Questions & Mysteries Did Whole Cake Island Arc make you hate Sanji?

Some arguments here reminds of early editions of DnD, where you would have some Lawful Good Paladin, and, if the character ever did a single action that wasn't deemed "lawful goody", the DM would bring forth the anger of a thousand incels and complain to the player that he now has to lose his paladin powers because he once did something that goes against his alignment.

- Luffy telling Law he plans to "beat the shit out of the 4 Emperors" is completely out of character for someone thatis never the aggressor, but more like a defender.
- Zoro not wanting to hurt Monet just because she's a woman is completely against his entire backstory with Kuina.
- Robin deciding to play the "mother role" with Momonosuke is completely out of touch with Robin's character.
- Jinbe betraying Big Mom by beating Opera and saving Luffy and Nami, then trying to do the "honorable sake cup" theatrics makes no sense (thanks @TheAncientCenturion for opening my eyes on this one. lol)
- Usopp making that speech on his head telling Nami to just lie to Ulti and say that Luffy won't become PK just so she can live, when he did all that "don't you dare laugh at my friend's dream" stunt in Alabasta against Mrs Merry Xmas and Mr4 also contradicts his character and his growth to becoming a brave warrior of the sea.
- Chopper during TS says he wants to become a "monster" if it is for Luffy's sake, but instead becomes even more sugar coated and gives people diabetes just by existing.
- Garp going through that dilemma of either helping Ace, or keeping his duty as a Navy soldier, and then, out of nowhere, wanting to kill Akainu because Akainu carried on the execution that was supposed to happen.
Etc.
Sanji is not above that.
Of course his character has contradictory moments.
What do you expect when you have an author that wants to juggle hundreds of characters by himself?
Luffy going along with the plan involving destroying what's clearly Big Mom's "treasure" (the Mother Caramel picture).
 
Actually I believe that was his best arc, we got to know a lot about him and there was a lot of development and realities that he had to face and we saw how putting him in that situation had repercussion on his mental state and we saw how he had to face them in this arc.

So no it didn't make me hate him
 
WCI was wild in that the main conflict and reason the arc was happening for 40 chapters was Sanji/Judge and then Oda dropped it for 40 chapters only for it to end with Judge still thinking Sanji sucked.

It didn’t make me hate Sanji just left me confused and unsatisfied
 
Literally any Sanji from any arc ever is night and day to WCI Sanji, which was some one arc rental Sanji ripoff Oda subbed in to make the arc a tearjerker. It's a shame this deep into One Piece Oda was willing to do that to a core character.
According to Luffy fans that's how Sanji always was apparently
 
sanji fanboys are still salty towards zoro even when he's not there
:rolaugh:
yep he is not there, but don't forget while WCI was happening, zoro was out there doing nothing, he didn't did his promised to luffy that he will going to gather samurai while luffy was out,

zoro is a lying bitch worst than ussop, atleast ussop lies turn real, while zoro lies and proceed to act like he is loyal and won't tolerate dishonesty.
:whitepress:
 
yep he is not there, but don't forget while WCI was happening, zoro was out there doing nothing, he didn't did his promised to luffy that he will going to gather samurai while luffy was out,

zoro is a lying bitch worst than ussop, atleast ussop lies turn real, while zoro lies and proceed to act like he is loyal and won't tolerate dishonesty.
:whitepress:
at least zoro didn't cause more problems and made big mom as another enemy in Wano, unlike a certain cook :kayneshrug:
 
Yea you're not even arguing with facts, just feelings.

Every strawhat has compassionate feats, they're all compassionate, but you can't name me a single strawhat with showings like these.



Legit heated argument with Nami who he simps for 24/7 to let kids pleading to be saved go. Right in their face.
Ignoring them is one thing, he downright advocated to not help them. It's not a terrible reason (it's so the crew doesn't get slowed down), but miss me with the 2nd most compassionate strawhat nonsense. Listing out the good doesn't ignore the bad, every strawhat has tons of feats helping others.

I'm gonna leave it at this because you're clearly driven by emotions for this character, moreso than objective reasoning.
Really bad points dude, if someone is driven by agenda here is you.
you clearly cannot notice the diffrence between gag and serious in the first panel you posted, sanji is shown to be the guy who saves and does most for his crew so it is makes him the kindest u cant argue that, just because u dont want to post the previous panles in punk hazzerd that shows sanji being suspicious about giant kids maybe they are not who they say then he is a bad person right? its like you dont even read the story you just spout bullshit without even backing it up, in this same arc sanji saves and fed the kids, plus saved kinemon so all your point are honestly dogshit becasue no one with a brain will agree with your points about sanji being like you describe him to be, completly false and not even close, i suggest you read the story again pal.
 
"The kindest":cantseeme:
Tells Jinbei to off himself
Doesnt want to help the Kids in PH if it wasnt for Nami
Puts razors and poison in Zoro s food
The wyper shit:virusprot:
 
"The kindest":cantseeme:
Tells Jinbei to off himself
Doesnt want to help the Kids in PH if it wasnt for Nami
Puts razors and poison in Zoro s food
The wyper shit:virusprot:
Zoro dared Sanji to put the razor blades and posion


Nami agreed with what Sanji said and Sanji goes onto help the Kids in the next page anyway




The Jinbei is bad I'll agree with that and with Wyper he was their enemy until he decided to brake the bean stalk
 
Zoro dared Sanji to put the razor blades and posion


Nami agreed with what Sanji said and Sanji goes onto help the Kids in the next page anyway




The Jinbei is bad I'll agree with that and with Wyper he was their enemy until he decided to brake the bean stalk
Doesn't matter if Zoro told him to
L.anji didn't even wanted to put poison in BM cake at Bege request
The same BM that was threatened to kill Zeff the same BM that almost killed his friends that he tried to protect:cantseeme::virusprot::cantseeme:
 
Top