Speculations Did Smoothie give Killer his scar?

[ReggieZoldyck21]

If you look at Killers left arm post time skip he’s got a weird looking scar.

It almost looks like a burn. But it also kind if looks like his arm has been "drained" in some way. Could Smoothie be responsible. We already know that the Kidd Pirates have had their run ins and conflicts with the Big Mom Pirates, and Smoothies powers definitely seem like they could make Killers arm look that way.

If Smoothie was the one to give Killer his scar it could set up a possible fight between them if the BM Pirates end up joining the battle.

@rerere @Lukegranders @Pantheos @Legendaryconquer#1 @style @Fenaker
@Zowo ect...

 

[Etemenanki]

The left arm has the same size of the right one, so to me it doesn't seem like it was drained.
It seems more burnt or damaged by acid.

I'd say it was from when they clashed against Shanks crew, when Kidd lost his arm and maybe Killer was more lucky and was only injured.

 

[Zolo]

man, smoothie is hot

 

[MonsterZoro]

YEA LOL WHAT DO U EXPECETED KILLER VETERAN LEVEL GOT NEG DIFF AND SCAR BY YC2

 

[vikas]

I always wondered how did they even get this info. Did Roger spread this info? Especially because BM Already had the Red Phoneglyph before roger even got the info about it.

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

Maybe Smoothie is the sweet commander Kidd wounded?

 

[spawn]

Both Kid and Killer have had something happen to their left arms.
Seems to me that Shanks instructs his crew to attack people's left arms.

 

[ReggieZoldyck21]

Maybe Smoothie is the sweet commander Kidd wounded?

I’ve always thought that Kidd either injured Cracker or Smoothie. Since Cracker has the noticeable scar across his eye and Smoothie is guarding the poneglyph room and is the only Sweet commander that seemingly hasn’t battled a Worst Generation member yet.

 

[kumae]

Let's no make Smoothie relevant,OK?

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

I’ve always thought that Kidd either injured Cracker or Smoothie. Since Cracker has the noticeable scar across his eye and Smoothie is guarding the poneglyph room and is the only Sweet commander that seemingly hasn’t battled a Worst Generation member yet.

I think you can rule out Cracker because apparently no one's seen his face in forever. We've never seen one of Smoothie's eyes so maybe Kidd blinded her?

 

[ReggieZoldyck21]

I think you can rule out Cracker because apparently no one's seen his face in forever. We've never seen one of Smoothie's eyes so maybe Kidd blinded her?

Cracker never said no ones seen his face before. He said something like, “it’s been a while since someone has seen my true form.” Since it’s implied that Kidd invaded BMs territory around 1- 2 years ago, I would say that counts as “a while”. Kidd could have been one of the few people to see Crackers true form.

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

Cracker never said no ones seen his face before. He said something like, “it’s been a while since someone has seen my true form.” Since it’s implied that Kidd invaded her territory around 1- 2 years ago, I would say that counts as “a while”.

Cracker probably would probably also hide the fact that someone broke his armor.

 

[Fuckthis3]

Reggie dont be like Sky as if she useful enough to do something like that now shanks crew the only possible choice i bet on rockstar

 

[vikas]

Maybe Smoothie is the sweet commander Kidd wounded?

I don't think so, cracker took care of them. And I doubt Katakuri and Smoothie were even in WCI as they came to tea party after being away for so long. Given the events, it's most probably Snack after which Urougue fought and beat him. Cracker is unlikely as I doubt he was wounded before Luffy, but he is the other one in my list.

 

[Jackteo]

Smoothie would have killed him so no

 

[Zolo]

what are chances that smoothie is actually one piece?

 

[Finalbeta]

what are chances that smoothie is actually one piece?

Well she is still in one piece and she is also one beautiful sensational piece.

Also judging from the size of Killer's arm, the chances he was drained are not that high.

 

[Ricassian]

If you look at Killers left arm post time skip he’s got a weird looking scar.

It almost looks like a burn. But it also kind if looks like his arm has been "drained" in some way. Could Smoothie be responsible. We already know that the Kidd Pirates have had their run ins and conflicts with the Big Mom Pirates, and Smoothies powers definitely seem like they could make Killers arm look that way.

If Smoothie was the one to give Killer his scar it could set up a possible fight between them if the BM Pirates end up joining the battle.

@rerere @Lukegranders @Pantheos @Legendaryconquer#1 @style @Fenaker
@Zowo ect...

It's a good point Reggie, I thought about this a lot and considered Smoothie as a possibility during their (possible) meeting in WCI
But tbh I agree more with this explaination

The left arm has the same size of the right one, so to me it doesn't seem like it was drained.
It seems more burnt or damaged by acid.

I'd say it was from when they clashed against Shanks crew, when Kidd lost his arm and maybe Killer was more lucky and was only injured.

Cause imo makes more sense that both Kidd and Killer got injuries during their worst defeat (Red Hair Pirates)

Smoothie still has chances to be the one tho

 

[Garp the Fist]

Smoothie? Do something of note?

Behave yourself.

 

[Zolo]

Boner she did gave, and not only to killer