Controversial Are Admiral fans getting too cocky about GB’s black blade?

#1
The colored manga coloring his blade black was a W for them, but it’s important remember that the colored manga isn’t any more canon than the anime. The colored manga also gets designs wrong sometimes, such as them giving Jupiter having blonde hair in the colored manga even though the latest volume cover proved he had white hair. Many GB fans are popping the champagne too early imo. We need to wait until a volume cover or official drawing from Oda himself depicts it as black, or until Oda makes a statement about it being a Kokuto or not. It could still just be a brown, wooden blade imo
 
#2
The colored manga coloring his blade black was a W for them, but it’s important remember that the colored manga isn’t any more canon than the anime. The colored manga also gets designs wrong sometimes, such as them giving Jupiter having blonde hair in the colored manga even though the latest volume cover proved he had white hair. Many GB fans are popping the champagne too early imo. We need to wait until a volume cover or official drawing from Oda himself depicts it as black, or until Oda makes a statement about it being a Kokuto or not. It could still just be a brown, wooden blade imo
It’s black in black and white too
 
#5
There was never a need for a coloured manga. Everyone that isn't blind could tell that the blade is as black is it can possibly get in a manga.
The anime very clearly went on a cover up mission and we Admiral fans waited for more credible sources to expose that nonsense.
Lmao. It’s a black or white manga. It can only be drawn as black or white. If it was a brown blade, it would be drawn as black in the manga. We need to wait for the Admiral volume cover to know for sure
 
#8
Yeah I think there’s a significant difference between a characters hair color (which got corrected in the color manga) and a characters sword which is black in the very release of the manga.
Bro. It’s a black and white manga. It can only be drawn as black or white in the manga. If it’s canonically any color besides those two, Oda will arbitrarily chose to depict it was black or white.
 
#13
Realistically? It doesn't matter to most "admiral fans", they aren't getting happy because it'll make no change Aramaki's ranking for them among the admirals. (It won't for me either, unless the black blade is a supreme blade). This will just be used to prop up Akainu more by claiming how the guy who accomplished the samething as Mihawk + Ryuuma and is a logia, thus superior to them, is Akainu's inferior. Thus showing how strong Akainu truly is!!!

It also really wouldn't matter to the "Sword fans" can use it for their own good and claim an Admiral has a black blade, and even then Mihawk is the one recognized as the Strongest Swordsman. Thus meaning worst for the admirals. And if you want to get more disgusting, you can twist it as GreenBull becomes certified as the Top 1 admiral because he did something only 2 other characters in known history have done, thus even the strongest admiral is below Mihawk!!!


In the end it's just another cog in the Akainu circle jerk vs Mihawk circle jerk. Both will use it in what benefits them.


Unless you're part of these two circle jerks, this isn't a topic to stress about.
 
#18
Let’s look at when he used Groves of Wrath and his tree form… white to light gray.
Kuma canonically has brown hair, but it's drawn as black in the manga... The point is that Oda is wildly inconsistent with this stuff and that if the sword was any color than black or white, Oda would arbitrarily pick to shade it as either black or white based on what looks cooler with the rest of the black-and-white design of the character
 
#19
The colored manga coloring his blade black was a W for them, but it’s important remember that the colored manga isn’t any more canon than the anime. The colored manga also gets designs wrong sometimes, such as them giving Jupiter having blonde hair in the colored manga even though the latest volume cover proved he had white hair. Many GB fans are popping the champagne too early imo. We need to wait until a volume cover or official drawing from Oda himself depicts it as black, or until Oda makes a statement about it being a Kokuto or not. It could still just be a brown, wooden blade imo
:wonderland:
 
#20
The reason I think it's not as big a W as they're making it out to be, is because despite all their efforts to prove otherwise, it's still a W for Mihawk. It just means that he has a blade that's even stronger than ANOTHER black blade, and that he himself is stronger than Aramaki as well.
It's not really a win for them against the sword fandom, when you consider that.
But it is very impressive outside of that.
 
Top