Search results

:kuzanshut: Quite on the creek.

I thought he was talking about Gambit. Either way why did you get hung up on that friend, you gucci this game or evil?

Vote Lynch Gambit Leaving this to marinate

If I have to pick a side on Ratchet GTH right now I’d agree

So what sequence are you referring to then lmao? There were 5 posts form Ratchet and only two consisting of reads with one being about Yohoe and non related to the rest in the post prior.

Overall not a fan of your responses and reaction to my initial statement here though Gambit, tbc.

He had a total of 5 posts before you made your read to be clear so by definition there is no “progression” at the time you’re saying u already made this conclusion but post #170 and #172 are fine takes to start a game off so I guess that’s fine and not much more to discuss here ( although still...

Right, which is fair, but that’s not how your original statement was phrased so I can’t read your mind. “i’ll give Ratchet a small town cred for his early reads” feels a bit cut and dry. Can you point me to the specific posts where you saw some progression that you liked.

I don’t have an issue with that lol, I’m not defending him whatsoever to be clear.

It’s stupid and means nothing but I like the troll of it all lol. Melkor usually feels self conscious to me. 1 post is nothing to judge him off of but I wouldn’t say the intro struck me as that, arguable the opposite.

Agree X2 btw. Especially after Ratchet’s response felt like they just hopped on a bandwagon. The whole “building a case” thing just felt like a big reach in general as well. Perhaps an overreaction.

Is it crazy that I almost want to like Melkor’s entrance lol.

You seriously overestimate the amount of full on reading I’m doing. I opened a page at random and that was one of the first posts I seen that made me want to comment and let them know that’s not a good reason. I didn’t even fully back read to page 1 till after the fact and I still haven’t read...

Fuji is vibes, also I can’t rlly explain why but him asking directly for my read of him is more rand villagey. I can’t recall a wolf game where he did that in recent memory. That’s like not a good reason but I don’t think he’s bad so far. With Yohoe, I’m just repeating what Fooji said here, but...

I don’t have any yet, but I firmly dislike the latest two posts from Gambit

And again, I’m pushing back on Gambit’s REASONING, I’m not saying you just flat out aren’t town.

Yohoe and Fuji are town reads, any issue now? Like I said, I just started playing friend.

Yohoe seems fine, even though you weren’t asking me

Wdym it’s not right?? I’m giving you a reason for disagreeing that someone should be town read for the specific reason you outlined. I can have that opinion lol, Ratchet themself would agree it’s not AI. You don’t have to listen to me lmao, it’s not like I’ve flat out said Ratchet can’t be good...

What is the amnesiac, and why are we already hinting at roles? Is that recommend more the usual in TOS, or just Flower being Flower. I’m going to have to actually read the roles huh loll.