Speculations Who is the slayer of Xebec?

[nik87]

As we draw closer to the fateful day in God Valley, where Rocks D Xebec met his end, it is time to guess who gets to decorate himself with the badge of "killer of Rocks".
We know that many were present at the hunger games happening in God Valley where Pirates and Marines united to crush Rocks Pirates.
However, among all the Rocks Pirates, only Rocks himself died that day, it seems...

Who killed him?

On the opposing side, we had Roger Pirates, Garp's unit, Holy Knights and at least one Elder.
Imu is also worth considering due to remote takeover of bearer of mark of Abyss.

Top candidates that can be considered as the killer of Xebec are:

1 - Monkey D Garp
2 - Gol D Roger
3 - Figarland Garling
4 - Elder Saturn
5 - remote Imu
6 - betrayer among Rocks Pirates

 

[Cruxroux]

What if it's imu

 

[Garps tekkai]

They talked about betrayal mulitple times. I think he might have really been backstabbed. Might even be that Silver Axe and his presumed Karma fruit symbolically became his Karma that got him.
1.choice: backstabbed by Silver Axe
2.choice: Remote Imu

 

[Killerj]

Gold d rogeru

 

[Salah WG]

Dorry vs Brogy ---> Ruined by Mr. 3
Luffy vs Katakuri ---> Ruined by Flampe
Zoro vs Killer ---> Ruined by Onimaru
Kaidou vs Oden ---> Ruined by Higurashi
Kaidou vs Luffy ---> Ruined by Guernica
Calgara vs Noland ---> Ruined by Mousse (Unintentional)
Harald vs Loki ---> Also Hinted to have been Ruined by Jarul
... etc

This Historic End of Xebec have all the Signs that it was another Legendary Fight between Rivals ruined by Someone,
Seeing the Pattern, it can't be Someone as Strong as them, it should be Someone Weaker than Xebec who put an End to his Reign,
It should also be Someone from the Team of whoever landed Final Blow,

Since Garp's Group & Roger's Group don't have anyone who could rely on such Dirty Tactic, then it must be Garling who Killed him,
And the one who intervened in the Fight is either a Traitor from Rocks or Someone from WG, also the Pattern suggest it's not Someone who really benefitted after that Fight, They were dealt with soon after,

Personally i Suspect either Masked Holy Knight (Who looks like Road's Initial Appearance in Elbaph) or One among these Four (Don Marlon, Ganzui, Kyo & Barbel)

 

[MonsterKaido]

Imu/Garling/Gorosei/HKs

Roger beat him though.

 

[Bad English]

Garling

 

[nik87]

then it must be Garling who Killed him

I wasnt using the same logic as you but I arrived at the same conclusion.

 

[HA001]

Zkx

 

[kekaro]

Zkx

real
he will kill him in a sbs

 

[York]

Another victim of heart disease. Simply tragic

 

[soupongo]

Only Imu can erase an island from the map, with Uranus

 

[D. Plant]

Garling, one of those dads who messed with Xebec.

 

[Killerj]

Xebec was surrounded by many men, the father can be even Silver Axe, idk

 

[LolonoisZolo]

Only Imu can erase an island from the map, with Uranus

Can he do it with yours ?

 

[SkySanji]

Roger beat him and then Garling killed him or Imu destroyed the island

 

[MarineHQ]

Obviously Imu

 

[Dragon777]

Imu.

I'm pretty confident It was him.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

After getting backstabbed and betrayed by everyone, and getting quintuple teamed, rocks got so angry that he spontaneously combusted into flames and passed away.

 

[Rej]

I am team Imu.
Xebec probably let himself sink with the island to merge his soul and heart with the sea and become like Davy Jones.

Some Davy Jones locker references.