Search results

We don't know what predicament she was in that prevented her from leaving. Look at Bepo, left Zou at 8 years old. Inu and Neko when they were 10. And Carrot couldn't leave if she was always interested in the outside world. She stated she always wanted an adventure at sea, but as we've seen...

Please, can you make this more coherent? If you're saying she was a minor part on the destruction of Zou flashback, then yeah, because its a recollection of events, ending in the defeat of the Mink Tribe. Also, Inu and Neko stowing away, while very similar to Carrot, isn't a reason why she's...

That's only if you take Luffy's claim of them being just like Chopper on the surface level and say they are not interesting characters in their own right. Look at how he and his crew reacted after the Minks revealed they knew Raizo was on Zou this entire time and that they lied to the Beast...

That's because outside Jack, she didn't have a personal grudge against Kaido like the Dukes did. They have more history with not only him, but Wano as a whole. Just saying she feels like a side character doesn't mean she'll stay in that same position. The goal post always shifts in regards to...

It's as personal as any of the Straw Hats who are third party members in it. The main connection she has with this war is that her people were attacked by them, so by proxy, they initiated conflict with the Mink Tribe, so now they are retaliating. This is also excluding the fact that Dukes are...

Yeah, I was wrong about Carrot starting off in base and eventually going Sulong. I personally don't like she's doing this off the gate since Sulong is a double edged sword of a form, especially against an adversary like Perospero who can drag out a fight with candy. Hopefully she overcomes these...

lol this entire war is personal to her since their tribe was ransacked by members of the Beast Pirates. She's just personally remarking that in this current battle, Pedro's death was the driving force for her eventual understanding. It's not gonna happen immediately, like we said. We knew she...

Mighty presumptuous of you to think the "Dawn of the World" begins and ends in Wano.

I don't feel Tama's chances, not by a long shot. But I will say she was definitely unexpected and the highlight of the chapter. She pulled that "RKO Outta Nowhere" card.

Those are not similarities, its just that they are antithesis of one another narratively. Oda has already confirmed on a Japanese YouTube webcast that Katakuri is not a child of Kaido, so you can scrap that.

I don't see how Yamato compares to Katakuri in the slightest. He is a Pirate already with years of experience, she's not.

I'm not talking about the circumstances, it seems you didn't read what I've said before. If she had been shown earlier in this arc and had that conflict introduced sooner, there would have been a lot more payoff to Luffy learning Ryou. It was literally solved in 2 chapters. I keep telling you...

It was done with gag tears though. Also, the conflict was introduced in one chapter and resolved immediately the next. So no, she has no further character conflict that would have supposedly made her leave the island in the span of 2 chapters. That's kinda what I mean by how rushed I feel about...

Weren't you just doing that?

Till she fights Perospero and does another "one hit wonder."

Let's not resort to this. Besides, arguments against Carrot were made numerous times in Whole Cake Island before she ended up being one of the main highlights of the arc. Gotta have some level of patience.

Dude, Jinbe made a public statement on leaving the Big Mom Pirates and joining Luffy. I don't recall why you'd think Carrot's presence would warrant suspicion when Jinbe openly declared who he was declaring his service to. Something everyone could see and hear. It was pretty public, don't know...

Because he openly declared it at the tea party, in case you forgot.

But that didn't affect his bounty, which was the point of my original statement.

And basically you just confirmed that Brook, Chopper, and Nami weren't seen as a threat either. Also, Jinbe's bounty didn't go up, its always been 438 million since the timeskip started after his status as a Warlord was nullified.