Search results

  1. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    Not sure about any particular fandoms but indeed people wanting their headcanon regarding their fav character to come true instead of the route the author chooses certainly does add in to this hate the entire story agenda just because your fav characters didnt behave like you wanted them to.
  2. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    Appreciate your honesty about not having read my thread in the first place . My bad i mistook you for yet another OP basher troll on this forum who is hell bent on hating or shallow reviewing but at the end of the day posting memes & trolling is not in anyways contributive to any discussion of...
  3. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    I am aware that the second half of SG wont exist without the first . Its more that even though the first half was supposed to be build up part , it was way too bland & dry . The entire show threw away its sci fi mystery potential to devolve into a typical romance story coupled with stereotypical...
  4. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    Defense coping mechanism at work. Trolling is the only way you weekly complainers who like to whine like bit**es every chapter can cope your way out. Cope hard. The very existence of this thread is like a thorn in the face of pitiful clowns like you lot. I came here & said what i wanted to...
  5. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    Lol lol , you felt the need to call in your "daddy" to defend & cover up for your insecurities . What a pitiful bunch of clowns your entire lot is. All that Ls that you use at the end of each character's name as a suffix is simply put projection on your part. Forget about One Piece , Manga or...
  6. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    Is that so ? I heard ppl say that FMA was anime staff guys writing the story & FMAB was the managaka's story & that FMAB was better so went for FMAB. Should i watch FMA as well or does FMAB give away spoilers to FMA beyond the intro part which is same i guess for both ?
  7. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    I have added an additional point in my original post right after Daniel's clip :- Merphy who has placed One Piece neck & neck with The Gentleman Bastards as her top 2 series of all time is not just a booktuber (with 300k+ subs) but also a manuscript critique professionally (people who offer...
  8. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    @The White Crane Steins gate was too much bland for its first half. People had said that things will gear up from the mid point. They did but to me felt like all the so called build up of the first half didnt pay off at the end. Far from it. In fact the only reason why the second half felt like...
  9. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    Yes agreed. Also what i am saying is that Pre TS arcs was binge reading for most of us (Version 1) which is >> Version 3 (rereading an arc )>>>>> version 2 (weekly reading ) & Post TS arcs were version 2 so they are not even on the same level playing field . And also while reading pre ts...
  10. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    You are contradicting yourself to a ridiculous extent. First off you say that you dont care about art but more about story & yet you are a Murata worshipper whose job is primarily to draw the manga & not craft the story which ONE does mostly even for the manga version. Murata drawing is better...
  11. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    I respect your opinion but i disagree. In my book , OP is several times better than FMA & felt FMA to be overrated indeed. But ok lets agree to disagree. FMAB & Steins Gate were sitting at #1 rated anime on ANN & myanimelist or very close to that but they are absolutely not in my opinion...
  12. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    Exactly. I even mentioned in my original post that they must go & check out Thriller Bark Zoro nothing happened moment on Arlong Park forums & how most ppl back then didnt like it or called Kuma's actions as PIS & non sense.
  13. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    So have those scholars & experts that you mentioned even picked up a manga ? Because manga is a different medium altogether , most of these experts dont even pick it up in the first place. If they do pick them up in future then i will listen to their opinion as well. But people who have read...
  14. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    First off , as i mentioned in the first half of the thread ->You are at Version 2 which is inferior to version 3 which is inferior to version 1. The things visible to a version 1 or 2 reader wont be to weekly readers. The other reasons why people feel there is no tension is because:- To them...
  15. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    I would somewhat agree & disagree on that but more importantly the experience of pay off is much better when you read it in one go & not weekly over 10 years. That is what the first half of this thread is about. You are at Version 2 which is inferior to version 3 which is inferior to version 1 .
  16. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    So you too skipped all the points just because you saw a reddit link. I dont even have an account on reddit let alone post there. The only reason i posted that reddit link is because thats where i found that Daniel clip. Also consider reading all the points before commenting. I can...
  17. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    I dont even have an account on reddit let alone post there. The only reason i posted that reddit link is because thats where i found that Daniel clip. Also consider reading all the points before commenting. I can respectfully disagree with your opinion but not if you skip all of my points &...
  18. Windfall Island

    General & Others Post TS arcs are massively underrated + Oda is on a level with the all time fantasy greats.

    First off , if you don't care to read till the end then no need to reply. Yes One Piece has its fair share of inconsistencies , flaws & puke inducing moments (eg. sanji nosebleeding , "comedy scenes" that just don't click , annoying characters like "children at PH" etc) . Background :- Most...
Top