General & Others What Arc Has Hurt One Piece The Most?

Thoughts?


  • Total voters
    60
#42
Well, that's your point of view. I consider the structure of Wano to be the reason why it's so good.

So.... we in pickle, aren't we?
There's no pickle. You have shitty tastes, whereas I know quality when I see it. Pre-FMI is filled with it. After FMI, it gets thinner. Wano? Wano is the graveyard of quality, in writing, pure idea, and visuals. If Wano were a new mangaka's first arc, then the manga wouldn't reach its second.
 
#44
What is hilarious to me is that I predicted this:



.. back when Luffy was still fighting Katakuri. People do not realize just how predictible they are in their critics and rethoric. There is nothing new, what is seen as the worst in Wano, was already used as an excuse to diss on whole cake at the time, and already back then, it was based on very little to no understanding of the story.

The only difference is that Oda demonstrated the irrelevancy of these critics by making what was subtle much more visible and mostly because people took the time to analyze the story correctly.

People who read the story now without their illegitimate expectations generally understand just how beautiful these stories are. Sadly, this won't be the case of the others and again, it's mostly because 4 reasons:

- The impatience in front of a story that takes its times
- A bad reading environment
- A bad analysis of the structures, thematics and subtilities
And of course
- Illegitimate expectations.

You have shitty tastes
Sure
 
#46
It is so hard to predict that a good story that suddenly starts to be told badly will have critiques.
No, it's funny to know that critics will mostly be sparked by the same reason : illegitimate expectations.

Here. Let me give you a prediction right now that you do not yet expect:

People won't like Joyboy.

Don't ask me why, you will see :)
 
#47
The funniest thing about people who glaze post ts One Piece is that they somehow expect One Piece to be the only story to break the tradition of falling off after going on for over a decade or so
It's even funnier since I'd say it's easier for One Piece to fall off after a while because it's more repetitive than other popular stories. The majority of the arcs, while still being at least somewhat good in my opinion, follow the same exact formula every time. There's just no way that won't get old after a while
 
#49
No, it's funny to know that critics will mostly be sparked by the same reason : illegitimate expectations.

Here. Let me give you a prediction right now that you do not yet expect:

People won't like Joyboy.

Don't ask me why, you will see :)
I already don't like the fuck. Not since he took everything that made Roger interesting away.
So your expectation about other people's expectations is baseless.
 
#51
A beginning a middle and an end ?
Get to new island.
Befriend local.
Clash with henchman.
Learn why locals suffer at the hand of villain.
Lose to villain.
Flashback.
Use friendship with local as a mental boost.
Win against villain.
Something something about strawhat / Joyboy / Roger / the D.
Sail to next island.
 
#52
I already don't like the fuck. Not since he took everything that made Roger interesting away.
So your expectation about other people's expectations is baseless.
Lmao

You are making my point

You're not really this obtuse.
A separation, an ally, a conflict and a resolution ?


Get to new island.
Befriend local.
Clash with henchman.
Learn why locals suffer at the hand of villain.
Lose to villain.
Flashback.
Use friendship with local as a mental boost.
Win against villain.
Something something about strawhat / Joyboy / Roger / the D.
Sail to next island.
Why are you describing the Water Seven Saga ?
 
Top