Who will be the next SH?


  • Total voters
    159

Kizaruber Eats

IMU = I M Usopp
This person doesn't know what iambic pentameter is. A Japanese manga author would not use a rhythm pattern tied to English poetry. These languages work on two distinct sound principles/systems.
:lawsigh:
Oh I posted in the wrong thread lmao. And yeah exactly! I was wondering WTF he was talking about, like he's trying to throw out random pseudo intellectual buzzwords as baseless praise to sound likes he's doing some incredible, groundbreaking, compelling praise and analysis of the series.

Well said, his "logic" is so nonsensical but he probably expects most people to take what he says as gospel at face value and not question or criticise it, never mind call him out too.
 

Mr. Reloaded

🎶 Do what you want cause a pirate is free 🎶
Remember than Roger, Rayleigh and Gaban were equals. Which by default means Kid, Killer and Heat are all equals. Thus Kid and Killer's feats automatically go to Heat logically speaking.

Therefore
Kid = Killer = Heat > Loki = Wire = Oden

And the same can be applied to Law's crew.
Law beat a Yonko too

and Bepo nearly defeated the final villain


Therefore Bepo's feats become Sachi's feats. And Blackbeard > Loki

So Law = Bepo = Sachi

Kid
Law
Killer
Bepo
Heat
Sachi

That's 6 people who scale above Loki right there @DarkestKnightofSpoilers :doakes_suss:
 
Remember than Roger, Rayleigh and Gaban were equals. Which by default means Kid, Killer and Heat are all equals. Thus Kid and Killer's feats automatically go to Heat logically speaking.

Therefore
Kid = Killer = Heat > Loki = Wire = Oden

And the same can be applied to Law's crew.
Law beat a Yonko too

and Bepo nearly defeated the final villain


Therefore Bepo's feats become Sachi's feats. And Blackbeard > Loki

So Law = Bepo = Sachi

Kid
Law
Killer
Bepo
Heat
Sachi

That's 6 people who scale above Loki right there @DarkestKnightofSpoilers :doakes_suss:
Whats blud waffling about :AlexChills:
 

Mr. Reloaded

🎶 Do what you want cause a pirate is free 🎶
PK crew has not the same structure as other crews,
Kid and Law were in the running tho therefore you can scale them the same. :Haku_Shovel:
And why low and lidd have no wings but a solitary chicken tender :josad:
I just told you their wings :Hara_What:

Although Penguin and Sachi are literally the same character, so either or could work lol
 
How about they just take Ragnir and force him into indentured servitude?. He spends the rest of his days running on a giant hamster wheel, producing clean, renewable, kinetic energy to power the Sunny. Maybe have like a................a massive acorn just hanging inches from his reach. I mean the rodent already produces lightning and Ice, we got our electric energy and if the Sunny gets too hot they got an AC.
:goquad:
 
Now that Brook is blocking advanced CoC attacks from Imu, can we finally admit that powerscaling is stupid and we don't really know what level Loki is at yet?
Brook’s feat can be chalked up to a nothing burger, Loki’s powerlevel is concrete and consistent.

Posted this in another thread, I’ll leave this here as well.

The narrative actually depicts Loki as a stronger threat than Harald. The buildup and conclusion of the incident makes that very straightforward.

Buildup:
  • The df is essential for Xebec’s plans, and it’s mentioned as a world-ending threat multiple times. Harald strongly believes that only Loki with the df can stop him. A power hungry HK Harald also wanted the fruit for himself, it’s that powerful.
  • Loki is then established as a special ancient giant, born from Harald. He was doing Kaido-level feats as a newborn, and taking Xebec’s aCoC attacks as a preschooler.
  • Loki tamed Ragnir after Harald made it clear that it was nearly impossible, even for his usual self.
  • Shanks and Gaban were completely unable to deal with Harald.
Conclusion that solidifies Loki’s feat:
  • Later, both Imu and Gaban stated that Harald should have been unstoppable, and Imu outright shut down his plans for decades because of this newborn threat.

Loki is the version of Harald that Xebec wanted to team up with in order to defeat Imu. Scratch that, he’s actually the big upgrade. He‘s way more special than Harald as evident from his eyes and growth rate. Has hyped up strength since birth, and already managed to tame Ragnir as a 16-year-old in giant years.
 
Brook’s feat can be chalked up to a nothing burger, Loki’s powerlevel is concrete and consistent.

Posted this in another thread, I’ll leave this here as well.

The narrative actually depicts Loki as a stronger threat than Harald. The buildup and conclusion of the incident makes that very straightforward.

Buildup:
  • The df is essential for Xebec’s plans, and it’s mentioned as a world-ending threat multiple times. Harald strongly believes that only Loki with the df can stop him. A power hungry HK Harald also wanted the fruit for himself, it’s that powerful.
  • Loki is then established as a special ancient giant, born from Harald. He was doing Kaido-level feats as a newborn, and taking Xebec’s aCoC attacks as a preschooler.
  • Loki tamed Ragnir after Harald made it clear that it was nearly impossible, even for his usual self.
  • Shanks and Gaban were completely unable to deal with Harald.
Conclusion that solidifies Loki’s feat:
  • Later, both Imu and Gaban stated that Harald should have been unstoppable, and Imu outright shut down his plans for decades because of this newborn threat.

Loki is the version of Harald that Xebec wanted to team up with in order to defeat Imu. Scratch that, he’s actually the big upgrade. He‘s way more special than Harald as evident from his eyes and growth rate. Has hyped up strength since birth, and already managed to tame Ragnir as a 16-year-old in giant years.
This ^^
This isn't at all like Vista clashing with Mihawk.
 
Out of all of the possibilities I would’ve liked for Carrot to have joined as the lookout. I thought she fit in really well with the crew. I think her returning to Zou to rule it is stupid and feels like a square peg forced into a round hole.

Yamato would’ve been good cause she has CoC and the Straw Hat crew can’t survive with just Luffy and Zoro having it. I know Sanji will get it purely due to plot armor, but Yamato having CoC feels less forced than Sanji the cook having it.

Loki seems like he’d fit in well, but his size is a major issue that I don’t see them overcoming.

Vivi fits in great with the crew but is so weak that she makes Usopp look powerful, so I don’t think she works or deserves to be on the crew.

With Carrot and Yamato being committed to serving their home countries, I don’t see a good legitimate candidate to join the crew.
 
Last edited:
Top