Chapter Discussion Dorry and Broggy...

#49
They were still fighting in chapter 633


Post automatically merged:


The problem is this tendency of his has left us with more questions than answers and we are seemingly nearing the end of the manga. Its just bad writting.
theyre fistfighting, so its no longer a fight to the death. also the news coo is dropping news that the straw hats are alive and in the new world.
 
#51

usopp says they want to go to elbaf


They both want to meet the straw hats again and agree.


they agree to settle the fight and work out why theyre fighting later. its already determined its no longer a fight to the death.

later, they are still fighting when they learn their friends the straw hats made it to the new world and might actually make it to elbaf after all, so they settle the fight and go to meet them there.

it seems perfectly sensible. in this case (and probably a lot of others) its less that Oda isn't explaining it, and more like you never bothered to pay enough attention to catch how its already explained
 
#52

usopp says they want to go to elbaf


They both want to meet the straw hats again and agree.


they agree to settle the fight and work out why theyre fighting later. its already determined its no longer a fight to the death.

later, they are still fighting when they learn their friends the straw hats made it to the new world and might actually make it to elbaf after all, so they settle the fight and go to meet them there.

it seems perfectly sensible. in this case (and probably a lot of others) its less that Oda isn't explaining it, and more like you never bothered to pay enough attention to catch how its already explained
I thought the guys from enies lobby went to get them
 
#58
Well looking at Stephen's translation, I think since they both survived countless times trying to kill eachother their "God" has blessed them both.

So their equally right, just like their strength.
Dorry: But our village
has its laws.
For instance, if you start a quarrel within the town, and neither side can settle it...
We beseech the judgment of the God of Erbaf.
The God of Erbaf always grants divine protection to the one who is right.
Only the one who is right is allowed to survive.
So I caused a bit of trouble in town.
Now, another man and I use this island as our duelling ground.
The side which is just will win... and survive.
 
Top