Worstgen

View previous comments…
D
Dragomir
I'm deadass considering joining. Very good debate, but that's only because Kiro isn't here.
Cinera
Cinera
Cinera
Cinera
Thanks, I'll check it out.
Buusatan94
Buusatan94
Yep congratulations you have become even better since Oro Jackson.
Cinera
Cinera
@Sentinel I may have to consider revising you upwards in my tier list. :catsalute:
Sentinel
Sentinel
@Cinera Did you forget that we had wall-of-text discussions several times back in OJ? :)
Finalbeta
Finalbeta
Doffy is a respectable semi-power house :3
Cinera
Cinera
@Sentinel no I haven't forgotten, I'm just thinking of moving you from mid top tier (where I place myself and most of the other great posters) to high top tier (where I place @Light D Lamperouge and a few others).
Sentinel
Sentinel
@Cinera

Well, to be fair, you haven't seen the discussions between me and kiiro in which I mostly debunked his nonsense with huge evident wall-of-texts, especially when it comes about Snake Man and Snake Man's FS.
RayanOO
RayanOO
Haha @Cinera you have a posters tier list ?
D
Dragomir
I'm curious as to where I rank on that list.
Finalbeta
Finalbeta
I have Doffy YC1.5 so I should rank high :3
Cinera
Cinera
@RayanOO I'm working on one for arena regulars yeah.

@Dragomir I haven't placed you yet, (the early placements were largely of memory, and you joined during my second hiatus). From the few interactions I've had with you, I would say either high high tier or low top tier.
Cinera
Cinera
I am actually re(reading) some of the major threads to have a better placement of the posters on the list. I'm not going to share the list, but I would share a screenshot of the criteria I tried to keep in mind while working on it.
Cinera
Cinera
I haven't had enough time to read the threads I wanted to, so it's kind of outdated a bit, but I'll gradually work on it over the coming weeks. Would probably reevaluate a lot when the fights start.
Cinera
Cinera
@Finalbeta merely agreeing with me doesn't actually do you that big a favour. I don't think I'm some perfect arbiter of powerscaling. I have changed a lot of my powerscaling opinions (I previously thought Yonkou > Admiral, previously thought all out Dressrosa Zoro could push Fuji (and Mihawk) to at least medium difficulty, previously thought Doflamingo could push Kuzan to at least medoum difficulty...
Cinera
Cinera
I previously thought Kuzan > Sakazuki (magma has an advantage over ice), etc). I will change my mind on some of my other powerscaling opinions in future.

Placing Doffy anywhere within mid high tier (YC 3 and YC 2) is reasonable IMO. Placing him in low high tier (YC 4) isn't justifiable, and neither is placing him in high high tier (YC 1). I don't really care that you place Doffy exactly at YC 1.5.
Cinera
Cinera
I don't think Doffy is necessarily > all YC 2s either. IIRC, I have Lucky Roo and Queen above him in my tier list (but him above Jozu and Smoothie).
Top