Search results

This interaction here, looks quite bad in hindsight, since it provided Melkor with his alibi for the first phase.

I was talking more the group as a collective, because the other four aren't revived dead towns. You and Worst are cleared mechanically. I know you have doubts on CW, but I view them as clear now too because the level of momentum that built near the end leads me to believe scum were trying to...

The group that killed off Melkor earned a lot of town points with me. Flower, Worst, Crowned Witch, GalaxyShanks, and AlwaysMind Scum keeps clearing off swathes of the board each night, but we have a lot of new intel from last phase. I think we can town clear Crowned Witch now and looking...

I've been avoidant to share my passive because it is a potentially useful tool against the scum, it's one that activates if certain conditions are met. I have found a loophole that would allow me to self-activate whenever I feel like it though, so I have that handy if the situation calls for it.

@bittersweet claimed to be a bodyguard for Jan, something he locked himself into D1, yet now Jan is night-killed but bittersweet is still alive?

CW should claim at this point. There's no gain in not doing so. Claim or it's all over.

That's true, but when I proposed Charlie nobody in the thread budged, now everyone followed. Vote Lynch Orca

I tested the water on CW lynch, but I don't like how fast it just snowballed and some of the names attached. We should experiment other directions.

Alright, then I'll see where this takes us. Vote Lynch Crowned Witch

I doubt both sides of the wagon are scum. If we get a scum flip from Melkor or Orca EoD, then I'd say step away from the other one at the council until we have another day phase for town to re-evaluate with the new information. Only if we have a town flip EoD would I be weighing lynching the...

Vote Lynch Orca

But here's another question. Does Fuji as a host create a rolesheet that requires the player to have in depth flavor knowledge of the lore of the show in order to utilize? One of the primary concerns of a host should be to make the game accessible for those who may not be familiar with the...

I meant actual reasoning, meme-posting doesn't count.

I don't think it's too unlikely there would be a Stark among the fake-claims. It seems there's too much plausible deniability built into his role for it to ever be properly tested. If ever asked to test it against an outed Stark he can just say the ability failed, it must have been the wrong...

You see, Charlie already thought ahead and added the caveat that his ability might not work even if he correctly identifies one of his children. That way we can't hold him accountable if his ability fails to protect one of her children, because it might have been one of the other kids that his...

I'm aware that you said it, and I'm also aware that it sounds like complete nonsense. Well, I'm not against flipping Orca since I'm pretty sure you are a scum team right now. Funny you mention him because you seem rather allergic to that wagon. You argued that there's no point in being part...

Vote Lynch Charlie

Now, I did not mention Charlie in my reads list because I thought he deserved his own post, because I believe there is something incredibly damning that I came across looking back at his post. Near the end of the Day Phase, Charlie basically throws a life-raft out to Polar Bear. He has a very...

Yeah, well you should understand why this is something that looks suspicious considering the timing and Polar flipping scum. You suddenly started reacting right as the plan to pivot to Polar was being discussed and Jan requested votes away from Dio.

I'm not suspicious because you I think that was a legitimate effort to lynch Flower; I'm suspicious because you appeared to use that joke vote as a smokescreen to shift your vote from Melkor to Dio out of nowhere after Jan explicitly called for moving votes away from Dio to get that Polar lynch...