Questions & Mysteries Celestial ravisher

Who is Bonney's biological father?


  • Total voters
    43
#42
With the events of the recent chapter revealing Ginny was in fact captured by a Celestial Dragon and raped for 2 years which produced Bonney it brings the question which scumbag was this?

Watching a recent Ohara video I thought he brought up some good points on one individual.

So the person I believe to be Bonney's father is Saint Roswald and here's why.

When we first introduced to Charlos the first thing we seen him do was take someone else's fiance as his wife an almost like for like situation with Kuma.



This is around the same time Bonney saves Charlos from Zoro.

So it's not hard to possibly believe that the father of Charlos doesn't have the same greedy habits.

Oda has also gone out of his way to punish Kuma first by his parents, then Ginny and finally I believe this is his last form of punishment that Ginny's biological father did to Kuma



I don't believe it's beyond Oda at this point to have the one who cucked Kuma and raped the love of his life to also be using him as a horse with a chain around his neck.

Why?

Kuma's character is all about taking pain. Look at the ability of his fruit as an example.

Anyway the final reason why I think Saint Roswald is Bonney's father is because the way she reacted when she seen him/Kuma. Originally we thought the him meant Kuma but what if she had found out who it was who raped her mother and seeing how he is treating her 'father' Kuma she swears he'll pay.



I think this panel is meant to throw us off thinking she meant Kuma but in fact meant Saint Roswald as now we know the story we know the context right after she says 'I didn't think I'd meet him here' she follows it up with a 'You'll pay'.

If Saint Roswald is Bonney's father I hope someone punches the shit out of him as well.

@Uncle Van @Gol D. Roger @Jiihad @HA D CLOWN @ @Pringles @Bisoromi Bear @Paperchampion23 @Roronoa-sama @nik87 @DonWick @Embers Kaios @Julius @straightforward @Roo @K!NG HARA$H!MA @Sentinel @ConquistadoR @KonyaruIchi @MarineHQ @Salah WG @notAfanboy @Lor D. Coast @CoC: Color of Clowns @pg13 @Dark-Abel @Jailer @Cruxroux @soheilhazrat @Jackteo @Albino 👑 @centurion @BOCCHI @Reborn @BangOO🍅 @Kerkovian @Erkan12 @Hedfi @Toby D. Dog @Herrera95 @Andy @vikas @SDfear @centurion @Nekomamushi @MonsterKaido @Tejas @Extravlad @Jew D. Boy @djiayebee @matt245 @Moegara @Boiroy @Zolo @Akai2 @Fleet Leader Fenaker @SkySanji @AverageNamiEnjoyer @Jackteo
@Gorosei Informer @NikaInParis @Devilbat @Adam 🍎 @Light D Lamperouge @SmokedOut @LANJI CUCKSMOKE @Rhea @Ekkologix @Fujishiro @TheKnightOfTheSea @Cream filled donut7 @Pot Goblin @Marimo_420 @MUUGEN @Indigo @Mr. Reloaded @TheAncientCenturion @RayanOO @AL sama @Natalija @Doggo @Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier @Sir Yasheen @Apollo @SakazOuki @Jaguark101 @Kagu Nyan @Bepo D. Bear @Goodman Grey @Owl Ki @Longleg Larry @Cross_Marian @Etzel Andergast @The White Crane @IceWitch @NAMELESS @Elder Lee Hung @NotTommy @MonochromeYoru @GrandmasterChef Zonji @Veku @FloriGlori @ZenZu @Tobra @uyuu
 
Last edited:
#43
Bonney doesn't even know who her bio dad is, it makes no sense for her to know it was Roswald.

The whole "You'll Pay!!" is meant for Vegapunk because originally Bonney thought Vegapunk was responsible for what happened to Kuma.

Also Roswald just feels a bit too random for him to be Bonney's bio dad.

If I had to guess who Bonney's bio dad is, I would say it's one of the God's Knights.
 
#46
Bonney doesn't even know who her bio dad is, it makes no sense for her to know it was Roswald.

The whole "You'll Pay!!" is meant for Vegapunk because originally Bonney thought Vegapunk was responsible for what happened to Kuma.

Also Roswald just feels a bit too random for him to be Bonney's bio dad.

If I had to guess who Bonney's bio dad is, I would say it's one of the God's Knights.
We don't know that she doesn't know though.

She knew Saturn was the one who ordered Kuma to have his memories erased etc so there's a lot she knows the we don't know that she knows.

Again that line is an implication that she meant Vegapunk. During the Marineford arc Bonney said something similar saying she would go after him we originally thought that meant Blackbeard but that made no sense knowing what we know now.

The parallels are there I don't think it's coincidence that whenever Bonney is shown near Celestial Dragons it's always near Saint Roswald and his family. Saboady and Reverie etc.

We May not like it but this pos might have been the one to rape Ginny.
Post automatically merged:

Nah he seems like the type that would go after her himself. The whole ordered to be kidnapped sounds like an order from a fat slob Celestial Dragon
 
#47
@Adamxero
:lawsigh:

Again she literally doesn't fucking know. She was just a baby when she and her mom were kicked out of Marijoa.

Kuma doesn't know who her bio dad, neither does the rest of the Revs. Bonney grew up with Kuma and probably thought that he was her bio dad, she has no idea who her actual bio dad is.

Bonney didn't find out the truth about the whole thing with Kuma until she entered that memory bubble of Kuma.

And do you know why she knows Saturn was the one who ordered Kuma to have his memories erased? Because she found that out through the memory bubble.

Did you forget about that whole scene? Where she entered Kuma's memory bubble.

Before she entered that memory bubble, she didn't know anything.

After entering that memory bubble, that's where she learned the truth.

Rowald being there doesn't mean jack shit, the only reason why Oda has so far only focused on them originally was because he has yet to introduce the other CDs during that time such as the God's Knights.

Rowald and his family are not the only CDs, there are many other CDs as well.

Don't think that he and his family are the only and main CDs.

If Oda is going to built up some sort of villain for Bonney to face by the end of the series, it makes sense for it to be a God's Knight who is not only a CD but also a fighter.
(If Oda does decide to have Bonney participate in the final war.)

Either way, your whole Rowald theory just makes no sense and it just feels too random.
 
#53
Saturn because kidnapping Ginny specifically made me think he just want to get back at Kuma considering the beef/obsession he has with him.

Also, I’ve learned about sapphires in planet Saturn from one of the theory in the chapter thread.

So, I think he will reveal it in attempt to crush Kuma or Bonney’s spirit.
 
Last edited:
#55
Harashima 's thread title was better....
Post automatically merged:

It’s Garling

Garling has been continuously highlighted throughout this arc. First he killed Myosgard, then we saw him at God Valley.

I think Garling being Bonney’s dad gives her character somewhat of a happy ending as it means Shanks is her brother and she still has living family that isn’t completely awful.
Post automatically merged:

Also Bonney being Shanks’s sister gives Luffy a reason to seek out Shanks besides just the hat
Isn't Bonney is Shanks' sister an old theory?
 
Last edited:
#57
@Adamxero
:lawsigh:

Again she literally doesn't fucking know. She was just a baby when she and her mom were kicked out of Marijoa.

Kuma doesn't know who her bio dad, neither does the rest of the Revs. Bonney grew up with Kuma and probably thought that he was her bio dad, she has no idea who her actual bio dad is.

Bonney didn't find out the truth about the whole thing with Kuma until she entered that memory bubble of Kuma.

And do you know why she knows Saturn was the one who ordered Kuma to have his memories erased? Because she found that out through the memory bubble.

Did you forget about that whole scene? Where she entered Kuma's memory bubble.

Before she entered that memory bubble, she didn't know anything.

After entering that memory bubble, that's where she learned the truth.

Rowald being there doesn't mean jack shit, the only reason why Oda has so far only focused on them originally was because he has yet to introduce the other CDs during that time such as the God's Knights.

Rowald and his family are not the only CDs, there are many other CDs as well.

Don't think that he and his family are the only and main CDs.

If Oda is going to built up some sort of villain for Bonney to face by the end of the series, it makes sense for it to be a God's Knight who is not only a CD but also a fighter.
(If Oda does decide to have Bonney participate in the final war.)

Either way, your whole Rowald theory just makes no sense and it just feels too random.
We don't know what she knows. Stop acting like you know all of Bonney's past. There's obviously a point where Bonney learns more than she did in the flashback we're currently in. The bubble again is something to be seen I'll wait to the next dialogue from Bonney and Saturn to decide to concede on that specific panel.

Bonney isn't being set up to fight some final villain she's the person the Straw Hats are going to save in the arc then move on. Her biological father being a scumbag like Rowland is fitting.

We see Bonney first appear when Charlos steals someone's wife.

We see her as Rowland is abusing Kuma.

Give me one other reason why out of all the Celestial Dragons we know in the story why Rowland doesn't make the most sense with what we know and the parallels that are already there in the story.

I get the idea of someone like Saint Rowland raping Ginny isn't easy to swallow but based on the info we know it makes the most sense it being him seeing how we've seen how his son is.
 
#58
You do realize that Kuma is not there anymore, he left that place and is about to come to Egghead.

Also how would Kuma knows who it is? As far as we know, Kuma doesn't know which CD took Ginny.
We don't know where Kuma is at the moment, but what we do know, he has no free will, so whatever he was programmed to do on Mariejois, he will finish it, because he can't go against the programming. What else could he possibly have been programmed to do there that would cause him to attack the most fortified place on the planet, and that he is willing to give his life for?
 
Top