Status
Not open for further replies.
We can already deduce that Garling fought WB as WB claims his scars ache when he sees shanks face
I'm not on board with that theory.

This seemed very clearly telegraphed to be about someone we - the audience - already knew, i.e. Roger.


Roger and Shanks' past with him was of course discussed almost immediately after.


Whatever level you think Shanks is, I don't think it can be taken for granted Garling is even all that close. He may very well be, but I think we can pump the brakes on who can scar Whitebeard and who Oda would go out of his way to foreshadow 652 chapters prior to their debut.
 
Last edited:
That is headcanon there is no panel of sengoku giving the order of killing women/children.
It wa draw marines that did it tho… If Oda wants the WG to be the one that does something, he doesn’t have the marines do it

When it was revealed that even Sword was an official division of the marines then it was clear that everything the marines do is an order from the Fleet admiral… There is no faction of marines that gets orders from someone besides the fleet admiral
 
So we really think that a non-prime daddy is stronger than the 4B son with 2 of the most poweful dfs??? Lmfaooo

Teach himself might be maxed out at this point, he‘s just not revealing his last powerup. At most one powerup away from prime, this version is still>>Rookie dad by logic.
Xebec killed the admiral before he became a pirate. So he was not even a rookie
 
I'm not onboard with that theory.

This seem very clearly telegraphed to be about someone we - the audience - already knew, i.e. Roger.


Roger and Shanks' past with him is of course is discussed almost immediately after.


Whatever level you think Shanks is, I don't think it can be taken for granted Garling is even all that close. He may very well be, but I think we can pump the brakes on who can scar Whitebeard and who Oda would go out of his way to foreshadow 652 chapters prior to their debut.
I think it’s a simple retcon, oda is not above that. I don’t think Rocks was a thing back then, just like Ace wasn’t Roger’s son at the BOS
Post automatically merged:

Ace if he was alive > Law, Kid, Sanji and Zoro
Post TS Ace = Shanks
 
I'm not onboard with that theory.

This seem very clearly telegraphed to be about someone we - the audience - already knew, i.e. Roger.


Roger and Shanks' past with him is of course is discussed almost immediately after.


Whatever level you think Shanks is, I don't think it can be taken for granted Garling is even all that close. He may very well be, but I think we can pump the brakes on who can scar Whitebeard and who Oda would go out of his way to foreshadow 652 chapters prior to their debut.

Whitebeard has no scar on his last meet with Roger :DeepThink:
 
Roger and Garp vs Rox
Sengoku described Rocks as maybe being his greatest foe. This doesn't compute with that.


Entire Holy Knights vs Whitebeard
Ray and Gaban vs Shiki
I'm actually m
My bad, I'm high as shit. :kobeha:

Gil Bastar is one of the weakest Rocks members
Based on what?

To Wang Zhi be defeated was need BBP + Law + Koby

Idk how Wang Zhi wasn't recognized as an emperor
What are you basing any of this on?
 
I almost forgot - i don't know if anyone mentioned this but - we get a chapter revealing Rocks, and the title of that chapter is "Unable to die" - i know that's pure madness but there's a chance.

Everything we know about Teach and Rocks = death of Rocks is SUS.

Let's put it this way - until the manga shows me that Rocks actually died - i won't believe it.

:goyea::usoprice::catsure::crybeard:
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top