Chapter Discussion does the meaningless title of "pirate king" fit rocks more than roger?

[Impact]

Bro...

I think Xebec's group and Blackbeard's group are basically terrorists...

Terrorist King lol...

Like... Where Luffy might show concern about the Marines showing up because he doesn't want to kill them and wants no trouble... The opposite is true with Blackbeard. He might actually be like "Zehahaha!! Black hole!" and kill 100 dudes.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Scaling tards calling the pk title meaningless is all I need to know to judge this thread

 

[Sentry22]

Problem is the fandom keep equating Pirate King as strength based. It is an achievement, NOT strength.

Remember Roger kneel and begged Whitebeard to lend him Oden so he could achieve his dream. Whitebeard never cared about the One Piece. He also stole Big Mom's poneglyph without facing her.

He was also Garb's equal. Compared to Rocks who killed an admiral and clashed evenly with a Yonko level at the same day and in the day of the heavily guarded Reverie.

Let that sink in.

"Wealth, fame, power... Gold Roger, the King of the Pirates, obtained this and everything else the world had to offer and his dying words drove countless souls to the seas.""You want my treasure? You can have it! I left everything I gathered together in one place!

How does this fit into your it’s not strength related argument? At this point in the flashback Roger had not yet become Pirate King as he was still just a regular pirate.

How does someone who’s power rivaled that of the World’s Strongest Man not be considered strong in the first place?

 

[Charlotte Horchata]

last time roger was hyped by the story was during that squardo flashback, like 15 years ago

Then comes the harsh reality where Kaidou wanked Roger.

Anyways, any Rocks wank won't last because, at the end of the day, he was despised by the same people who respected Roger. Roger has always been the best portrayed character by Oda and Rocks won't take that place from him, ever. Just enjoy Rocks' brief moment of fame, because it won't last forever.

Problem is the fandom keep equating Pirate King as strength based. It is an achievement, NOT strength.

Not the fandom, the manga equals freedom and strength.

 

[a_fan]

"Wealth, fame, power... Gold Roger, the King of the Pirates, obtained this and everything else the world had to offer and his dying words drove countless souls to the seas.""You want my treasure? You can have it! I left everything I gathered together in one place!

How does this fit into your it’s not strength related argument? At this point in the flashback Roger had not yet become Pirate King as he was still just a regular pirate.

How does someone who’s power rivaled that of the World’s Strongest Man not be considered strong in the first place?

I will certainly wait for God Valley reveal before jumping into conclusion but it isn’t looking good for Roger stans now

 

[Halyup]

I will certainly wait for God Valley reveal before jumping into conclusion but it isn’t looking good for Roger stans now

Anything less than 1v1 with Rocks

and Loger will be on Fraud watch

Post automatically merged: Today at 12:56 AM

Then comes the harsh reality where Kaidou wanked Roger.

Anyways, any Rocks wank won't last because, at the end of the day, he was despised by the same people who respected Roger. Roger has always been the best portrayed character by Oda and Rocks won't take that place from him, ever. Just enjoy Rocks' brief moment of fame, because it won't last forever.



Not the fandom, the manga equals freedom and strength.

PK is a collective achievement
to achieve freedom you need powerful allies

shanks have the most balanced crew among the emperors
kaido have 3 calamities and a smile army
Bigmom have an army from different bloodlines
WB have 16 Division Commanders whose strength varies