Who will be the next SH?


  • Total voters
    150
Who is the better candidate between Loki and Yamato?

Both have been argued to be stronger than Zoro and/or Sanji which messes with the Monster Trio. I'd say Loki is stronger than Yamato from the Elbaph hype around Loki and his bounty. Yamato may be stronger than King, Queen, and Jack but it was not clearly stated nor did any of them fear Yamato. It could be argued King and Queen are more capable than Yamato so since Yamato has a better chance of not breaking the Monster Trio her chances are higher than Loki's in that regard currently.

Yamato missed a key moment in confronting Kanjuro as Oden. Yamato could have evolved from her Oden shtick to her own person. She left to confront Kaido but would have met Kaido sooner if she would have stayed with Momonosuke. Oda purposely removed Yamato to delay her confrontation with her father. Then when opportunity to leave Wano with the Strawhats was given, she decided to stay in Wano to travel and experience Wano first before potentially leaving. Momo and Kin'emon also were invited which downplays any singular connection for Yamato.

Loki without a shape-shifting Devil Fruit cannot fit on the Thousand Sunny. The Strawhats are not getting another ship as the sailing the Thousand Sunny around the world is Franky's dream. However, Loki does have a decent chance of such a fruit because of the Norse lore about Loki though One Piece Loki also has a mix of Norse Thor wielding a hammer that can strike lightning bolts. Loki is somewhat sharing the spotlight with his brother Hajrudin who already is a Strawhat Grand Fleet captain.

Luffy has been giving great focus and attention to bonding with Loki where it was the opposite with Yamato trying to bond with Luffy. Loki was foreshadowed back on Whole Cake Island. Yamato came out of nowhere in Wano's Third Act.

I would give the edge to Loki as long as he has a shape-shifting Devil Fruit and both Zoro and Sanji prove to be better fighters which is possible by both Strawhats beating Domi Reversal Brogy and Dorry.
 

Devilbat

Just chill and let chill
Who is the better candidate between Loki and Yamato?

Both have been argued to be stronger than Zoro and/or Sanji which messes with the Monster Trio. I'd say Loki is stronger than Yamato from the Elbaph hype around Loki and his bounty. Yamato may be stronger than King, Queen, and Jack but it was not clearly stated nor did any of them fear Yamato. It could be argued King and Queen are more capable than Yamato so since Yamato has a better chance of not breaking the Monster Trio her chances are higher than Loki's in that regard currently.

Yamato missed a key moment in confronting Kanjuro as Oden. Yamato could have evolved from her Oden shtick to her own person. She left to confront Kaido but would have met Kaido sooner if she would have stayed with Momonosuke. Oda purposely removed Yamato to delay her confrontation with her father. Then when opportunity to leave Wano with the Strawhats was given, she decided to stay in Wano to travel and experience Wano first before potentially leaving. Momo and Kin'emon also were invited which downplays any singular connection for Yamato.

Loki without a shape-shifting Devil Fruit cannot fit on the Thousand Sunny. The Strawhats are not getting another ship as the sailing the Thousand Sunny around the world is Franky's dream. However, Loki does have a decent chance of such a fruit because of the Norse lore about Loki though One Piece Loki also has a mix of Norse Thor wielding a hammer that can strike lightning bolts. Loki is somewhat sharing the spotlight with his brother Hajrudin who already is a Strawhat Grand Fleet captain.

Luffy has been giving great focus and attention to bonding with Loki where it was the opposite with Yamato trying to bond with Luffy. Loki was foreshadowed back on Whole Cake Island. Yamato came out of nowhere in Wano's Third Act.

I would give the edge to Loki as long as he has a shape-shifting Devil Fruit and both Zoro and Sanji prove to be better fighters which is possible by both Strawhats beating Domi Reversal Brogy and Dorry.
And yet the moment any one of them joins they'll be reduced to running gags, background characters behind Nika and almost no screen time.

That being sad, I wonder what Loki running gag is, because every SH has one. Any ideas?
 
And yet the moment any one of them joins they'll be reduced to running gags, background characters behind Nika and almost no screen time.

That being sad, I wonder what Loki running gag is, because every SH has one. Any ideas?
Loki could show up as random sizes in different comedic and strategic situations. Perhaps have eating competitions with Luffy. We do not know why Loki wanted to marry Lola. Maybe the women Sanji does not like, Loki does. Maybe get his horns stuck in trees, ceilings, etc.
 
Not Vivi :josad:

Yamato is guaranteed to leave Wano at some point, her dream of 20+ years must come true.
Agreed.

If people can feel good about Vivi reuniting with Luffy, then the same can be said for Yamato.

No matter what one thinks of Vivi, it’s always possible Oda can have her murdered, like how her dad was murdered.

So unless one is fine hearing more theories like Vivi murder theories, then we should be able to talk about Yamato with no problem.
 
Almost 2026 and folks are still posting about Yamato joining. Just let it go Oda already broke our heart once don't fall for it again:josad:
Dude, again, the same thing happened with Vivi. Oda spent all that time with Vivi only for her to ditch Luffy in the end for an entire country, and is now set to reunite.

Unless, of course, Oda ends up having Vivi murdered in the story.
 
Last edited:
Dude, again, the same thing happened with Vivi. Oda spent all that time with Vivi only for her to ditch Luffy in the end for an entire country, and is now set to reunite.

Unless, of course, Oda ends up having Vivi murdered in the story.
Not at all the same. Vivi is a crewmate according to Luffy. Yamato is nothing more than a Wano side character
 
While I like Loki and him joining would be dope but similar too Shirahoshi and Momonosuke (and maybe carrot) might be too important to join
Yamato like Jinbe plans to temporarily stay on their islands but making it back to Luffy. So I do believe that theyll


Back to Loki whether he’s another shirahoshi and momo or Jinbe and Yamato depends on if he takes the throne imo. If he takes it he’s definitely just staying. If he’s doesn’t he has no reason to stay besides doing another temporary hold of to protect the island
 
Dude, again, the same thing happened with Vivi. Oda spent all that time with Vivi only for her to ditch Luffy in the end for an entire country, and is now set to reunite.

Unless, of course, Oda ends up having Vivi murdered in the story.
We'll see. I wanted Yamato join, but if he rejoins now it'll be even funnier because of the memes lol
 
Top