Chapter Discussion Shamrock chapter reveal is extremely important according to Oda himself.

#21
prolly related to their mom
The idea that Shamrock has endgame relevance is a misunderstanding and even if it wasn't, his mom has nothing to do with chapter 1137.

The chapter itself divulges some of this Giant history and Shamrock declares the conquest of Elbaf to be one of the most important conflicts
 
#23
The idea that Shamrock has endgame relevance is a misunderstanding
he was in the endgame 12 panel...

and even if it wasn't, his mom has nothing to do with chapter 1137.
yeah oda just silhouetted her for no reason even tho he revealed BB's mom in the same chapter...
Not to mention Garling actually marrying her. From what we know of garling, he is not someone who marries a random nobody.

She was from an island of Davys and Ds. She is the one who gave shank his iconic unique red hair. The only hair that oda uses special tone for.

The chapter itself divulges some of this Giant history and Shamrock declares the conquest of Elbaf to be one of the most important conflicts
That chapter is not the one where they declared war with elfab. The declaration of war came after sham went back.

That chapter is important because of shamrock being revealed.
 
#26
he was in the endgame 12 panel...


yeah oda just silhouetted her for no reason even tho he revealed BB's mom in the same chapter...
Not to mention Garling actually marrying her. From what we know of garling, he is not someone who marries a random nobody.

She was from an island of Davys and Ds. She is the one who gave shank his iconic unique red hair. The only hair that oda uses special tone for.


That chapter is not the one where they declared war with elfab. The declaration of war came after sham went back.

That chapter is important because of shamrock being revealed.
He was likely in the large splash you're referring to, and top 12 well... how many antagonists do you think are left?

The mother was not featured by silhouette in chapter 1137. You're conflating things. "Introducing Shamrock" is the chapter where we get info dumps about the history of the Giants, and if you want to say Shamrock himself is relevant then all you can point to besides his physical appearance is what he says: the seas belonged to them. Now we know specifically that "Elbaf is the D" and this ties into many earlier hints. As time goes on it will tie into many of the greatest mysteries. Shanks having an evil twin is not, itself, relevant to Roger and the history of the world.
 
#27
yeah oda just silhouetted her for no reason even tho he revealed BB's mom in the same chapter...
Not to mention Garling actually marrying her. From what we know of garling, he is not someone who marries a random nobody.
It might be the opposite and shanks mom actually isn’t important in the grand scheme of things. Why hide her face unless it’s a setup for a shanks flashback and even then what would that even do?
It’s speculation that him and teach are both part of the Davy clan but shanks mom face wouldn’t reveal much if anything she doesn’t even resemble a Davy.
The only shock value it would severe is her probably having imu eyes or something I can’t think of an important reason of silhouetting her face unless she resembles some character we’ve seen besides shanks and shamrock.
 
#28
I mean, there's an 80% chance her face wasn't shown because it wasn't worth the effort to even draw. Moms in One Piece scale between NPC and plot device, where Oda is unlikely to ever back fill. Once they carry the child into the plot and die, that's it.
 
#34
It might be the opposite and shanks mom actually isn’t important in the grand scheme of things. Why hide her face unless it’s a setup for a shanks flashback and even then what would that even do?
It’s speculation that him and teach are both part of the Davy clan but shanks mom face wouldn’t reveal much if anything she doesn’t even resemble a Davy.
The only shock value it would severe is her probably having imu eyes or something I can’t think of an important reason of silhouetting her face unless she resembles some character we’ve seen besides shanks and shamrock.
Tbh What do we gain with her Face?purpose was Shanks Story And presenting cruelty of garling
 
#38
Maybe the hint was that Imu and Joyboy are also related and lived the same thing as Shanks and Shamrock. Separated at birth and developped different values.
I wonder how Davy jones ties into all this

Imu and joyboy being brothers makes sense now that I look at it that way since Joyboy since wanted to be King.

What is weird tho is that imu abilities seem to not be brought up at laughtale and even rocks didn’t know what they where.
 
#39
I wonder how Davy jones ties into all this

Imu and joyboy being brothers makes sense now that I look at it that way since Joyboy since wanted to be King.

What is weird tho is that imu abilities seem to not be brought up at laughtale and even rocks didn’t know what they where.
Nah Joyboy has to do with d clan
 
#40
There’s absolutely nothing gained from seeing her face,she was unimportant
Well there is one card available: the clown nose reveal. It's probably still a cloud over the flashbacks lol
Maybe the hint was that Imu and Joyboy are also related and lived the same thing as Shanks and Shamrock. Separated at birth and developped different values.
That has nothing to do with the chapter though. He clearly gave Fukuda a hint and allowed him to relay it as a teaser. For all of Oda's weaknesses I don't think he's going out of his way to make such a tenuous connection.
 
Top