Search results

  1. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    I am not backpedaling. Whitebeard wasn't Roger's rival. He was his bud. They happened to be pirates and they had friendly sparring sessions here and there. Whitebeard took his kid under his wing. There was no animosity between the two. Roger and Xebec had a clash of ideals and goals. One...
  2. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    I don't have trouble understanding that Xebec was Roger's true rival and not WB or Garp. You do have a problem tho. Luckily Sengoku is here to help you:
  3. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    Xebec, not Whitebeard bro. It's not that hard to read, exactly.
  4. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    Exactly here: Whitebeard and Garp were buds with Roger. That's not a rivalry.
  5. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    Oh no. Author's own words and panels are now copium. Gladly Oda writes OP not some irrelevant random on WG. Keep coping.
  6. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    It appears Sengoku said that Xebec was Roger's first and greatest rival not WB:noo: Maybe Whitebeard had an allergy. Not everyone takes garlic well.
  7. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    Proceeds to cry and whine about Whitebeard who is not even considered to be Roger's greates rival like Xebec is. Keep crying in the corner. Seasoning or onion. A lot of things bruv.
  8. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    What is this fucking WB cope? Are people compensating for how tragic of a tale WB post timeskip is? Oda should've never touched his character after the timeskip and maybe then it would be better for his case. That dude didn't want to go for the PK title and preferred not to fuck with WG. Both...
  9. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    No. I am saying that this panel proves Xebec was Roger's true and only rival. Time and time again it was said that Whitebeard didn't give a fuck about PK shit once and as seen in flashbacks he preferred to not fuck with the WG. Xebec and Roger's goals ultimately clashed.
  10. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    "First and perhaps his greatest". <----- About Xebec. Where does it say anything about Whitebeard? Keep coping.
  11. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    What the fuck do you mean by "tried passing off this panel"? He literally tells you that Xebec was Roger's first and true rival. Completely dismissing WB and Garp. Both of them were like sparring partners who got mutual respect for each other rather than any animosity between them. What...
  12. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    Because not fucking once Whitebeard competed for anything with Roger. WB never cared about the PK title. King of the World vs King of Pirates, the ultimate clash of ideals between Xebec and Roger. Whitebeard and Garp were like friends from the mat in the MMA club for Roger.
  13. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    Okay lmfao. You are delusional or you don't read the manga. Here: Now go away. Roger and WB were like buddies sparring, there was no animosity.
  14. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    Well, Yonko had similar bounties, some had few hundred more millions than other or not. Rivalry is not something so simple. I will trust Oda on that one with Xebec. This is not something I made up. So I think you jumped on me for wrong reason.
  15. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    He will retcon. He said it himself lmfao. Don't be bothered by this tbh. We are in for a lot of retcons, right? Even Oda said it himself. Whitebeard said that his scar aches whenever he sees Shanks. This is just a theory not something confirmed so don't feel offended by it. Why would...
  16. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    Huh? Are you dumb on purpose? LMFAO. I am speaking about canon facts not what fans fucking made up. Yonko bounties chapter. "Xebec was Roger's only true rival".
  17. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    Bro this old man says a lot of things. First and foremost. One Piece was meant to last 5 years, this is how long Oda has planned the story to be. Everything after that is stretching for $ purposes because he was pressured by Shueisha to become their golden egg. He recently said that newcomers...
  18. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    Bullcrap. Xebec was Roger's one and only rival.
  19. Seth

    Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

    I discussed this already. Even tho fans can go over the top sometimes it's better if WB stuff is retconned and Oda connects it to Figarland. It makes no sense for WB to say it in such a manner as if he had resentment towards Shanks for this. There is no reason for scar to ache since WB loved...
Top