Super Role Madness Game Of Thrones: A Song Of Ice and Fire

[bittersweet]

Well, a lot of the thread has seemed to be arguments around the PB heal argument. I said that I had suspicions around the role based on prior roles in other games by the host.

I suggested pressure on Orca because he was playing very wallflower.

Based on this spread of the dead,

Dead Town:
Orwellian
Yoho
Flower
Jaguar
York

Dead Scum:
Polar Bear

Unknown Dead:
Sallucion

Here's where I sit right now:

Town Leans:
Jan
Tayenne
AL sama

Null:
RippedCal
Mr. Reloaded
Alwaysmind
Charlie
GalaxyLevelShanks
SakazOuki
Michelle
Yo Tan Wa

Scum Lean:
The Orca
Crowned Witch
Worst
gingerbread
Lord Melkor

I kind of want to shift Great Potato towards more of a indie lean based off the census claim.

 

[bittersweet]

that's why you're third but I m not obligated to believe you

people can lie

Yes, I know they can. I guess you'll just have to formulate your opinion off other players then.

 

[bittersweet]

We could probably work through some of my null reads and see if anyone else agrees on any of them to apply some more pressure to?

 

[AL sama]

I kind of want to shift Great Potato towards more of a indie lean based off the census claim.

actually quite possible

 

[Tayenne]

We could probably work through some of my null reads and see if anyone else agrees on any of them to apply some more pressure to?

the list looks good to me

tbh ripped cal and mr. reloaded are interesting cases for me, I don't have deep reads on them but just based on their tone I do supect them less atm than the other people who are not participating as much, like the way they just appear and say some random things about their roles just seems funny without any agenda to me, similar to york

 

[Charlie]

hm okay btw though not all of your kids are dead yet so you still can use it

To be fair, i don't know for sure it's kids. I'll just use it on any stark adjacient claim but tbh it's hard for me to believe there won't be any fake claim among stark kids tbh. So wouldn't suprise me if ??? Is just Bran and Sansa is Cersei's fake claim or sth

 

[Crowned Witch]

@Tayenne @AL sama Could you explain why I'm in your PoEs while Melkor isn't? I don't get it.

 

[Charlie]

Has Shanks claimed yet? Only thing i remember from him was that sudden push on melkor i think.

 

[Tayenne]

@Tayenne @AL sama Could you explain why I'm in your PoEs while Melkor isn't? I don't get it.

I supect him a tiny bit less than you because it felt like to me that eod D1 mafia was comfortable with him getting lynched D1, like when the wagons were between him and Dio the thread seemed very quite and only when PB suddenly got more votes there seemed to be a shift idk
I want to see more of his reads tbh

tbh I haven't looked into you as much so far, like no isos or anyhting, because you do participate in the game it feels like at your own tempo I give you room to let me see what you are doing, I think your contributions are logical but so far nothing of it gave me a strong pull fully if you are a wolf trying to be towny or a genuine town

 

[Crowned Witch]

I have the feeling I'm only on your lists because of Ratchet's inactivity while at the same time you choose to ignore that two nights in a row abilities on Melkor have failed.

 

[Tayenne]

I have the feeling I'm only on your lists because of Ratchet's inactivity while at the same time you choose to ignore that two nights in a row abilities on Melkor have failed.

ye not being active on day 1 is defo a big disadvantage, because lowkey I always think D1 activtiy is the most important one
like even in later days backtracking d1 with new info in mind gives a ton of info usually

I am not that knowledgable about roles tbh so I don't really put my reads a lot on that, y'all probably know more than me which claims are believeable and which aren't, for example I only have seen healer so far being a town ability lmao

but if we believe orca than he jailed melkor d1 and reloaded also said he roleblocked him
on d2 we don't know if his ability didn't work since apparantly jan whom he wanted to give the ability didn't even use his ability

 

[AL sama]

@Tayenne @AL sama Could you explain why I'm in your PoEs while Melkor isn't? I don't get it.

his posts are coming off as genuine to me while all I m seeing from you is a CWAC play style

 

[AL sama]

Has Shanks claimed yet? Only thing i remember from him was that sudden push on melkor i think.

no

 

[Tayenne]

overall getting suspected and especially based on POE doesn't mean much, like everyone will get suspected at some point throughout the game
just focus on solving the game and helping town and if you are town that usually leads to avoid getting mislynched

 

[AL sama]

I have the feeling I'm only on your lists because of Ratchet's inactivity while at the same time you choose to ignore that two nights in a row abilities on Melkor have failed.

Ratchet's activity is always NAI so no

 

[Michelle]

I have the feeling I'm only on your lists because of Ratchet's inactivity while at the same time you choose to ignore that two nights in a row abilities on Melkor have failed.

Failing abilities are not solid proof.

@bittersweet how do you intend to sort your nulls?
@Tayenne why is that list good?

 

[Michelle]

Back to sleep i go

 

[Tayenne]

Failing abilities are not solid proof.

@bittersweet how do you intend to sort your nulls?
@Tayenne why is that list good?

good in the sense I can see where he would be coming from with where he is putting people, not good in the sense that I agree with him but good in the sense that I find it believable it could be his genuine perspective

 

[Charlie]

Game would be much easier if we could just solve by flavour xd like, brienne would be great fake claim for mountain, just like ludwin was for quirbyn

But it can't be that easy, right? Right?

 

[Michelle]

One more thing
There's a big possibility the D1 wagon om Polar was pure