CH 812: NEW HSU Prediction Thread

#21
I'm still coming to my verdict but I'm mostly unimpressed.

The biggest plus for me is that Shin now has his personal 5K unit. Hopefully we get to see this 5K grow into a truly elite unit in time.

I also like the official addition of a medical squad and the apparent permanence of at least some of the Saki clan. Considering the size of the unit, I wonder if that makes Rin a 1K Commander? Is she considered an officer expected to be present at meetings now? Hopefully we'll find out more soon. It's been my personal hope Io still joins and fills such a position within the HSU.

I also like the detail of So Sui's unit being responsible for transport protection. That makes all the more sense if you remember he used to be in charge of the logistics before Ten took over.

What I don't like:

This busines with Suu Gen being a 3K Commander but also commanding the entirety of the +10K infantry sucks, and requires explanation before it could even make sense.

Most promotions are too low. Ga Ro in particular should've been up for 5K over En, but fine, Hara thought differently. Still, a single increment in rank just seems far too low relative to his abilities, stats, prominence in the story, proximity to Shin and overall importance to the HSU. Ga Ro should be a 3K Commander at minimum, with Man Dou as his lieutenant.

Other thoughts
  • 3000 archers out of an army of 40K - less than 10% - is on the very low end, yet how is Taku Kei meant to protect that many with 300?
  • Why is Kou only just now a unit commander? He should've been one eons ago as a HSU founding member
  • What of Shi Tou, the young 50-Man Commander with the sword? Ei Tou? Shou Kai, who appears to be Shou Sa's son?
  • Ka Ryo Ten should have her own army unit if not at least a couple thousand men
  • The Archer Bros are 100M and 50M Commanders - what the fuck is up with that?
 
Last edited:

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
โ€Ž
#22
Iโ€™m not sure if rank is supposed to equate to overall ability, I donโ€™t think it is in this case, butโ€ฆ.if thatโ€™s the case, I would say Ryusen is too low, Garo is too low, and Suugen is too high.
 
#23
Iโ€™m not sure if rank is supposed to equate to overall ability, I donโ€™t think it is in this case, butโ€ฆ.if thatโ€™s the case, I would say Ryusen is too low, Garo is too low, and Suugen is too high.
Aside from So Sui and En, who were set in stone before this, what ranks did your expect/would you change?
 

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
โ€Ž
#24
Aside from So Sui and En, who were set in stone before this, what ranks did your expect/would you change?
Meh. I never really cared for the structure of the HSU tbh. Not sure I would put En at 5K man commander. Not to disrespect him but Sosui is leagues above him, En is in no way close to him. En should probably just have a special rank where he is with Karyo Ten and performs whatever tasks she assigns him to. If I had to pick another 5K commander besides Sosuiโ€ฆidk. Maybe Garo or Suugen I guess.
 
#27
Some ranks I wanted to see

4K - Suu Gen
3K - Ga Ro
2K - Man Dou, Den Yuu, Hai Rou
1K - Den Ei, Ryuu Sen, Io/Rin
500M - Ryuu Yuu, Taku Kei
400M - Chu Tetsu
300M - Bi Hei, Sou Jin
200M - Kou, Kan To, Ton Bros,
100M - Kei, Shi Tou, Sou Tan, Hei Rai
50M - Ei Tou
10M - Shou Kai
5M - Kyou Rei

-

In general, the HSU should've added a lot of new officers and units both at Tai Gen and during the latest wave of recruitment.

I wish Hara had dedicated some panels to these new units within the HSU structure specifically. I want to know how many of those fast cavalrymen they've added. How big is that violent clan that came after Shin? What about those giants?

What about the 22,000 that joined at Tai Gen? How many officers among their number transferred to the HSU? Hara completely glossed over this.
 
#28
Not gonna lie, I'm going to forget most of this rank stuff soon anyway.

Suugen should probably be a 5K commander since he is in charge of the infantry. Most of the notable HSU old guard could arguably be bumped up to 1k commanders at least based on veteran experience alone by this point. The HSU is a pretty large army now, being this conservative with ranks is a bit pointless. Cause if the old guard aren't being 1k commanders then who is? Lol.
 
#29
Not gonna lie, I'm going to forget most of this rank stuff soon anyway.

Suugen should probably be a 5K commander since he is in charge of the infantry. Most of the notable HSU old guard could arguably be bumped up to 1k commanders at least based on veteran experience alone by this point. The HSU is a pretty large army now, being this conservative with ranks is a bit pointless. Cause if the old guard aren't being 1k commanders then who is? Lol.
At 40K, I don't know why Shin would only have 3x 5K Units including his own.

Suu Gen and Ga Ro could've both been promoted to 5K Commanders.

Also, what happened to the reinforcements at Tai Gen? Why is Hara acting like there were no officers among the 22,000 soldiers they absorbed?
 
Top