RDR2 is classic “modern audience” slop. There are a ton of sections of the main story where the game completely robs you of control and forces you to do exactly what it wants you to do. The gameplay is slow and monotonous, the allure of the gunplay fades as soon as you realize that there is nothing more to it than just the spectacle of the violence since auto-aiming robs combat of all skill. The game is for the most part piss easy, save for a few specific pre-programmed set pieces such as Bear hunts where you can be insta killed without being able to react, because the game is poorly designed, it is less of a game and more of an interactive movie.
Nah, RDR2 is a 7/10 and that 7 is carried by the production value. These interactive movies designed so any casual with 30 minutes of couch time a day can excel at them are just trash.