Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard
- Thread starter GoldDiamond
- Start date
During the flashback with roger, whitebeard has no scars, so him getting scarred by garling in valley can't happen unless oda retcons it
Why would garling fight wb and wouldn't his crew know about this, since wb stays with his crew?
Why would garling fight wb and wouldn't his crew know about this, since wb stays with his crew?
Garling probably fought WB again 24-10 years ago
F
This fandom has a weird obsession with inserting their headcannon into the story and expecting Oda to follow through with it lol
Also, this is the last time we see prime WB and the sake cup is blocking his chest scars
He got them after God Valley and Roger is still the likely candidate that gave them to him
Also, this is the last time we see prime WB and the sake cup is blocking his chest scars
He got them after God Valley and Roger is still the likely candidate that gave them to him
Even tho fans can go over the top sometimes it's better if WB stuff is retconned and Oda connects it to Figarland.
It makes no sense for WB to say it in such a manner as if he had resentment towards Shanks for this.
There is no reason for scar to ache since WB loved Roger in a way.
F
Bro this old man says a lot of things.
First and foremost. One Piece was meant to last 5 years, this is how long Oda has planned the story to be. Everything after that is stretching for $ purposes because he was pressured by Shueisha to become their golden egg.
He recently said that newcomers don't have to read previous 1000 chapters because they will be irrelevant since he will adapt the story meaning he will retcon the living fuck out of some things.
First and foremost. One Piece was meant to last 5 years, this is how long Oda has planned the story to be. Everything after that is stretching for $ purposes because he was pressured by Shueisha to become their golden egg.
He recently said that newcomers don't have to read previous 1000 chapters because they will be irrelevant since he will adapt the story meaning he will retcon the living fuck out of some things.
I'm pretty sure yellow data book mentions that the scar was made by Roger , tho idk if that changed since it's an old databook .
"The Pirate King's Opponent
Whitebeard has fought with many pirates during his life long journey as a pirate. Among his opponents, the most famous will be the Pirate King, Gol. D. Roger!
Picture with 3 peeps
Whitebeard: Having fought many battles with Roger's pirate crew, I remember some of the people with special characteristics. That interesting guy with a red nose who was with you, is he still alive?
Caption: An old friend of Shanks when the latter was still a trainee onboard Roger's ship. In this cruel world, not many can survive.
Picture at the bottom
Whitebeard: When I see your face, the wound which that bastard gave me is starting to hurt.
Caption: The wounds left on Whitebeard's body are the evidence of his battles with Roger, they are unforgettable memories..."
"The Pirate King's Opponent
Whitebeard has fought with many pirates during his life long journey as a pirate. Among his opponents, the most famous will be the Pirate King, Gol. D. Roger!
Picture with 3 peeps
Whitebeard: Having fought many battles with Roger's pirate crew, I remember some of the people with special characteristics. That interesting guy with a red nose who was with you, is he still alive?
Caption: An old friend of Shanks when the latter was still a trainee onboard Roger's ship. In this cruel world, not many can survive.
Picture at the bottom
Whitebeard: When I see your face, the wound which that bastard gave me is starting to hurt.
Caption: The wounds left on Whitebeard's body are the evidence of his battles with Roger, they are unforgettable memories..."
You make a good point with the scar aching thing since Oda uses that to link characters that have a level of animosity towards each other.
WB had one scar here that he likely got from Roger, but the ones after that it's possible that he got them from Garling in some offscreen event that might be addressed, who knows.
It's just weird that something this significant has no foreshadowing at all — if it's true. I guess that's what happens when you keep adding new ideas without remembering older events
WB had one scar here that he likely got from Roger, but the ones after that it's possible that he got them from Garling in some offscreen event that might be addressed, who knows.
It's just weird that something this significant has no foreshadowing at all — if it's true. I guess that's what happens when you keep adding new ideas without remembering older events
Basically when Shanks went to meet WB he said the scar he got from "that guy" aches when he looks at Shanks' face
Everyone assumed it was Roger because it was the obvious choice, since Roger was his rival and that Shanks was Roger's apprentice. Now that Garling has been introduced some people think he scarred WB instead, since he's a relative of Shanks' and that it makes more sense; scars in One Piece link characters and have animosity embedded in them so WB and Roger's friendly rivalry doesn't add up and Garling is the better option. The real question is when they actually fought.
That's pretty much it
Everyone assumed it was Roger because it was the obvious choice, since Roger was his rival and that Shanks was Roger's apprentice. Now that Garling has been introduced some people think he scarred WB instead, since he's a relative of Shanks' and that it makes more sense; scars in One Piece link characters and have animosity embedded in them so WB and Roger's friendly rivalry doesn't add up and Garling is the better option. The real question is when they actually fought.
That's pretty much it
F
He will retcon. He said it himself lmfao. Don't be bothered by this tbh.
We are in for a lot of retcons, right? Even Oda said it himself.
Whitebeard said that his scar aches whenever he sees Shanks.
This is just a theory not something confirmed so don't feel offended by it.
Why would Whitebeard's scar start to ache when he sees Shanks? Whitebeard loved Roger like everyone did.
Usually, something such as scar aching comes from animosity towards someone like @JayKitetsu said.
Oda definitely didn't plan this then and there but he will definitely try to use it.
We are in for a lot of retcons, right? Even Oda said it himself.
Whitebeard said that his scar aches whenever he sees Shanks.
This is just a theory not something confirmed so don't feel offended by it.
Why would Whitebeard's scar start to ache when he sees Shanks? Whitebeard loved Roger like everyone did.
Usually, something such as scar aching comes from animosity towards someone like @JayKitetsu said.
Oda definitely didn't plan this then and there but he will definitely try to use it.