The Brook and Gunko flashback is a textbook example of bad writing: instead of Brook processing his own generational grief or achieving personal growth, the flashback serves as a narrative pipeline to establish Gunko as the mechanical key to stopping Imu's possession or reversing the plot conflict.
Oda is now constantly substituting plot mechanics for genuine human emotion.
The Brook and Gunko flashback perfectly exposes how the manga’s priorities have warped:
1. Flashbacks as Manuals, Not Motives
Pre-timeskip, flashbacks were used to build the soul of a character.
2. The Loss of Character Agency
When a character's history is weaponized purely for plot utility, the character ceases to be an individual and becomes a tool. Instead of Brook using his 90+ years of life experience, his unique musical abilities, or his underworld soul powers to actively overcome a challenge in Elbaf, the narrative says: "Brook is relevant here only because he happens to know the living plot device (Gunko) who will do the heavy lifting."
3. Gunko is just a Piano in the Bushes
For anyone unfamiliar with the expression, it describes a clumsy, incredibly artificial plot device where an author needs a highly specific solution to a problem, so they suddenly manifest it out of thin air, acting as if it were totally natural, like a host randomly finding a fully tuned grand piano sitting perfectly hidden in a random patch of forest bushes. This flashback is basically the story of how some people randomly left a Piano in the Bushes.
So yes, this flashback is not making Brook a better character than Usopp, or even developing Brook as a character. All this just for one thing:
The crew remains sidelined as a visual gag, while a convenient plot device will solve the immediate conflict against Imu. Luffy will get his chance to push back Imu into Marijoise. The Giants of Elbaf will spend the entire arc bowing to Luffy, further cementing his "Chosen One" status while ignoring the rest of the crew completely. Usopp’s decades-long dream will be reduced to nothing.
Which is more fun, Brook will also remain the same. This is not about Brook's development.
Oda is now constantly substituting plot mechanics for genuine human emotion.
The Brook and Gunko flashback perfectly exposes how the manga’s priorities have warped:
1. Flashbacks as Manuals, Not Motives
Pre-timeskip, flashbacks were used to build the soul of a character.
- The Past: Chopper’s backstory with Hiriluk, or Brook’s original tragedy with the Rumbar Pirates, existed to explain why they think the way they do, why they hold their values, and why they are willing to die for Luffy.
- The Present: Today, the flashback isn't there to deepen Brook’s character or give him a fresh perspective on his isolation. It is being used like an instructional manual. It exists solely to introduce Gunko, explain her specific ancient power or relationship to Imu's possession, and lay down the exact tracks for how a future plot hole will be solved.
2. The Loss of Character Agency
When a character's history is weaponized purely for plot utility, the character ceases to be an individual and becomes a tool. Instead of Brook using his 90+ years of life experience, his unique musical abilities, or his underworld soul powers to actively overcome a challenge in Elbaf, the narrative says: "Brook is relevant here only because he happens to know the living plot device (Gunko) who will do the heavy lifting."
3. Gunko is just a Piano in the Bushes
For anyone unfamiliar with the expression, it describes a clumsy, incredibly artificial plot device where an author needs a highly specific solution to a problem, so they suddenly manifest it out of thin air, acting as if it were totally natural, like a host randomly finding a fully tuned grand piano sitting perfectly hidden in a random patch of forest bushes. This flashback is basically the story of how some people randomly left a Piano in the Bushes.
So yes, this flashback is not making Brook a better character than Usopp, or even developing Brook as a character. All this just for one thing:
The crew remains sidelined as a visual gag, while a convenient plot device will solve the immediate conflict against Imu. Luffy will get his chance to push back Imu into Marijoise. The Giants of Elbaf will spend the entire arc bowing to Luffy, further cementing his "Chosen One" status while ignoring the rest of the crew completely. Usopp’s decades-long dream will be reduced to nothing.
Which is more fun, Brook will also remain the same. This is not about Brook's development.
Last edited:
