Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1199 Spoiler Discussion Thread

Who do you prefer?


  • Total voters
    92
That’s every government to ever exist though.

Imu specifically doesnt care about the every day happenings of people. Drum Island is a great example. It has an entire monarchy replaced and the world government is fine with this, so long as they pay their tributes and they obey the overall laws.

A tyrant that governs through excessive order would not allow (probably any sub division of independent monarchy) this type of ruler change without their express approval, or would hand appoint one.
The WG also allowed Alabasta to straight up have a civil war without intervening. If you read the first few hundred chapters of OP, the WG comes off as pretty Libertarian(yeah the irony here isnt lost on me) on pretty much everything but the Void century. I wonder if thats something Oda would change if he started the story from the begining
 

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
The WG also allowed Alabasta to straight up have a civil war without intervening. If you read the first few hundred chapters of OP, the WG comes off as pretty Libertarian(yeah the irony here isnt lost on me) on pretty much everything but the Void century. I wonder if thats something Oda would change if he started the story from the begining
I mean they are a very lazy dictatorship that almost functions as a mafia rachet. The celestial dragons have no concern for governing at large and there are numerous islands not affiliated with the WG or booted out cause they can’t pay (and now subject to slavery, piracy and more).

it could be a story beat of an ever slothful government now reaping the follies it set

It could be the fact they can’t exert full control on the world due to technological limitations

but yeah they are pretty passive in most cases
 
The lightning sword and the cloud shield are basically the result of an animal creating armor out of what nature has to offer.

It's the imagination powers at work, but restricted by what a monke, primarily based on its sensory perception, would make out of it for combat.
Far in contrast to Imu, who just used a highly advanced light saber. Homo habilis vs technological advanced modern human
 
I mean they are a very lazy dictatorship that almost functions as a mafia rachet. The celestial dragons have no concern for governing at large and there are numerous islands not affiliated with the WG or booted out cause they can’t pay (and now subject to slavery, piracy and more).

it could be a story beat of an ever slothful government now reaping the follies it set

It could be the fact they can’t exert full control on the world due to technological limitations

but yeah they are pretty passive in most cases
I think its mostly because both sides in Alabasta wanted to keep their position in the WG, which I think was something that Oda could take for granted back in like 2001, but I can kind of imagine someone like Big Mom trying to win favor with rebels in a major WG country(Alabasta had like 1 million people in the capital, and is the source of all the autism about the OP planet being supersized or whatever). Its not the end of the world though, but it kind of strikes me as an early installment weirdness thing.
 

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
I think its mostly because both sides in Alabasta wanted to keep their position in the WG, which I think was something that Oda could take for granted back in like 2001, but I can kind of imagine someone like Big Mom trying to win favor with rebels in a major WG country(Alabasta had like 1 million people in the capital, and is the source of all the autism about the OP planet being supersized or whatever). Its not the end of the world though, but it kind of strikes me as an early installment weirdness thing.
I mean it's not even a new development, Kaido's homeland had to give Kaido up or they'd be stripped of their status in the WG, which makes them susceptible to more dangers.

The WG seems ready to abandon nations incapable of paying the tribute and only gets aggressive if nations are actively trying to do harm to the WG (like the 7 nations that openly rebelled in solidarity with the Revolutionary Army).
 
Top