Worstgen

Cinera

Until you can show the above three to be convincingly false, your 300 metres estimate is ludicrous. You are off by an entire order of magnitude.

If you figure out a way to debunk any of the above three, tag me. Otherwise, I have no interest in engaging with your thread.

comrade

Pica's finger is as thick as his head, while being 3 times as long. Luffy's G3, upon making contact with Pica's head, is displayed as being half the size of Pica's head. The same G3, upon clashing with Chinjao's head, is displayed as being of Chinjao's height, who is officially 5m tall. Pica being several km tall is ridiculous.

Cinera

@comrade Luffy's G3 does not have consistent size it varies pretty widely. The Elephant Gun that smashed Kaido's head was much bigger than the Elephant Gun that Cracker blocked.

My other points stand. Pica being mere hundreds of metres tall is ridiculous.

comrade

So you yourself admit that sizes in One Piece are inconsistent. Like Zoro wielding Oden's blade. Nevertheless, there are various other scans. Like Pica compared to the walls of Dressrosa, Pica compared to the height of the Colosseum, the fact Pica's palms are multiple times as big as his hands, etc. San Juan Wolf is 180m and already humongous, being as tall as the Marineford fortress. 300-400m is ridiculously big.

comrade

San Juan Wolf's palm is as big as a giant, and Wolf has pretty small palms compared to his body, while Pica has humongous palms, which are disproportionally large compared to the rest of his body. With his head looking like a grape compared to his melon sized hands. So him being 300-400m is reasonable. But him being kilometers tall is not.

Finalbeta

Of course sizes are inconsistent how would you even scale pixels accurately after all :P

comrade

Look at this close up of a 3 store building at Pica's torso: https://i.imgur.com/XtvcYnf.png
You really believe Pica is several kilometers tall?

Cinera

I showed you the scans that made the 3 - 4 storey buildings look tiny. Even in the scan you posted, there are multiple other buildings that look really small.

Cinera

You're just cherry picking the scans that make you look small. The walls of Dressrosa were also calculated to be much larger TBH. So while I agree that they are a bit indicative of Pica's height, I think your values are ludicrous.

Cinera

The One Piece Magazine shows that Pica is intended to be as large as Flower Hill. That's official scaling from Oda. Flower Hill being mere hundreds of metres tall is impossible.

Cinera

> So you yourself admit that sizes in One Piece are inconsistent.

@comrade: Sure, but that's not my point. I wasn't saying sizes in OP are inconsistent; I was saying that the size of Luffy's G3 actually varies pretty widely. It grows to as big as he needs it.

Cinera

Examples of G3 being ginormous:
* Destroying Noah with Elephant Gatling.
* Vs Dragon Kaido

Examples of G3 being Smaller:
* Vs Chinjao
* Vs Peros' wall
* Vs Cracker.

Cinera

Grizzly Magnum vs Pica's Golem's head is simply an instance of the former.

Cinera

Even in the scan you cherry picked to show a building appear large, there are multiple other multistorey buildings that appear tiny, but mere hundreds of metres is still not enough for them.

Cinera

The one thing that is clear is that Oda intended for the golem to be as high as Flower Hill. Flower Hill is clearly a legitimate mountain.

Cinera

Pica being 1 - 3 kilometres is reasonable.

Pica being less than 1 Kilometre is not.

Finalbeta

I am so hyped for San Juan guys, can't wait to see him in action

comrade

https://s6.mangabeast01.com/manga/One-Piece-Digital-Colored-Comics/0701-014.png
Pica is twice the size of that castle standing on the grey construct. Does that thing look Burj Khalifa size to you?

Cinera

> * Buildings over 10s of metres high look like ants on Pica.

Buildings over 10s of metres high also look like ants on the Flower Hill. Oda intended for Pica to be as tall as the Flower Hill. Something merely the height of the Burj Khalifa can't make multistorey buildings look so tiny.