Powers & Abilities Roger isn’t a swordsman

Alright.. You repeated yourself and gave nothing of substance.. This is it..
what you consider a blunt a attack or slicing attack doesnt make you a swordsman or not LOL. Rocks is a swordsman and his slashes are like air canon now what ?. A swordsman is if he uses his sword as main or only arsenal of weapon or not. Thats all: Mihawk, Shanks, Roger,Rayleigh, Rocks, Zoro are using it as the only way to attack. For example, BM, Queen and King use it as a side weapon and have other abilities too. Thats what makes you swordsman or not.

That bullshit you wrote about blunt attacks or not is total crap too but thats somehthing too low
 
what you consider a blunt a attack or slicing attack doesnt make you a swordsman or not LOL. Rocks is a swordsman and his slashes are like air canon now what ?. A swordsman is if he uses his sword as main or only arsenal of weapon or not. Thats all: Mihawk, Shanks, Roger,Rayleigh, Rocks, Zoro are using it as the only way to attack. For example, BM, Queen and King use it as a side weapon and have other abilities too. Thats what makes you swordsman or not.

That bullshit you wrote about blunt attacks or not is total crap too but thats somehthing too low
Just wielding a Sword doesn't make you a Swordsman..
 
Just wielding a Sword doesn't make you a Swordsman..
Just wiedling a sword doesnt make a swordsman is for BM or King. Roger is a swordsman due him only channeling his attacks with sword if the attack is blunt, slcing like an air canon doesnt change the fact. Mihawk would become an emperor himself if he would be the commander of the Cross Guild instead of Buggy. That guy is emperor level. So stop trying excuses he is a bit stronger than Shanks, he doesnt have crew who back him up.
 
Just wiedling a sword doesnt make a swordsman is for BM or King. Roger is a swordsman due him only channeling his attacks with sword if the attack is blunt, slcing like an air canon doesnt change the fact. Mihawk would become an emperor himself if he would be the commander of the Cross Guild instead of Buggy. That guy is emperor level. So stop trying excuses he is a bit stronger than Shanks, he doesnt have crew who back him up.
Actually Big Mom is more of Swordsman than Roger, she's willing to cut down people with her Blade Napoleon.. Roger doesn't cut only blunt damage.. How is he a Swordsman.. He's a Sword user..




As i said several times and keep saying which can't be refuted.. What is the core purpose of a Gun?.. To shoot or fire Bullets from it, if you never do and only use the Gun to pistol Whip your opponents, then you're not a Gunslinger.. Same logic applies to Blades and cutting..
 
No it's not.. just because you give your opinion doesn't mean objectivity turns into subjectivity...

You got cooked..
What's objective.. That the core base fundamental of Swords, Swordsmanship, Sword duels, whether it's in manga or reality, it's to cut down people.. If a Sword user is not able to do that rudimentary requirement how is he a Swordman..

Just Wielding a Sword doesn't make you a Swordsman..
 
Actually Big Mom is more of Swordsman than Roger, she's willing to cut down people with her Blade Napoleon.. Roger doesn't cut only blunt damage.. How is he a Swordsman.. He's a Sword user..




As i said several times and keep saying which can't be refuted.. What is the core purpose of a Gun?.. To shoot or fire Bullets from it, if you never do and only use the Gun to pistol Whip your opponents, then you're not a Gunslinger.. Same logic applies to Blades and cutting..
Is here anything that implies, that it's about blunt and cutting or about technique and non-technique ?.
I think you dont understand that blades actually cut. He wields a sharp sword, so he cuts a man. This is getting interesting. It's about how you wield it, not about cutting and blunting. That's something only you can come up with. Don't send more panels or you will get embarrassed. Also, Rogers' attacks are cutting, but Garp, Oden and Imu simply defend against it. Your interpretation skill is way low off the charts. I don't know how you can communicate with other people, you dont have the minimum skill to understand simply things. Also Rocks attacks are like air canon he is still a swordsman. Law is also a swordsman. BM is a part-time-swordsmann she uses her fists and homies too. Roger only wields a sword. That makes him a swordsman.
 
What's objective.. That the core base fundamental of Swords, Swordsmanship, Sword duels, whether it's in manga or reality, it's to cut down people.. If a Sword user is not able to do that rudimentary requirement how is he a Swordman..

Just Wielding a Sword doesn't make you a Swordsman..
Zoro used the blunt side of the sword here:

Is he not a swordsman?
Edit: Here's another panel
 
Zoro used the blunt side of the sword here:

Is he not a swordsman?
We also see that divine derparture is a cutting technique when he uses it against Oden and Shanks uses against Kid also Roger uses against Imu that guy is really doing it A.) on purpose to generate a click-bait or B.) he really believes what he wrote here.
 
Last edited:
What's objective.. That the core base fundamental of Swords, Swordsmanship, Sword duels, whether it's in manga or reality, it's to cut down people.. If a Sword user is not able to do that rudimentary requirement how is he a Swordman..

Just Wielding a Sword doesn't make you a Swordsman..
lil bro speaking in yapanese...

You're just repeating what you said..

When I already addressed it...

And you failed to provide an adequate response...
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
The main argument here is:
Zoro's fighting style involves cut attacks.
Roger's fighting style involves blunt attacks.

Suddenly, you bring up an isolated scene from 1000 chapters ago where Zoro seems to have used wind to try and refute the fact that Zoro's fighting style involves cutting attacks lmao
Rogers strongest attack cut rocks.
 
There were several shockwave blasts.

Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Oden.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack WB.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Garp.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Imu.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Xebec from behind

His final finishing attack was similar to Garp's: several shots of CoC. That doesn't look like a slashing attack at all, you guys have been brainwashed

The damage control is enormous, yours even want to remodel Roger's fighting style to fit the criteria for calling him a swordsman lmao
That's never going to happen, man, relax.
Post automatically merged:

No it hasnt. Hes sliced him. Theres no argument.
@Erkan12 Come take care of your whore.
 
Last edited:

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
There were several shockwave blasts.

Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Oden.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack WB.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Garp.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Imu.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Xebec from behind

His final finishing attack was similar to Garp's: several shots of CoC. That doesn't look like a slashing attack at all, you guys have been brainwashed, Zoro!

The damage control is enormous, yours even want to remodel Roger's fighting style to fit the criteria for calling him a swordsman lmao
That's never going to happen, man, relax.
Post automatically merged:



@Erkan12 Come take care of your whore.
Mr air bar tryna lecture anyone else is hilarious.
 
There were several shockwave blasts.

Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Oden.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack WB.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Garp.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Imu.
Roger used CoC shockwaves to attack Xebec from behind

His final finishing attack was similar to Garp's: several shots of CoC. That doesn't look like a slashing attack at all, you guys have been brainwashed

The damage control is enormous, yours even want to remodel Roger's fighting style to fit the criteria for calling him a swordsman lmao
That's never going to happen, man, relax.
Post automatically merged:



@Erkan12 Come take care of your whore.
He didnt they just defended against it so they dont get cut in half actually rocks was cut in the last attack full of crap
 
Top