Salem of Lies Throne Of Lies: The WG War

[GalaxyLevelShanks]

I agree with your assessment that he's not mafia, i'm personally leaning more towards town but i can see an arguement for indie. who is your number 1 suspect

YOU

 

[The Orca]

What you're saying is that ironically, if he's town he won't learn the lesson?

Yep lol

 

[Yoho]

Oh wait, people know if they're healed?

idk i'd assume so

 

[GalaxyLevelShanks]

tbh u might be jester or something else

I just think you're the least towny so far

I was sussing orca but he seems to be better now although I'll still keep my eyes on him

since voting is mandatory it has to be you my friend sorry

 

[Yoho]

YOU

Me?! preposterous

 

[GalaxyLevelShanks]

Me?! preposterous

It's fine you're probably safe... for now

 

[Charlie]

I'm working basically until eod. Won't be here much. Is still put him on trial, even if he's just indie tbh.

Let me know if there's cfd or sth

 

[Lord Melkor]

Oh wait, people know if they're healed?

I remember that if Physician is converted by Unseen he can make someone falsely believe he was attached and healed

 

[The Orca]

I'm working basically until eod. Won't be here much. Is still put him on trial, even if he's just indie tbh.

Let me know if there's cfd or sth

Thoughts on Saber? I'm pushing them up my suspect list

 

[GalaxyLevelShanks]

@Charlie is there still any scum suspicion on me or am I clear now

I did mess up pretty badly last night lol

 

[Charlie]

I remember that if Physician is converted by Unseen he can make someone falsely believe he was attached and healed

Oh.

I mean in this setup im basically a doctor so i guess IT can be verified

 

[Charlie]

Thoughts on Saber? I'm pushing them up my suspect list

Earlier i'd say Town but now thread is so diluted with ekko bs that it's hard to say. Maybe really weak Town. Not same tier as zemmi and naomi for sure.

@Charlie is there still any scum suspicion on me or am I clear now

I did mess up pretty badly last night lol

From Polar perhaps? I have you as null atm.

 

[Reborn]

Contrarian take but I genuinely think @EkkoLoJinx isn't mafia lol

Apart from @Reborn pressing him nicely, I haven't read a single good argument for him being mafia

The way Ekko has been talking I think he's indie

Feel like this is an obvious mislynch

Although it would be better if Ekko just claimed lol I think he's a valuable player and I don't think it's worth getting mislynched for it

Not as contraband as you might think. I think its me, Polar, and Worst with that view as well

He's likely to be not mafia here so this leaves us with two possibilities

1) he's indie - in this scenario based on his refusal to claim even the class come across as not being neutral or pro town indie. So, of he's indie then he's harmful indie.

This is the reason why zem and I even discussed him being scorned.

2)A strong town role - but even a strong town role here can claim and get town protect thus this is less likely to be the case.

 

[Reborn]

More and more I think about it, more I feel ekko can't be town or pro town indie here.

A pro town indie has no reason to deny claiming.

A town role who doesn't want to claim directly still has numerous ways to come clean

1) he can claim via whisper to any of his strong town reads

Or

2) if his role is good then he can say he can do something to self resolve later


But ekko has been very adamant about not claiming or doing anything listed above.

This can't be a town or pro town indie slot.

Could be a jester or harmful indie if not mafia

 

[Polar Bear]

I'm headed to bed, no idea how the eod goes, probably still gonna be asleep.

My 2 cents

Don't lynch yoho, he's town imo

Ekko might not be scum, probably indy, do whatever to him

Shanks can slide down some and towards town bc of his reasoning of his screw up with me

Vote lynch ali

 

[Polar Bear]

From Polar perhaps? I have you as null atm.

I slid him back to more null and not scum lean anymore

 

[Worst]

Morning​

 

[Polar Bear]

Here's the other thing....

There was so much of a non appetite last game for an ekko lynch when he was clearly scum and he never really fought or did anything

This game hea fighting back some, seems like maybe he really is not scum, maybe indy though still

 

[Polar Bear]

Morning​

Good night

 

[Worst]

More and more I think about it, more I feel ekko can't be town or pro town indie here.

A pro town indie has no reason to deny claiming.

A town role who doesn't want to claim directly still has numerous ways to come clean

1) he can claim via whisper to any of his strong town reads

Or

2) if his role is good then he can say he can do something to self resolve later


But ekko has been very adamant about not claiming or doing anything listed above.

This can't be a town or pro town indie slot.

Could be a jester or harmful indie if not mafia

Yep his refusal to claim is imho the only thing worth of notice here, not just that but his reasoning, so people " can learn " how to read and not rely on claims, but it doesn't make sense, might as well just say " f**k you I'm know claiming for any reason " I would've accepted that better

Still conflicted though