength? Sengoku literally talked about him as a Roger Pirate. Again it was stated multiple times that Odens a Roger Pirate.

 

[soupongo]

Sunbell was named in a SBS, Oden is extremely relevant. Like hes the most known guy that voyaged with Roger bar Rayleigh and now Gaban lmfao, and he was not named.

Post automatically merged: Wednesday at 12:41 AM

Oden would be third, why wasnt he named :)

Lmao, his popularity doesn't matter, Sunbell has been consistently shown as a crewmate, and yet wasn't mentioned in the SBS. Plus, Shanks and Buggy are probably more known than Oden anyway...

 

[Shiroyru]

same reason Sunbell, Buggy and Shanks aren't. Not every Roger pirates needs to be named, or had a roll in the crew, I guess.

Bro Oden’s role in the crew was translating the RPs. The he had no role cope makes no sense. Sunbell wasn’t included because he’s just as irrelevant as the rest of the background Roger Pirates and Oda only chose a few of them because he didn’t want to give a role to all 30 members. Shanks and Buggy weren’t included because they were just kids

 

[Sir Yasheen]

You lost bro. A dude that has a role of torturer was named but not Oden lmfao.

Youre literally arguing with the canon because odens not a core member of the Roger pirates… despite multiple Roger pirates being named members but not being mentioned here.

Nah this is some wild mental gymnastics lmao

 

[Fujishiro]

Lmao, his popularity doesn't matter, Sunbell has been consistently shown as a crewmate, and yet wasn't mentioned in the SBS. Plus, Shanks and Buggy are probably more known than Oden anyway...

Cause we’re talking importance not strength? Sengoku literally talked about him as a Roger Pirate. Again it was stated multiple times that Odens a Roger Pirate.

The duality of man.

Yes his relevance and popularity matters Loupongo.

 

[Monkey D. Luffy]

Literally all of Yasheen’s opinions are designed to wank Croc by proxy as much as possible lol. One of the most shameless agenda posters on this site

Wouldn't Kurwa wank the Admirals for the same exact reasons?

 

[soupongo]

Bro Oden’s role in the crew was translating the RPs. The he had no role cope makes no sense. Sunbell wasn’t included because he’s just as irrelevant as the rest of the background Roger Pirates and Oda only chose a few of them because he didn’t want to give a role to all 30 members. Shanks and Buggy weren’t included because they were just kids

Okay so, Odens role was already known I guess?
Why would Age matter? Shanks and Buggy are still in fact members of the Roger pirates lol