Controversial Whats your top 5 headcanons

Yoho

I'm Quite Dandy
#1
Good Morrow my fellow Worst Degenerates Yoho here to prose to you yet another question what is your Top 5 theories or head canons ?

I'll share mine from least to most likely to be true

5- Morgans Is The Man Marked By Flames- we've never seen his Human form he's always in devil fruit form, and he's alwaya on the move now Shiryu theorized that the man marked by flames works for the world government and it's said he rides around in an all black ship, and he sinks ships with mysterious whirl pool abilities, thats all good n dandy but who better to spread rumors and lies then the guy who runs the biggest news company in the world a man who is known to twist the truth in order to entertain.

4. Nami is the daughter of a holy knight- Over the years I've seen lots of theories about Nami's origins everything from daughter of a powerful pirate to princess of a kingdom i've even seen claims she may be a celestial dragon but what if shes the daughter of a holy knight? We know the hunting games apparently happen every 3 years and the first known one was 38 years ago which means if we do the math the day Nami's village was attacked would of been a hunting festival year we know the wg loves to manipulate the truth it wouldn't be hard to report that pirates attacked Namis home of OYKOT when in reality it was Holy Knights in a hunting game and muxh like Shanks she to was found and taken in as a baby

3- Usopp Will Be The Next Conqueror- People will call me a mad man but conquerors isnt just about strength it's will power its someone who is willing and ready to stand above their peers l while Usopp may be weak and he may be scared half the time he's no coward, fear and cowardice are two different things Usopp is the man who dueled his captain over a boat, usopp is the man who has constantly challenged people way outta his league even most recently he shit talked Imu to the point imu personally arrived on Elbaf and it will be the final sign that he has officially become a brave warrior of the sea.

2- Koby Defeats Black Beard- I've been preaching this for a while now and most call me crazy but Koby beating black beard would be the perfect ending for his journey and prove to the readers that he's on that level, fans think Luffy has to defeat Black Beard and then turn around and beat Imu or vice versa but no unless you want two of the biggest villains in one piece to have rushed defeats that's filled with ass pulls, bad back stories and random power ups I wouldn't recommend that option instead who better to take down the black beard pirates then an unlikely alliance Sword(Fujitora, Sengoku and Tsuru) tagging along Remnants of big mom pirates lead by Katakuri, Law and Bepo will come rescue their crew i think thats enough fire power to take on the black beard pirates and it'll cement Koby's legacy i wouldn't want an ending where koby never really amounts to anything.


1. Robin is Luffys older half sister- Dragon had a connection to Ohara before it was ever destroyed, I believe that connection was Nico Olivia and Nico Robin whenever Robin was sent to tequila wolf it just coincidentally happened right around when the revs where planning to attack, now every straw hat was sent by Kuma to a place where he felt was best for them to go to grow stronger but why Send Robin to the revolutionaries? And why was she called the light of the revolutionary? People will say its because she can read the Poneglyphs and Ohara was the straw that broke the camels back for dragon but I think its because shes dragons daughter and he's been trying to find her all these years


There we go my top 5 head canons
 
#3
-Vice Admiral Maynard has captured Barto and Law, and Akainu is plannning their execution right now

-Kid woke up on Pirate Island and entered an alliance with Blackbeard, to take down Shanks, they will soon sail to Elbaf

-Caribou is not a Blackbeard fan, he lied. He is actually possessed by Ochoku (his father), who was a Holy Knight

-Sommers will kill Kuma, Usopp will eat the Pawfruit

-Chopper will defeat Pizarro, Doc Q will lose to Brook

I have more but I had to limit myself to 5
 
#5
Luffy will try to recruit smoker to join the crew after their final fight. The white hunter vs white hair luffy. Plus all the connection between Roger and Garp. Essentially luffy will surpass Roger because he got one of his marine rivals to join.

Usopp will die because his dream doesn't need him to be alived to be true but add more merit to it.

Tashigi and Kuina are cousins.

Tashigi will get Wado from Zoro, one way or another if you catch my drift.
 
#6
I'm not sure about my top 5, but I'll list some in the order I posted them:

- The Grim Reaper that Zoro saw might be a Klabautermann-like spirit, but for blades. [Posts 1, 2, & 3]

- Shamrock is Bonney's biological father. [Posts 1 & 2]

- Shiryu's blade will consume the Garuda Mythical Zoan. [Posts 1 & 2]

- Teach will liberate Davy D. Jones from the deep sea using the Yami Yami no Mi. [Posts 1 & 2]

- Pizarro will control the statues of Mary Geoise. [Posts 1 & 2]

- Luffy's 'shishishishi' laugh and its potential tie-ins. [Posts 1, 2, & 3]

- A potential telekinetic power-up for Usopp. [Posts 1, 2, & 3]

- Burn Scar is either a former Devoted Blade of God or a Knight of God. [Post 1]

- The Knights of God will recruit the Vinsmoke Family. [Post 1]

- The Heaven World of Elbaph has another god. [Posts 1 & 2]
 
#7
(1) The Man marked by flames have the Kraken Kraken fruit (that explain the whirpools). (2) It will be a battle royal between the SH, some member of BB pirates and Cross Guild against this man for that last poneglyph. (3) he is the man with the eye patch, and will resemble a true pirate with a wooden leg, pirate hat and cloth. (4) He challenge Imu and the world gov at some point, but something happened that Imu leave him with those scars, then he stole the last poneglyph. (5) His name is Davy Jones.
 
#9
Everyone is human- the fishmen, giants, long arms, etc aren't natural evolution but normal humans modified themselves a long long time ago and no one remembers. Now the WG is built on the celestials being above humans and the different "tribes" being below humans, but the truth is everyone is human and shares the same blood, from minks to sky people, and this will probably be important to the conflict in the void century. And that "they will never meet again" stuff speaks about humanity in general becoming more and more divided
 
#10
1) Sanji is a lunarian/human hybrid

2) Garling and Blackbeard are working together to overthrow Imu

3) After Sanji defeated Queen, he told Franky where to find Queen's severed arm with the laser technology. There, Franky also found the half destroyed RS canister and he is currently working on a RS 2.0

4) Vinsmoke Romeo is real

5) The last RPG is on the Moon, which is accessible from Elbaf Heaven realm
 
#11
1) Sanji is a lunarian/human hybrid

2) Garling and Blackbeard are working together to overthrow Imu

3) After Sanji defeated Queen, he told Franky where to find Queen's severed arm with the laser technology. There, Franky also found the half destroyed RS canister and he is currently working on a RS 2.0

4) Vinsmoke Romeo is real

5) The last RPG is on the Moon, which is accessible from Elbaf Heaven realm
I think all of these are true except the second one
 
#12
Everyone is human- the fishmen, giants, long arms, etc aren't natural evolution but normal humans modified themselves a long long time ago and no one remembers. Now the WG is built on the celestials being above humans and the different "tribes" being below humans, but the truth is everyone is human and shares the same blood, from minks to sky people, and this will probably be important to the conflict in the void century. And that "they will never meet again" stuff speaks about humanity in general becoming more and more divided
:perocry:So touching
 
#13
1. Shamrock is Bonney's father
2. Tritoma is Luffy's mother
3. Kuma will join the crew
4. Luffy has 4 more fights, not counting whatever this is for Imu in Elbaph. Sakazuki, Shamrock, Teach and Imu.
5. There are exactly 4 more locations we'll be seeing in the series. Law's original destination, Lodestar, Laugh Tale and Mariejoa.
 
#15
As Bonney's father? Male Bonney is drawn very similar to Shanks/Shamrock. The timeline also fits given it happens after Shanks leaves the HKs (he probably would have saved her). Thats basically it, theres really nothing else to go on lol

As a fight imo its because Shamrock exists purely as an excuse for Luffy to fight Shanks without actually fighting him lol. Not convinced Loki is relevant in that affair tbh because he harbors zero personal connection Shanks while Luffy does.
 
Last edited:
#16
1. Shamrock is Bonney's father
2. Tritoma is Luffy's mother
3. Kuma will join the crew
4. Luffy has 4 more fights, not counting whatever this is for Imu in Elbaph. Sakazuki, Shamrock, Teach and Imu.
5. There are exactly 4 more locations we'll be seeing in the series. Law's original destination, Lodestar, Laugh Tale and Mariejoa.
Ginny is too good of a character to waste making a pivotal battle around the melodrama of making shanks brother her goddamn rapist bruh. Sorry I dont mean to be rude but i cant think of a way to ruin ginney's story than to focus on the nitty gritty of like "who raped her? We need an epic double page spread of him getting hit with bajrang gun" thats crazy lol that would be the worst vibes ever. The very example of why people complain about rape as a plot device.

for all the complaints about kuma/ginney having very sad backstory imo it is kept in the bounds of respectability entirely because it doesn't focus at all on the "evil real dad" and excessively dwell on the trauma ginney endured from him, but treats both her and kuma as explicitly heroic figures both willing to sacrifice their lives for love of their child and focuses on their heroism at the end. Especially now that egghead left the two of them in a happy state it would be so cheap to throw some guy walking in and telling a 12 year old he did monstrous things to her mother

I actually think tritoma is luffys mom tho
 
#17
As Bonney's father? Male Bonney is drawn very similar to Shanks/Shamrock. The timeline also fits given it happens after Shanks leaves the HKs (he probably would have saved her). Thats basically it, theres really nothing else to go on lol

As a fight imo its because Shamrock exists purely as an excuse for Luffy to fight Shanks without actually fighting him lol. Not convinced Loki is relevant in that affair tbh because he harbors zero personal connection Shanks while Luffy does.
No the father thing is incredibly obvious. I meant the fight thing.
I think Sabo should fight Shamrock though. Or Teach kills him and eats the Cerberus fruit, but that'd be weird since I also think Teach will kill Imu, not sure if Oda would have him do both and especially take both of their fruits. He has to get only 3 fruits.
 
#20
Ginny is too good of a character to waste making a pivotal battle around the melodrama of making shanks brother her goddamn rapist bruh. Sorry I dont mean to be rude but i cant think of a way to ruin ginney's story than to focus on the nitty gritty of like "who raped her? We need an epic double page spread of him getting hit with bajrang gun" thats crazy lol that would be the worst vibes ever. The very example of why people complain about rape as a plot device.

for all the complaints about kuma/ginney having very sad backstory imo it is kept in the bounds of respectability entirely because it doesn't focus at all on the "evil real dad" and excessively dwell on the trauma ginney endured from him, but treats both her and kuma as explicitly heroic figures both willing to sacrifice their lives for love of their child and focuses on their heroism at the end. Especially now that egghead left the two of them in a happy state it would be so cheap to throw some guy walking in and telling a 12 year old he did monstrous things to her mother

I actually think tritoma is luffys mom tho
I think you misunderstand me, I dont think itll be ever addressed as a plot point. Its kind of like Viola and Doflamingo having an implied romantic (forced?) relationship that Oda actually confirms in an SBS. You are right in that its way too adult for a shonen to address but IMO it is the implication.
 
Top