Questions & Mysteries Devil Fruit - Science or Fantasy

Science or Fantasy

  • Science

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Fantasy

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
#1
How are yall feeling about wishing a fruit into existence? Its pretty nice thematically, as far as tying back into dreams, but I've seen some people say they wish it was more science fiction, i.e. alien tech/vegetation, or ancient lost tech.

Which do you prefer and why?
 

Peroroncino

πŸ…·πŸ…°πŸ…»πŸ…° πŸ…ΌπŸ…°πŸ…³πŸ†πŸ…ΈπŸ…³
β€Ž
#4
better than the predictable option of them being from a tree created by some kind of deity
 

Worst

Custom title
β€Ž
#5
Right now not sure it will satisfy everyone but I'm sure it will make more sense during a Void century flashbacks......

I think there are two possibilities

1) We know the Ancient Kingdom was really damn advanced even more than Vegapunk! They likely had the free energy and what not, so maybe the people started to become even greedier and desire much much more ( which could explain why the mother sea cursed them ) all this pre Void century

2) Scenario 2 whatever happened during the Void century was so brutal that everyone started to strongly desire ways to fight / run away from it and that's how they were born and maybe they are also anither way for people to pass on their will and hope for a better future so maybe they all serve the same purpose :O

I personally like it it fits well in the story and opens up to ways to fit in different scenarios
 
#6
Of course i prefer it to be fantasy. But even fantasy should also at least reveal the origin on-panel in some climactic moments, instead of just relying on Vegapunk's exposition. Imo there should be the place of origin, for all the Devil Fruit.

Maybe a fantasy tree or, some titanic otherworldly floating altar or something. The place that receives all the wishes from the entire world,






...with an ultimate artifact that realize those wishes. So, is this One Piece?

 
#7
Of course i prefer it to be fantasy. But even fantasy should also at least reveal the origin on-panel in some climactic moments, instead of just relying on Vegapunk's exposition. Imo there should be the place of origin, for all the Devil Fruit.

Maybe a fantasy tree or, some titanic otherworldly floating altar or something. The place that receives all the wishes from the entire world,






...with an ultimate artifact that realize those wishes. So, is this One Piece?

Im curious if new fruits are being created currently. Maybe there is a tree of origin that drops the fruit into trees of the world. I dont think we've seen a fruit that hasn't been pulled from the branch. Maybe thats the way to tell a new fruit from a recycled one: whether or not its on a tree.
 
#11
Someone please explain to me what Oda meant by that statement? I didn't understand it at all. "Wish a devil fruit into existence"? What does that mean?
I think he means to literally wish a devil fruit into reality. Like somebody wished to be able be one with lightning and then enels fruit was created from that wish.....or something like that.
 
#12
I still don't get it. Not sure how that fits into the story. 1000+ chapters into the story and I haven't seen any character wish for any powers.
I don't think you wish for it and then get it. I think you wish for it and then it shows up in the world somewhere. Odas gonna have to explain it at some point.
 
Top