[FNZ] Super Role Madness Game Of Thrones: A Song Of Ice and Fire

[Lord Melkor]

Day 1 claims

Flower - watcher, immune to duels, is Bran Stark = confirmed N2
Zemmi - some important town ability that can do smth vs converts/ cults or smth like that
Charlie - can save someone from lynches
Polar bear - Healer = mafia confirmed N2
Ripped cal - said his role would be beneficial for Council
Melkor - can amp actions, is Robert Baratheon

Night 1 actions claims

Zemmi - got janitored N1
Flower - watched Jan N1 -> action failed
Jan - Melkor N1 -> town (cause of redirect N1 Flower is actual -> town), protected Melkor from vote manipulation N1
Worst tracked Zemmi N1 - Zemmi visited Yoho (both are dead that night), tracking ability is 2-shots
Jaguark tracked York N1 - she targeted Flower and Polar = confirmed N2
York - Protected Flower N1, shot at worst N1, is Loras Tyrell = confirmed D2
Worst - Didn’t lose Hp N1
Jaguark - got poisoned N1
Tayenne - got poisoned N1
Melkor - amped Flower N1
Reloaded - roleblocked Melkor N1
Michelle - her money was stolen N1
SakazOuki - redirected Jan to Flower N1
Orca - Jailored Melkor N1
Yo Tan Wan - Targeted Gingerbread N1, Gingerbread chose -> protection from Night King actions

Day 2 claims

Michelle - checked census: 14 townies, 6 evils, 2 neutrals
GreatPotato - is Jon Snow, initiated Duel with York
Polar Bear - submitted action to heal Jaguark
Bittersweet - His role is tide to vote mechanics, can only vote the person his liege votes (seems like Jan is his liege)
Jan - Cop, is Ned Stark
Charlie - can save a specific character from a lynch who gets basically outed as innocent child but doesn’t know which character it is exactly, probably has some connection to his own flavour

Night 2 action claims

Mr. Reloaded - chose not to roleblock anybody
Worst - lost 1 hp at night, was possibly roleblocked, his role evolved
Tayenne - lost 1 hp at night
Yo Tan Wan - targeted Al Sama for his services
Melkor - amped Jan
Jan - didn’t investigate anyone
Orca - jailed LM and Michelle

Day 3 claims
Mr. Reloaded - is Sansa Stark, 2x roleblock, 1x give a player priority for the night
Yo Tan Wan - is 3P, wincon: has to offer to 4 players of different alignments his services, he offers protection from: redirection or poison or night king actions, can RPS his clients -> if he wins gets their gold
Worst - got by healed 1 hp
Charlie - is Caitlyn Stark, can possible save one of her kids from mislynch, no other active ability
Bittersweet - Is Brienne of Tarth, can choose a player on D1 who becomes his liege, he can only vote the same as his liege, he protects his liege from factional kills
Orca - is Bronn, X jailing, gets gold when nontowns get lynched


lemme know if something is missing

This is not my full claim.

I also have 2 vote power on even days, which i claimed.

 

[gingerbread]

Can you read his claim then and give your thoughts?

Whose? Orca's? I don't think the gold earning stuff is damning itself, like, everyone can use the shop, it's not scum only, so I assume gold gaining mechanisms aren't AI in their own?

 

[gingerbread]

Ripped cal - said his role would be beneficial for Council

Hmm, if Cal gave the Council the Night Lynch then it's towny I'd say

@RippedCal was u?

 

[gingerbread]

Bittersweet - Is Brienne of Tarth, can choose a player on D1 who becomes his liege, he can only vote the same as his liege, he protects his liege from factional kills

Is this something we can verify anyhow? I remember Jan is his liege. What happenes if you vote otherwise?

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

my child xd

 

[RippedCal]

Hmm, if Cal gave the Council the Night Lynch then it's towny I'd say

@RippedCal was u?

No

 

[The Orca]

So you could Jail two people?

N1 was you
N2 was Michelle
And its x shot, so possibly more

 

[Crowned Witch]

lol at least I seemingly was right about YTW having rolled indie again.

 

[Crowned Witch]

Vote lynch Lord Melkor

 

[Charlie]

VC4 D2

PB - 5
LM - 2
Worst - 2
Ginger - 1

Flower: LM > PB > Michelle > Ginger > Polar Bear
CW: PB
Worst: LM
Charlie: Ginger > Worst
Ginger: PB
Shanks: LM
York: PB
Michelle: Worst
Tayenne: PB​

VC5 D2

PB - 8
Jan - 3
LM - 2
Worst - 2
Orca - 1

Flower: LM > PB > Michelle > Ginger > Polar Bear
CW: PB
Worst: LM
Charlie: Ginger > Worst
Ginger: PB
Shanks: LM
York: PB
Michelle: Worst
Tayenne: PB
Saka: Jan
Cal: Jan
Jan: Orca
Potato: Polar Bear
LM: Polar Bear
Orca: Jan
Al: Polar Bear

Duel votes:

Potato: 12
York: 3

Flower: York
Worst: Potato
Ginger: Potato
Bitter: Potato
York: York
AM: York
Crowned: Potato
Saka: Potato
LM: Potato
Potato: Potato
Reloaded: Potato
Orca: Potato
Al: Potato
Jaguar: Potato
Tayenne: Potato​

Thread got so stale that maybe I'll finally do something. Crazy, i know.

So i thought, lynch cancelation had to be activated at some point. So why wouldn't Polar teammates throw a vote on him knowing it's going to avoid IT anyway.

These people being Al, Potato and Melkor it turns out. What are general thoughts on them? Impossible they're all scum but id be surprised if there's not 1 here.

At the same time, cw and ginger Polar their vote on polar early on and didn't try to pivot at all so i guess they'd be good? Like, it's not like there were no possibile pushes other than Polar and he was doomed.

 

[AL sama]

@AL sama don't be alarmed when you faxe a challenge to a game of RPS. It's simply the price asked for my aid. If you'd rather not risk your gold, let me know. I'll help you win the duel.

so that's you?? what do I get??

let me catch up first

 

[AL sama]

Why would he turn town? You think he was originally indie?

quite likely

 

[AL sama]

You have Worst as mafia or indie in that case?

mafia and we're very likely dealing with 2 mafia teams

 

[Tayenne]

Thread got so stale that maybe I'll finally do something. Crazy, i know.

So i thought, lynch cancelation had to be activated at some point. So why wouldn't Polar teammates throw a vote on him knowing it's going to avoid IT anyway.

These people being Al, Potato and Melkor it turns out. What are general thoughts on them? Impossible they're all scum but id be surprised if there's not 1 here.

At the same time, cw and ginger Polar their vote on polar early on and didn't try to pivot at all so i guess they'd be good? Like, it's not like there were no possibile pushes other than Polar and he was doomed.

I am gonna look more indepth in the tallys tomorrow I hope (got a bit sick today, hopefully it's a bit better tomorrow)

the way Potato lynched Polar EoD 1 I don't think he can be in a team with him at all, like he lynched him so suddenly and put him in danger when he could have just sit back or lynch anybody else from his long list of suspects without drawing much attention

and with the way the mafia probably already planned during n1 that they might save polar bear from the lynch d2, I think the order in which people lynched him isn't the real thing to look into but more like what reasons people gave to lynch him or even ever mentioed that they suspected him before lynching him

I also do think there is a high chance that at least 1 wold lynched PB but ye I don't think the last people to do it means automcatically they are wolfes, neither that the first ones who voted him must be townies

 

[AL sama]

I have to successfully offer services to 4 players, not all from same faction. That's my wincon.

The services offered are : Protection from
1) Redirection
2) Poison
3) Night King actions.
I am not allowed to disclose what my client choses though.​

what happens if I lose the RPS??

 

[Jan]

Wait, you're an indie? :D

Not town would have picked you.
You should expect that.

 

[gingerbread]

Dio: Zemmi > Alwaysmind > Melkor
Al: Reloaded > Flower
Saka: Reloaded > Dio
Flower: Melkor > Michelle >Dio > Bitter > Dio > Dio > Polar Bear> LM > Polar Bear
LM: Orca > Dio
Reloaded: Yoho> Yoho> Dio
Tayenne: Polar Bear > Sakazouki > Polar Bear
Jan: Melkor > Polar Bear > LM > Polar Bear
Yoho: Reloaded
Michelle: Worst
Worst: Charlie> Tayenne> LM
Cal: Jan
Orca: Dio > Melkor > Flower > Dio
Great Potato: Polar Bear
Polar Bear: Dio

Dio: Polar, Orca, Melkor, Reloaded, Saka
Polar: Flower, Jan, Tayenne, Great Potato
Melkor: Worst, Dio

Maybe not much new, but I think Polar wagon here is just probably town, I don't see purpose to bus if you have Dio there, a vote from which you can easily explain yourself from, as Dio didn't play convincingly.

I think Orca and Melkor are unpaired, as Orca was fine yeeting Melkor at one stage, effectively tying.

But I feel like if scum!Melkor was wagoned early, then there'd be more votes on Dio? Like, more incentive for the team to jump in there with votes, since there are 6 guys team. Not having to have to compromise Polar via last minute save. I think that scum movement was more comfortable not voting/voting at sides (@Charlie, jak będzie jebać głosami w bok?) when Melkor and Dio were tied, mislim was staged, no need for moves, then Polar did pannicky vote after CFD because he did not expect that.

Then I could see a scenario here also how Orca could have went to save Polar with either Melkor or Dio.

 

[gingerbread]

Not town would have picked you.
You should expect that.

Ye mfw receiving stuff after slacking d1

https://static0.srcdn.com/wordpress...o-be-sure-but-a-welcome-one-when-55157418.png

 

[Jan]

Dio: Polar, Orca, Melkor, Reloaded, Saka
Polar: Flower, Jan, Tayenne, Great Potato
Melkor: Worst, Dio

Maybe not much new, but I think Polar wagon here is just probably town, I don't see purpose to bus if you have Dio there, a vote from which you can easily explain yourself from, as Dio didn't play convincingly.

I think Orca and Melkor are unpaired, as Orca was fine yeeting Melkor at one stage, effectively tying.

But I feel like if scum!Melkor was wagoned early, then there'd be more votes on Dio? Like, more incentive for the team to jump in there with votes, since there are 6 guys team. Not having to have to compromise Polar via last minute save. I think that scum movement was more comfortable not voting/voting at sides (@Charlie, jak będzie jebać głosami w bok?) when Melkor and Dio were tied, mislim was staged, no need for moves, then Polar did pannicky vote after CFD because he did not expect that.

Then I could see a scenario here also how Orca could have went to save Polar with either Melkor or Dio.

The moment your melkor vs dio theory falls apart is when you look at general inactivity.

It is really hard to read into those eod votes when half the game barely plays the 2nd half of d1.

 

[Tayenne]

Dio: Polar, Orca, Melkor, Reloaded, Saka
Polar: Flower, Jan, Tayenne, Great Potato
Melkor: Worst, Dio

Maybe not much new, but I think Polar wagon here is just probably town, I don't see purpose to bus if you have Dio there, a vote from which you can easily explain yourself from, as Dio didn't play convincingly.

I think Orca and Melkor are unpaired, as Orca was fine yeeting Melkor at one stage, effectively tying.

But I feel like if scum!Melkor was wagoned early, then there'd be more votes on Dio? Like, more incentive for the team to jump in there with votes, since there are 6 guys team. Not having to have to compromise Polar via last minute save. I think that scum movement was more comfortable not voting/voting at sides (@Charlie, jak będzie jebać głosami w bok?) when Melkor and Dio were tied, mislim was staged, no need for moves, then Polar did pannicky vote after CFD because he did not expect that.

Then I could see a scenario here also how Orca could have went to save Polar with either Melkor or Dio.

Dio: Polar, Orca, Melkor, Reloaded, Saka
Polar: Flower, Jan, Tayenne, Great Potato
Melkor: Worst, Dio

this is not the right order btw of how people lynched, like I was technically the one that had my vote 1st on PB, then Potato 2nd and then Flower 3rd and Jan jumped in last on him as the4 th (he had his vote before that on PB but he switched at some point to Melkor)

about the others I don't fully remember who actuvally voted firts or last, need to check that
besides PB being the 5th and last person to put his vote on Dio

but ye the right order is incredible important always with lynches