Controversial 🤔 Why didnt Judge say anything

[Yoho]

So I've been thinking about something I just I realized

The Stussy we've been following all this time Is a clone? Correct

A clone created by MADS? Correct

An organization whose members consisted of Vegapunk, Queen, Ceaser Clown and Judge? Correct

So my question is..... Did Judge and Ceaser not realize that Stussy was the clone they made?

I'm sure they saw her during whole cake

Now that we know what we know it's strange Judge or Ceaser didn't even acknowledge Stussy's presence

Where they trying to maintain her deep cover?

If so why? What did they gain from keeping that secret 🤔

 

[vikas]

 

[Yoho]

😂😂

 

[Owl Ki]

Meta explanation: Oda either didn't want to reveal it at that point or hadn't thought about it.

In-universe explanation: Judge didn't really care about it. He had other more important things to think about. As for Caesar, he was kept away from the party until the last minute when he was sent into the proverbial frying pan, so he wasn't going to notice Stussy while in the middle of a dangerous situation.

 

[Salah WG]

If Characters say anything they know for no reason, they'd look both stupid & cringe

 

[Herrera95]

Stop pretending like Oda didn't had all planed since he was inside his own mother womb and is just creating random plots that makes no sense.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Because Judge didn’t care he didn’t say anything to Caesar either.

MADs was decades ago and they all moved on from it. Even Dufeld who thought Stussy was the original and not a clone didn’t really mention the old MADs days

 

[Saint Wentorno]

The govt most likely already knows she is a clone. Even if Vegapunk or Caesar didnt tell them, its safe to assume they already have records of the original Stussy and could put two and two together when a similar woman with both her name and her physical appearance pops up.
And if the govt knows , then most well established pirates/ubderworld figures who have a web of informants and sources of intel like Linlin and Shanks know too.
Linlin was with the OG Stussy in the same pirate crew and clearly she can tell, unless she has Alzheimers.
So there really wasnt any reason for Judge to say anything.
He probably only got a little sense of pride that their lab creation ended up becoming an underworld figure.

Now the thing I dont know is if the pirates, criminals and Judge/Caesar knew her true job was a Cipher Pol agent.