Chapter Discussion Did you like how the Robin and Saul Reunion was executed?

Was this done well?

  • Total voters
    60
J

JoNdule

‎
#43
#43
Ven437 said:
I can't believe there are some people here justifying Saul's asspull survival by "we didn't see it" :PepeThink:

Like BRUH

Click to expand...
They always excuse or defend Oda with "we didn't see the corpse buried or dying"

That's not the point
Bringing back Saul is bad
Post automatically merged:

Toby D. Dog said:
Comparing Ace's death to Saul is beyond foul.
Click to expand...
It's not beyond foul


Let's also bring back everyone who died cause why does it matter ?
 
T

trav

‎
#45
#45
Kind of indifferent.

Robins line ruined it for me.
"praise me for being alive"
Maybe its a translation issue and it would hit differently in japanese, idk.
 
J

JoNdule

‎
#47
#47
Ven437 said:


Oh boi I can't wait to see Olvia, Dr. Clover, and all the Ohara survivors show up in the next arc! :PepeCock:
Post automatically merged:




Fuck all the above I guess. New correction to the volumes:


:PepeCock:
Click to expand...
:milaugh:All those dramatic speeches from kuzan and Robin just for Saul to be alive and kicking in elbaf
 
Last edited:
Bisoromi Bear

Bisoromi Bear

‎
#48
#48
Ven437 said:


Oh boi I can't wait to see Olvia, Dr. Clover, and all the Ohara survivors show up in the next arc! :PepeCock:
Post automatically merged:




Fuck all the above I guess. New correction to the volumes:


:PepeCock:
Click to expand...
Kuzan is low key one of the most interesting characters.
Post automatically merged:

JoNdule said:
Like you said, let's bring back Ace too
Why does he need to say dead when Luffy didn't even change as a character.
Click to expand...
Ace was brought back, he has blonde hair now.
 
Kiiro

Kiiro

‎
#51
#51
Ven437 said:


Oh boi I can't wait to see Olvia, Dr. Clover, and all the Ohara survivors show up in the next arc! :PepeCock:
Post automatically merged:




Fuck all the above I guess. New correction to the volumes:


:PepeCock:
Click to expand...

Eh? Saul is a Vice Admiral, a Giant. Fire?

We have impel down characters being thrown hot water and not even flinch.

As mentioned, he was in Ice, it melted, so he got free, and has burns around his body.

That's very possible.

What I could agree that seems a bit forced, is that Robin never heard of Saul being alive.
 
Kurozumi Wiwi

Kurozumi Wiwi

‎
#52
#52
Ven437 said:
Great Robin moment but Saul should be dead. This is just tear bait for Oda to keep OP emotionally invested, but it feels completely forced even when compared to a reunion like Momo and Hiyori and their granddaddy

Would’ve been much more impactful if Robin reunited with a random Ohara survivor who could share in their pain together. We saw Saul die and were led to believe for over 500 chapters he was dead with a tearful goodbye, dying with a smile like D clan, and with no hints of coming back
Click to expand...
Basically
The chapter/reunion was well-done and I like it when taken in a vacuum but I absolutely hate Saul being alive when it comes to the story as a whole.
Last week I was rereading the volume 45 and that dialogue between Aokiji/Robin aged horribly holy shit
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top