General & Others Best One Piece fight overall till now in the manga.

[Punk Rotten]

Luffy vs Lucci for sure. You actually felt the grit in that one. The same for Luffy vs Crocodile, Zoro vs Mr. 1, Sanji vs Gin, and Luffy vs Arlong was fun too.

I think we need a fight from post timeskip that has that grittiness that pre timeskip had.

 

[Sigran101]

Strawhats vs Oars is my favorite by far.

 

[Kuroemon]

Luffy vs Lucci
Luffy vs Blueno (this just because the gear 2 introduction to me was super cool)
Sanji vs Jabura (diable jambe introduction also super cool)
Zoro, Luffy vs Kaido

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

What is your favorite One Piece fight from the Beginning part of the manga till the current arc.

My favorite fight is still Luffy vs Rob Lucci during the Enis Lobby arc. This fight had so much impact in the One Piece series. Pushing Luffy beyond his limits.

Second fight that comes close would be Luffy vs Katakuri. I loved the characterization of Katakuri, he was such an awesome character in fact best character and villain in WCI arc. But the fight can’t come close to the Lucci fight.

Same choices
Also the reason for the Rob still number 1 over Katakuri for me is the ending... I felt King Cobra vs Diced Mochi were not good enough attacks to end the fight with
Also the 10 min break before revealing the winner was kinda taking away from the fight...at least for me...

honestly this whole 10 min break of haki in gear 4th is so stupid in general, but whatever..

 

[Monster Luffy]

Luffy vs Lucci
Sanji vs Bonclay
Zoro vs Ryuma
Luffy vs captain Kuro

 

[uyuu]

Luffy vs Lucci, hands down the best in emotion, protecting theme, and choreography and rivalry. Followed by Luffy vs Crocodile, having the theme of surpassing the strongest.

 

[Finalbeta]

This conquered my heart in the recent time still;

 

[Cherry Hilk]

I have a thing for group fights therefore Oars vs Strawhats and Worst generation vs Yonko.
If we mean 1 vs 1 then Luffy vs Lucci and Zoro vs Mr1.

 

[Lifeismeh]

Luffy vs Katakuri

creative, symbolic and very entertaining

Below that there's just decent fights throughout the serie, nothing really stand out

I expect the Yonko final fights to be the greatest tho

 

[Fn Lucci]

There's a continuity of story to me. So the fights that come now are good because they build on the things that made the fights of the past good. For example if I see Zoro use Asura it builds on vs Kaku to hold meaning

 

[Peroroncino]

Luffy vs Foxy

 

[Fn Lucci]

Luffy vs Foxy

Some people here complain about Foxy, but he was a fun character and that was probably the most One Piece fight there is.

It was a big deal on the forums I went to back then and seemed just as popular in Japan

 

[Finalbeta]

Nami vs Mr. Doublefinger was also pretty entrancing to me. Nami almost died in that match up.

 

[Shadowtrigun]

Some people here complain about Foxy, but he was a fun character and that was probably the most One Piece fight there is.

It was a big deal on the forums I went to back then and seemed just as popular in Japan

Foxy’ character was well okay. But I feel like his arc was a waste of time

 

[rerere]

Luffy vs Lucci
Lowkey, I think that Oda will never reach that peak again

 

[Finalbeta]

Luffy vs Lucci
Lowkey, I think that Oda will never reach that peak again

One of the most beautiful yes, but I think the Peak will probably be reached again.

Luffy v Akainu
Zoro v Mihawk
Luffy v Teach
Perhaps Im

There's a lot of compelling stuff that will presumably occur imo.

 

[York]

Usopp and Chopper vs Mr 4 and Ms Merry Christmas

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Luffy vs Lucci
Lowkey, I think that Oda will never reach that peak again

Agree. Post-timeskip fights will be never as good as pre-skip fights.

 

[Kuruka]

Luffy vs Lucci is the best.

Luffy vs Kata approached this fight but it didn’t reach it.

For other characters:

Zoro vs Ryuma

Sanji vs Jyabra

Nami vs Kalifla

Usopp vs Luffy

Chopper vs Chessmarimo

Franky vs Senor Pink

Brook still yet to have a full fight

Jinbe not really have a full fight either

forgot robin

 

[ZenZu]

Pre timeskip: Luffy vs Lucci
Post timeskip: Luffy vs Katakuri

Both by a landslide. There is a lot of symbolism and some cool moments in other One Piece fights, but at the end of the day the fighting itself holds the most weight imo when judging a fight. These two fights are straight brawls, just look so clean both in the anime and manga.