Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

[Formerly Seth]

Where do you see the word "true" in that panel?

Where do you see the word "rival" in that panel?

Blud is really imagining shit 😂

Roger and Whitebeard were rivals, you're the only one coping lil bro.
:holdthisl:

Proceeds to cry and whine about Whitebeard who is not even considered to be Roger's greates rival like Xebec is.

Keep crying in the corner.

who is garlic

Seasoning or onion. A lot of things bruv.

 

[SkySanji]

Proceeds to cry and whine about Whitebeard who is not even considered to be Roger's greates rival like Xebec is.

Keep crying in the corner.

Seasoning or onion. A lot of things bruv.

Even if true, that's just a feat for Xebec, it doesn't change anything about Whitebeard, he's still shitstomping Admirals for example, rival or not.

Regardless, you're lying about panels that blatantly do not say what you want them to say, if anyone is crying it's you.

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

Proceeds to cry and whine about Whitebeard who is not even considered to be Roger's greates rival like Xebec is.

Keep crying in the corner.



Seasoning or onion. A lot of things bruv.

what does a seasoning have to do with wb then

 

[Formerly Seth]

Even if true, that's just a feat for Xebec, it doesn't change anything about Whitebeard, he's still shitstomping Admirals for example, rival or not.

Regardless, you're lying about panels that blatantly do not say what you want them to say, if anyone is crying it's you.

It appears Sengoku said that Xebec was Roger's first and greatest rival not WB

what does a seasoning have to do with wb then

Maybe Whitebeard had an allergy. Not everyone takes garlic well.

 

[SkySanji]

It appears Sengoku said that Xebec was Roger's first and greatest rival not WB

Maybe Whitebeard had an allergy. Not everyone takes garlic well.

Okay? And characters can have multiple rivals in different goals lol.

Whitebeard is Roger's rival, no amount of copium on your end is changing that.

 

[Formerly Seth]

Okay? And characters can have multiple rivals in different goals lol.

Whitebeard is Roger's rival, no amount of copium on your end is changing that.

Oh no. Author's own words and panels are now copium.

Gladly Oda writes OP not some irrelevant random on WG.

Keep coping.

 

[SkySanji]

Oh no. Author's own words and panels are now copium.

Gladly Oda writes OP not some irrelevant random on WG.

Keep coping.

Where does that panel say Xebec was Roger's only rival like your clown ass has been insinuating for 10+ posts?

 

[Formerly Seth]

Where does that panel say Xebec was Roger's only rival like your clown ass has been insinuating for 10+ posts?

Exactly here:

Whitebeard and Garp were buds with Roger. That's not a rivalry.

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

Exactly here:

Whitebeard and Garp were buds with Roger. That's not a rivalry.

it was a rivalry , they were familiar but it was still a rivalry
xebec was just a greater threat than wb was.
Not hard to see why

kid marco , jozu and vista arent exactly threatening

 

[SkySanji]

Exactly here:

Whitebeard and Garp were buds with Roger. That's not a rivalry.

You just can't read nine words properly, that's the problem here

 

[Formerly Seth]

You just can't read nine words properly, that's the problem here

 

[SkySanji]

Bluds spamming a panel he blatantly can't even read

 

[Formerly Seth]

Bluds spamming a panel he blatantly can't even read

Xebec, not Whitebeard bro. It's not that hard to read, exactly.

 

[SkySanji]

Xebec, not Whitebeard bro. It's not that hard to read, exactly.

You say it's not hard to read and yet have so much trouble doing exactly that

 

[Formerly Seth]

You say it's not hard to read and yet have so much trouble doing exactly that

I don't have trouble understanding that Xebec was Roger's true rival and not WB or Garp. You do have a problem tho.

Luckily Sengoku is here to help you:

 

[Reborn]

I don't see any inconsistency in Garling giving scar to WB


The way WB worded in that panel is similar to how shanks talked about getting scar from BB. WB had great respect for Roger so scar given by Roger is no big deal.


It was given by either Xebec or Garling.

Shanks has no connection with xebec but definitely has connections with Garling.


Garling gave that scar to WB during God valley incident and when WB was crew member of Xebec.

Oda simply wasn't consistent with Scars

 

[SkySanji]

I don't have trouble understanding that Xebec was Roger's true rival and not WB or Garp. You do have a problem tho.

Luckily Sengoku is here to help you:

You're backpedalling, your initial claim was that Whitebeard wasn't Roger's rival, now you're trying to argue he just wasn't as much a rival as Xebec was.

This is a hilarious performance bro, keep it going please.

 

[York]

I missed the update from Merriam Webster where it was determined that "first" is actually synonymous with "only" now

And "foe" is synonymous with "rival"

And "perhaps" is synonymous with "absolutely 100%"

 

[Formerly Seth]

You're backpedalling, your initial claim was that Whitebeard wasn't Roger's rival, now you're trying to argue he just wasn't as much a rival as Xebec was.

This is a hilarious performance bro, keep it going please.

I am not backpedaling.

Whitebeard wasn't Roger's rival. He was his bud. They happened to be pirates and they had friendly sparring sessions here and there.

Whitebeard took his kid under his wing.

There was no animosity between the two.

Roger and Xebec had a clash of ideals and goals. One more destructive than the other.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

He even drew Luffy's scar on Zoro once, and corrected it for the release of the volume

What lack of sleep does to a mf

Post automatically merged: Jun 8, 2023

Whitebeard wasn't Roger's rival. He was his bud. They happened to be pirates and they had friendly sparring sessions here and there.

Sethy, how do you define rival?