Questions & Mysteries Big Mom probably lost against Garp at God Valley

[Cream filled donut7]

she might have a personal grudge against him

 

[Roo]

A personal grudge when she smiled and then never mentioned Garp again?

 

[Cream filled donut7]

A personal grudge when she smiled and then never mentioned Garp again?

idk its just a thought

 

[FredericRoger]

Roger won against xebec, garp won against whitebeard and sengoku won against big mom.

 

[Herrera95]

Roger won against xebec, garp won against whitebeard and sengoku won against big mom.

Sengoku wasn't even there

 

[gz89]

Maybe it was like the rooftop fight with WB changing sides/leaving.

Something like Xebec,Shiki,Meme and some other bigshots of his crew vs Roger,Garp,Ray,Gaban etc

 

[Garp the Fist]

Big Mom got beaten like Killer, she got hit in the crossfire of a Galaxy Impact and that was enough for her.

 

[Date]

Think the Manga already said more than a 100 chapters ago that Garp and Roger defeated Rocks and his crew, whats new about it?

 

[Marco]

Garps warm up fight before he took on Xebec

 

[Monkey D Theories]

Whenever we get the God Valley flashback, I guarantee Big Mom will be used as a hype tool for either Garp, Roger, or Rayleigh

 

[Arthur Fleck]

It's almost impossible that only Garp, Roger, Rocks, BM, Kaido and WB were the only ones involved in that fight. Surely previous Admirals(maybe including Sengoku), Rayleigh+rest of Roger pirates and Rest of Rocks pirates were involved. BM might have fought admirals and won or fought WB and end up in draw.

 

[JoNdule]

If she lost, she would say it
If she lost, she wouldn't be clean shortly after God Valley

 

[Loki D. Terror]

Technically all rocks pirate were.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Big Mom got beaten like Killer, she got hit in the crossfire of a Galaxy Impact and that was enough for her.

Ngl at that point they did seem to be kind of weak compared to their current versions
So I can see them getting hurt in the crossfire of the clashes