Questions & Mysteries Do we have a confirmation of who exactly took Crocodile's hand off?

C

carter5

‎
#1
#1
I know most might have reached this conclusion, but since he admitted to have lost to WB once during the marineford arc I highly suspect the old man was to one who took crocoboy's hand off when they fought a long time ago omegle xender .

Some people think croc's hook is just a weapon, but I disagree.

If it was just a weapon and he still had his hand underneath it the Impel down guards would have took it off.

Besides WB's haki would explain why he wasn't able to regenerate his hand like any logia would.
 
Last edited:
Salah WG

Salah WG

‎
#4
#4
Crocodile hinted multiple times that He was Betrayed & recently He kinda confirmed that this Betrayal involved Mihawk as well
Both are designed as Knights and it seems that Crocodile strongly Hates WG, to the point He postponed his Revenge on WB just so that He doesn't see WG take a Win during MF War. He also told Jinbe that if you want to Protect someone, you gotta do it right

Also his Attitude & Personality & how He spoke against Doffy indicates that He thinks of himself as above everyone, it's very similar to Celestial Dragons, but even worse than Doflamingo, imo both Crocodile & Mihawk were Godheads (Meaning among 20 Leaders of Mary Geoise, such as Gorosei & Holy Knights & Imu)

Whoever Betrayed them had the Power to remove their Status as Godheads, it seems that it was Imu herself who Betrayed them, hence why Crocodile is trying to dethrone WG, but instead of Oda making him a Revos, He made him create Cross Guild because unlike Revos who wanna fix the World, Crocodile simply wants to replace CDs without changing anything about the way They dominated everyone

So coming to your question, it seems that when Crocodile was Betrayed, He was accused of a Crime and He was punished by severing his Hand, you can notice how Oda removes entire Arm for other Characters who were harmed in a Fight (Such as Shanks, Kid, Hawkins, Law, Jozu ... etc), but Crocodile only losing his Hand suggests that it was more of a Punishment, not a Battle

Imo it was Garling or Imu herself who took Crocodile's Hand as Punishment for touching something that is considered Forbidden even for Godheads, and it seems He was wrongly accused & Betrayed, hence his entire Villainous Plans & Motivation
 
Malick the last Light

Malick the last Light

‎
#10
#10
Salah WG said:
Crocodile hinted multiple times that He was Betrayed & recently He kinda confirmed that this Betrayal involved Mihawk as well
Both are designed as Knights and it seems that Crocodile strongly Hates WG, to the point He postponed his Revenge on WB just so that He doesn't see WG take a Win during MF War. He also told Jinbe that if you want to Protect someone, you gotta do it right

Also his Attitude & Personality & how He spoke against Doffy indicates that He thinks of himself as above everyone, it's very similar to Celestial Dragons, but even worse than Doflamingo, imo both Crocodile & Mihawk were Godheads (Meaning among 20 Leaders of Mary Geoise, such as Gorosei & Holy Knights & Imu)

Whoever Betrayed them had the Power to remove their Status as Godheads, it seems that it was Imu herself who Betrayed them, hence why Crocodile is trying to dethrone WG, but instead of Oda making him a Revos, He made him create Cross Guild because unlike Revos who wanna fix the World, Crocodile simply wants to replace CDs without changing anything about the way They dominated everyone

So coming to your question, it seems that when Crocodile was Betrayed, He was accused of a Crime and He was punished by severing his Hand, you can notice how Oda removes entire Arm for other Characters who were harmed in a Fight (Such as Shanks, Kid, Hawkins, Law, Jozu ... etc), but Crocodile only losing his Hand suggests that it was more of a Punishment, not a Battle

Imo it was Garling or Imu herself who took Crocodile's Hand as Punishment for touching something that is considered Forbidden even for Godheads, and it seems He was wrongly accused & Betrayed, hence his entire Villainous Plans & Motivation
Click to expand...
I'm going to be real with you man, I doubt Oda just makes 3 out of 7 OG Warlords Celestial Dragons. This also really raises some rather unnecessary questions on why Crocodile just had his hand taken instead of being killed and Mihawk is not injured whatsoever.

I have in the past speculated myself if Mihawk might be in some way related to Imu/a clone of him due to the eye connection I admit, but if Crocodile AND Mihawk are both god heads banished from the holy Land I think that would just be to repetitive for Oda.
 
Salah WG

Salah WG

‎
#12
#12
Malick the last Light said:
I'm going to be real with you man, I doubt Oda just makes 3 out of 7 OG Warlords Celestial Dragons. This also really raises some rather unnecessary questions on why Crocodile just had his hand taken instead of being killed and Mihawk is not injured whatsoever.

I have in the past speculated myself if Mihawk might be in some way related to Imu/a clone of him due to the eye connection I admit, but if Crocodile AND Mihawk are both god heads banished from the holy Land I think that would just be to repetitive for Oda.
Click to expand...
Everyone is related to CDs, not just Doflamingo

Hancock was a Slave there
Kuma apparently grew up there & his Backstory is definitely related to them, and not long ago He was also their Slave
Shanks was found in God Valley & it's strongly Hinted He could be from Figarland Family, and even if He wasn't, He definitely related
OG Emperors Trio were revealed to have been Part of Rocks Pirates who Attacked CDs in God's Valley Incident
Stelly hinted that Garp is also related to CDs somehow, same goes for Dragon who We still don't know what Motivated him to Fight them
Moria's Past is a Complete Mystery & someone from Mary Geoise ordered his Assassination
Even Buggy could be related somehow because He is inspired from Wizard of Oz (Who should end up sitting on Empty Throne)
One of Vegapunks wants to be a CD
... etc

It's not about repeating Plots, but when you write such a big Story in such a massive world & introduce hundreds of Characters, you will have to create common ground, a place that you can later on use to tie in all remaining Players so that you justify when they all meet & clash, allowing you to take out everyone who's not needed in Final Act

Instead of thinking that Warlords are revealed to be related to CDs, what if you look at it the other way around, WG created Shichibukai System not only to fight rise of piracy but also to keep certain Individuals who are related to them close

They made a Deal with Doffy, and same for Kuma, and Jinbe's Recruitment was also Political, Hancock was their Slave ... etc
And look at D. Members, They already had Garp & Saul as Marines, They then recruited BB, Law as Warlords & also tried to Recruit Ace once, so aside from Luffy & Dragon, WG is clearly keeping D. Family close to them (Nefertari Family was even revealed to be both D. & CDs)

In Crocodile's Case, He has Knight Design, He acts like CDs, his Backstory is related to another Knight-Looking Guy with same Eyes as Imu, his Interaction with Doffy was definitely some kind of Foreshadowing, He met Revos before (At least Ivankov), He learned about Arabasta Poneglyph, Pluton, He hates WG & tries to Dethrone them ... etc

He is 100% related to Mary Geoise in one way or another, maybe not a Former Godhead and simply a Guard (Who maybe was Exiled because He was in a secret relationship with a Female Celestial Dragon), but i want you to think about this:

There are 19 Families in Mary Geoise and Godheads are Leaders of each Family, Five of them are Gorosei, Nine of them are Holy Knights & finally there is Imu who sits on Empty Throne, so that leaves us with Four Missing Godheads, and i can't think of any Knight-Looking Characters who could have been Godheads aside from Crocodile & Mihawk
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top