Search results

One thing that doesn't work in Carrot's favor is that every SH had some kind of connection to a main villain at one point or another - Zoro got "captured" by Morgan's son then he defeated Morgan himself - Kuro worked for and tried to kill Kaya, who was Usopp's friend - Sanji fed Krieg when he...

I’m not sure at all about Yamato being stronger than Inu, Neko or Shutenmaru but I guess it’s not out of the realm of possibility. I’ve a much harder time believing she could be stronger than Marco though. It’s not that important anyway, the point is maybe her strength compared to Carrot’s is...

Now that I think about it, there’s a interesting pattern that should be noted. I’m not entirely sure, correct if I’m wrong but I think each time a crew member joined the crew before Wano, he was the strongest character available on Luffy’s side. Zoro was the strongest ally in Romance Dawn, Nami...

Luffy wants 10 companions, not 11. And three characters joining the crew in the same arc is extremely unlikely, two (Jinbe + either Carrot or Yamato) is already a lot.

Hum, you’re making a lot of good points. I guess time will tell.

Aren't you forgetting Yamato's relationship with Ace ? It has nothing to do with Momo. Their bond was created for the exact same reason the bond between Jinbe and Ace was created : to link them to Luffy through Ace's memory. And one of them is already part of the crew because of it.

Momo’s dream is to become the Shogun of Wano, he has no reason to join the crew.

Maybe, but I wonder how he could resolve this situation. Not only the guy is too strong for her, but he seems to be on the alliance’s side so there’s no point in fighting him. Even if Carrot’s anger is too strong to put their differences aside and she chooses to attack him, she’d need some...

I’m not even sure Oda cares about that, especially in the current context.

Now the theory of Jinbe dying in Wano can die once and for all, as the "he’s not in the color spread!" excuse doesn’t work anymore. Yamato’s becoming more and more physically distinguishable from Nami in each chapter. Like I said earlier, she’s a new character and we should give Oda some time...

Yeah, I suspect he did and if it’s true, I think that was a stupid move. You don’t sacrifice an interesting plot point just because people saw it coming, unless the element of surprise is essential to make it work (which is not the case here).

I don't get this hate for Carrot, to be honest. Why does she annoy so many fans ?

I'm not sure why Luffy's appreciation regarding Yamato's past or importance vis-a-vis the story of Wano should have any weight in his decision, especially considering the fact he often asked someone to join his crew for no reason. He recruited Franky, Robin and Nami without knowing anything...

So Oda would have to handle 12 SHs ? It was already complicated with only 9 of them.

Wow, chill out, pal, it’s not that serious. This is nothing to lose your head over. If she’s bound to join the crew, it will happen anyway. Our opinion doesn’t matter at the end of the day, as it’s Oda who decides and facts speak for themselves.

That’s true. But what does "putting more effort" mean for Oda ? Who can say he doesn’t think the horns, the height and the weird hair are enough to make her look unique ? Because that’s what separates Yamato from characters like Rebecca, Tashigi or Hancock, who are just regular humans without...

But maybe she already looks unique enough in Oda's eyes. What are the chances of having a panel of Yamato in which we'll be able to see absolutely none her unique physical features ? He should work on her eyes and nose to make her look more unique. He began to draw her only 2 chapters ago, he...

Does she really need to be more distinct from Nami though ? I get where you’re coming from and I can understand why their similar face bothers a lot of fans, but I think the real question is : does Oda care ? Does he think them looking radically different from each other is a prerequisite for...

I guess it depends on whether she joins crew. If she does, she’ll need a long term goal because Wano’s borders will probably be open after Kaido’s defeat.

Now she only needs a dream and an official role she could fulfill in the crew then she’d have all the necessary requirements to be a potential SH. What her role could be ? Blacksmith, maybe. Finding a dream for her is a little trickier, I have no idea what it could be. I thought it could be to...