Bougya To the "Shanks/Roger sword attacks doesn't cut therefore they are not a swordsmen" troupe

[S.W317]

There’s no such a thing as a hakiman, if there was that’s dumb because being the strongest always equals having the strongest haki in OP

 

[HerreraIsBack]

No like swird attack idiot.

It was a joke

Post automatically merged: Jul 17, 2025

There’s no such a thing as a hakiman, if there was that’s dumb because being the strongest always equals having the strongest haki in OP

B-b-b-u-t Shanks fans says he is the ultimate MMA hakiman

 

[MonsterKaido]

Big mom is swordswoman

 

[Guymieux]

He fought with a sword against Oars, my dear.
He appeared with a sword on a volume cover, and wielded a graded sword.
Luffy is a swordsman, for the same reason WB is, as YOU said ,a spearman, who only fought fodder with a spear.

Luffy fought oars with a sword because the shadow of a great swordsman was in him you moron

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Luffy fought oars with a sword because the shadow of a great swordsman was in him you moron

Against arlong he fought with sword, in wano he fought with sword.
100% swordsman according to Pederrera

 

[Guymieux]

Against arlong he fought with sword, in wano he fought with sword.
100% swordsman according to Pederrera

He used swords against arling then threw them away and said he doesn’t fight with swords because he’s not a swordsman . In wano he punched with a sword and zoro said that’s not how you use it .

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

He used swords against arling then threw them away and said he doesn’t fight with swords because he’s not a swordsman . In wano he punched with a sword and zoro said that’s not how you use it .

Still used a sword, that is the requisite of Herrera, not mine

 

[Cruxroux]

Against arlong he fought with sword, in wano he fought with sword.
100% swordsman according to Pederrera

Lmao you're just wasting people time intentionally now.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Lmao you're just wasting people time intentionally now.

Of course I am, i'm blatantly using semantics to shit on herrera

 

[comrade]

Mihawk in his duel with Shanks was like, "no Kamusari allowed in the fight, swordsmanship is about cutting".

 

[Cruxroux]

Mihawk in his duel with Shanks was like, "no Kamusari allowed in the fight, swordsmanship is about cutting".

That's still past lol.

Imagine in future mihawk asks Zoro to turn of haki. This is a swordsmanship match

 

[Rukusho]

How about Aokiji and Kizaru? Aokiji does have an ice saber. Kizaru uses his light sword against Rayleigh.

Aokiji going all out like we seen against Garp, he doesn't seem to be a swordsman but capable of swordsmanship.

It's similar to other members of CP9 (Kaku states he's the best swordsman on the crew - meaning other members have the capability to be swordsman but its not their preferred method of fighting)

Kizaru the closest we've seen him going all out to me is against Rayleigh where he was damaged and attentively trying to prevent something, at the moment I have him 50/50.

 

[HerreraIsBack]

Mihawk in his duel with Shanks was like, "no Kamusari allowed in the fight, swordsmanship is about cutting".

Chapter 1055 breaks your agenda

That's still past lol.

Imagine in future mihawk asks Zoro to turn of haki. This is a swordsmanship match

He literally taugh haki to Zoro in order to make him a better swordsman

Aokiji going all out like we seen against Garp, he doesn't seem to be a swordsman but capable of swordsmanship.

It's similar to other members of CP9 (Kaku states he's the best swordsman on the crew - meaning other members have the capability to be swordsman but its not their preferred method of fighting)

Kizaru the closest we've seen him going all out to me is against Rayleigh where he was damaged and attentively trying to prevent something, at the moment I have him 50/50.

Is not unusual of Oda to make retcons. Maybe he was initially a swordsman. The best game of One Piece had him as a swordsman because he was released before his fight with Garp I supposed.

 

[Sentry22]

Everyone knows Roger and Shanks are more so Hakiman than swordsman.

 

[Cruxroux]

Everyone knows Roger Shanks is more so Hakiman than swordsman.

Yes Shanks and Mihawk were fighting without haki.

 

[Blazing Lion]

Yes Shanks and Mihawk were fighting without haki.

The duels that WB even held in high regard were just cutting competitions and fencing.

 

[Cruxroux]

The duels that WB even held in high regard were just cutting competitions and fencing.

Without haki they were shaking grandline

 

[Blazing Lion]

Without haki they were shaking grandline

Damn they must have physical strength way beyond Oars the continent puller. WBs title confirmed fraud.

 

[Juanpiz]

Kaido is a clubman. Whitebeard is a spearman.

Akshually it is a naginata

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

The duels that WB even held in high regard were just cutting competitions and fencing.

It was just one duel i think, but yeah, it was an mma fight where Mihawk brought a sword