Search results

Saying unlikely does not mean its impossible. Even you acknowledge the possibility of Yamato's role being revealed can still happen in this arc and would count as a point in Yamato's favour. You also don't know if Carrot being on the mast is because that will be Carrot's role on the ship as...

It is VERY UNFAIR to compare Yamato and Carrot in this regard as carrot has 3 arcs to get all the points. Far longer than any straw hat who joined. Plus the majority of this interaction happens on the Sunny such as when Carrot bit Luffy's ears, the only real interaction Carrot and Luffy had...

Okay, first i had to look up thematic incarnation on Google and that term doesn't even exist, you just pulled that out of your ass. Secondly, what your speaking about is something very general with few variations, that if we were to apply to the existing straw hats many would have very general...

I pretty much disagree with this whole section here. Carrot's real defining choice was going after Perospero on Wano. There she had the time and comfort to make that choice. Pedro's death can't be considered the most defining as Carrot didn't have the choice to make a difference there. If...

The Post- Roles have until the end of the arc to reveal themselves. I already told you this. If you take Carrot's early role of climbing on the Sunny as the timeframe benchmark then more than half of the crew wouldn't make the list to join. We only saw Franky's shipwright skills in his flashback...

The complete theory | Carrot For Nakama I read your blog, and here are my issues with it. Thematic incarnation- obvious the theme for Yamato is Yamato representation the importance of inherited will. That carrying the dream and wishes of Oden of opening Wano's borders, even though Oden only...

According to your website, Yamato meets all the requirements, the only thing that Yamato doesn't have is being introduced into the Wano Arc early enough. Its a point that a lot of people already told you is irrelevant and doesn't affect Yamato anyway.

So you replied. :myman: here is what your website says: Be alive Be relevant to the story Be unique and have a unique ability Be free from faction duty or independant Be a friend or a false adversary Looking and acting toward adventure Have a moral Pillar And you can see that not every...

So she has the freedom to stay by Momo's side, but she can't join the crew because she's not free, therefore Yamato loses a point. lmfao, that is some mental gymnastics. :nicagesmile: But if Yamato doesn't stay by momo's side then that point doesn't even count. :rolaugh:

I can't quote something you already deleted. But that doesn't matter anyway because you still said that Yamato is staying with Momo before in the past, and you never changed your opinion on that fact, even now.

You just said before that Yamato was not free because she was still tied to Momo you liar. So you just changed your tune again. :seriously:

:suresure: Lmfao nice joke. 1641970615 No what i meant is your not Oda you can't change the story.

I read your rules, and they only work if you wrote the story, not Oda.

If you don't believe that Marco is joining the crew then you don't need to bring him up. 1641970346 I read your points and your points don't matter. Your points don't take into account every straw who joined in the past. Without consistency your points don't mean anything.

Zoro was not free, he was literally tied up by Morgan Chopper was not free, Sakura Kingdom was still under threat from Wapol nami was not free, her village was still held hostage by Arlong Sanji was not free, he still had obligations to Zeff Brook was not free, his shadow was still in the hands...

I don't need to accept these rules because they are rules you made up on your own, they are not Oda's rules, they are not One Piece's rules, they are rules that didn't even apply to Straw Hats who joined in the past. Your rules don't mean anything.

One Piece is a manga story with a plot, it's not a RPG game. Arbitrary points don't dictate who will join the crew, its the narration of the story and the direction that characters Oda chooses to drive them towards that counts.

That HAS always been the case. One Piece is a week to week publication, once the chapters are out, Oda can't just go back to change them. Changing the decision on who joins the crew isn't something that Oda can just do on a whim. Also, how do you know Oda ever had any intention of Marco ever...

They are not must haves as not every straw hat who joined the crew followed each of those 7 rules in the first place.

How can you find the core of a potential candidate by having broad rules? Having broad rules just expands the umbrella of available pool of candidates, its the opposite of narrowing down. What this actually does is decreases the qualities requirements of a potential straw hat just to fit in a...