OK I did an ISO of bittersweet and I think I scum lean them
1. The guy made multiple posts that could have been written on both factions, interacting with people not to solve but to just chatter with them
2. I think he's not really investing in his reads, I saw a few posts where he says "okay X could be scum, but actually I don't know, could be town", like, it's quite a safe approach - I don't think someone might be pressurized from this
I try but I suck at day one solving. I tried the activity route because of track records here but it's a poor methodology for solving. I could concur with people's reads on Watson, it seems a slow start and sort of lukewarm, but that could be from external factors too. I feel more confident that I could slide Shuijing up to town though after reading some more of their posts since i went to bed last night.
3. this indie list this early ticks me off - I think it's weird to put 3 indie candidates this early (how do you search for them?) and imo scum likes to focus on indie hunting in the thread because that's legit what they don't have TMI on?
I want to slot Alexis as town, so far. His meta for scum the last game I played with him was to be absent most of the phase, a clear difference from his usual town games where he's very vocal.
Town:
Alexis
Not sure on Shu, they played a really good game as a scum teammate in the Naruto game of Ekko's. Slot them NAI for the moment. Probably could slot Naomi and Hayumi there too. Never been a good reader of Hayumi, they're a good player.
Indie:
Shuijing
Naomi
Hayumi