My BBP vs SH matchups (I explained them in a video):
I listed the Blackbeard Pirates in order of their captain number. Each Titanic Captain is the captain of a ship, Burgess has the first, Doc Q is the captain of the 9th ship. You can order the Strawhats in the order they joined. Oda numbered them himself in coverpages. For example here:
If you now assign the first captain to the first Strawhat, the second Titanic Captain to the second Strawhat and so on, you get this:
Big overlap with my own match ups. Four are obviously wrong. Burgess won't fight Luffy. All the others where it doesn't fit are the matchups of the Weakling Trio. Even where it doesn't fit there is a pattern. Zoro vs Shiryu fits, so does Sanji vs Lafitte, Robin vs Wolf, Franky vs Vasco and Brook vs Doc Q. 1,3,4,6 are wrong. 1 and 3, and 4 and 6, are 2 apart. 1 and 3 are from BB's original crew, 4 and 6 are from level 6.
I listed the Blackbeard Pirates in order of their captain number. Each Titanic Captain is the captain of a ship, Burgess has the first, Doc Q is the captain of the 9th ship. You can order the Strawhats in the order they joined. Oda numbered them himself in coverpages. For example here:
If you now assign the first captain to the first Strawhat, the second Titanic Captain to the second Strawhat and so on, you get this:
Big overlap with my own match ups. Four are obviously wrong. Burgess won't fight Luffy. All the others where it doesn't fit are the matchups of the Weakling Trio. Even where it doesn't fit there is a pattern. Zoro vs Shiryu fits, so does Sanji vs Lafitte, Robin vs Wolf, Franky vs Vasco and Brook vs Doc Q. 1,3,4,6 are wrong. 1 and 3, and 4 and 6, are 2 apart. 1 and 3 are from BB's original crew, 4 and 6 are from level 6.
Last edited:
