Bougya Rate the One Piece Manga Overall
- Thread starter Light D Lamperouge
- Start date
Vergo critique shall flourish anew!
It's an Odyssey to read through some of the arcs. Dressrosa Arc should not be as long as the entire Summit War Saga.
It's an Odyssey to read through some of the arcs. Dressrosa Arc should not be as long as the entire Summit War Saga.
Elbaf doesn't feel classic at all in terms of a pirate tale to be honest as it doesn't even involve treasure chests and treasure maps to find them...
The most exciting thing I can think of that gives me classic pirate vibes is the search for the fourth and final Road Poneglyph, which will enable the Strawhats to pinpoint Laugh Tale's location.
The most exciting thing I can think of that gives me classic pirate vibes is the search for the fourth and final Road Poneglyph, which will enable the Strawhats to pinpoint Laugh Tale's location.
I'm talking about the final saga as a whole, not just Elbaf. The pirate tale would not really be interesting on its own, Oda explored it a few times already. What is is using the pirate mythos thematically through the quest of the OP. And here you get everything, the search for the treasure, the map, the pirates rivalry. The last Saga is pure pirate lore, more piraty than anything we saw.. we are just at its beginning.
I didn't think I would like it, as there are parts of it that aren't good. Its not really easy to figure out what or who could end the straw hat pirates run as a crew.
So many moments where you would think the crew died, but it was just some funny save. It is fun to talk about the warlords, but the author regretted creating so many.
The story is still a story, there was obviously a climax some may have not noticed. However, most of the villains we are seeing today have been introduced very early on, which proves my point.
That chapter gives this series an 8/10, because the story of those villains are so emotional.
So many moments where you would think the crew died, but it was just some funny save. It is fun to talk about the warlords, but the author regretted creating so many.
The story is still a story, there was obviously a climax some may have not noticed. However, most of the villains we are seeing today have been introduced very early on, which proves my point.
That chapter gives this series an 8/10, because the story of those villains are so emotional.
It's an 8 or 8.5/10 for me.
Many character designs, moments, plotlines etc are awesome, but sometimes there are things that drag it down.
10/10 for me would be a story that's objectively flawless, or which is so perfect for me that I can ignore all flaws and see it as a 10. I don't think I've ever seen a story of the first kind certainly.
OP isn't that fantastic to me because that bar is way too high, but it is still a memorable, grand and entertaining story that is lovable despite it's flaws.
Many character designs, moments, plotlines etc are awesome, but sometimes there are things that drag it down.
10/10 for me would be a story that's objectively flawless, or which is so perfect for me that I can ignore all flaws and see it as a 10. I don't think I've ever seen a story of the first kind certainly.
OP isn't that fantastic to me because that bar is way too high, but it is still a memorable, grand and entertaining story that is lovable despite it's flaws.
Oh no, a mildly positive score! 
How will Piece stans ever survive?
How will Piece stans ever survive?
This is why I explain that we need a more positivity axed system to counter this. Most of your mild opinions on One Piece are actually - for the most part - conditioned by the material condition in which you are reading the story (spoiler, bad opinion, pacing, week by week etc.). And since the interpretation of a story is bilateral, a bad environment equate to a bad opinion of the story.
This is why I explain that we need a more positivity axed system to counter this. Most of your mild opinions on One Piece are actually - for the most part - conditioned by the material condition in which you are reading the story (spoiler, bad opinion, pacing, week by week etc.). And since the interpretation of a story is bilateral, a bad environment equate to a bad opinion of the story.