Questions & Mysteries Is Zoro’s eye scar purely aesthetic

#21
Zoro - Huff huff, why does that woman have the same eyes as Hawkeye?

***Flashback with Mihawk during training***

Mihawk - Roronoa, there will be a time when you will use it as you continue to sail the sea. Use it wisely.

***Present time***

Zoro - Huff huff, don’t tell me she…huff, I guess I have no choice.

Guminko - What is this feeling? **Mirroring Zoro with Ryuma slaying God Knights in Wano capital**. It must be that brat Dracule!

 
Last edited:
#25
It probably can't be a power up. If anything observation haki is usually being portrayed as being able to see without using eyes. So the fact that Zoro can see and fight very well right now is a reason to think he leveled up by losing the eye (Odin did the same).
Opening the eye doesn't add any value in terms of power up since observation haki is symbolised by literally closing your eyes. But I can see Oda pulling an ass pull explanation and have him open the eye during his fight with Shiryu
 
#26
Did you noticed that Zoro is ALMOST ALWAYS nerfed before a fight or inside a ifhgt or his opponent is far better than him. This is not a coincidence, it's by design.

Zoro's journey is the representation of Struggle against a more powerfull ennemy. Why ?

Because Zoro is not only fighting for himself, he is also fighting for Kuina and his promisse to her. Zoro being nerfed is a way for Oda to represent an eternal reminder of his fight against Kuina AND a way to represent the Struggle of Kuina against the realm of stronger men through Zoro.

So his right eye being scared and unusable is an easy way for Oda to nerf Zoro indefinitely.

Zoro will struggle, but will always beat his opponent despite his apparent weaknesses. That's how Oda is saying "Men may be stronger than women, but Women can overcome this gap through their determination". At least that's how I like to think about it.

It's funny how Oda constructed the two wings of Luffy through their relationship to women.
 
#27
Did you noticed that Zoro is ALMOST ALWAYS nerfed before a fight or inside a ifhgt or his opponent is far better than him. This is not a coincidence, it's by design.

Zoro's journey is the representation of Struggle against a more powerfull ennemy. Why ?

Because Zoro is not only fighting for himself, he is also fighting for Kuina and his promisse to her. Zoro being nerfed is a way for Oda to represent an eternal reminder of his fight against Kuina AND a way to represent the Struggle of Kuina against the realm of stronger men through Zoro.

So his right eye being scared and unusable is an easy way for Oda to nerf Zoro indefinitely.

Zoro will struggle, but will always beat his opponent despite his apparent weaknesses. That's how Oda is saying "Men may be stronger than women, but Women can overcome this gap through their determination". At least that's how I like to think about it.

It's funny how Oda constructed the two wings of Luffy through their relationship to women.
This is peak analysis

What do you think about Kuina and Tashigi?
 
#28
What do you think about Kuina and Tashigi?
Thanks !

Tashigi, for some reason, has the same characteristics of Kuina. I would even say (even if we don't know about it) that Kuina was also very clumsy as well, after all, she felt in the stairs..

Now, I'm not exactly sure why Tashigi is here, but I think it has something to do with Oda wants to represent how a woman can achieve her way up despite challenges and also a way for him to develop Zoro's relationship to women.

For me. Zoro, more than Sanji, struggles with two contradictory views of women.

On one side

Zoro thinks women should do what they can to surpass the opposition. That they shouldn't make excuses for their weakness. As for him, Kuina making excuses meant devaluating HIM.



On the other side:

Zoro internalized the idea that women are weaker by nature and therefore should be protected and never defeated by men:



This is also why he refused to really be serious with Money:







Zoro says that he would have finished her and that could be true, but he would have had a HARD time doing it. It wouldn't have seem fair to him.


So this is Zoro's contradiction, on one side, Zoro's goal is to be the best swordman as he knew that if Kuina would be alive, she would be his Rival, but at the same time, the death of Kuina completely destroyed his vision of women and fragility and left him with an impossible struggle

Now, Zoro is constantly in struggle, Here is a video of MelonTee who explain this struggle, this anxiety of strenght:


I agree with the majority. Aside from the fact that I think that Zoro's journey is more than just this self induced anxiety.

It's the weight of grief.

Zoro carries his grief everywhere he goes:

His scars, his nerfs, his weaknesses, are ALL the representations of the burden of the grief that he is imposing on himself by seeking to beat the literal personnification of death who rides on a sailing COFFIN.

 
Top