Questions & Mysteries Dumbest One Piece Theories You've Ever Heard/Seen

[Frjay]

I honestly can see that happening. Cause we know Luffy needs to overcome Shanks and both wont get an all out battle against each other, except Shanks goes full betrayal mode, so the best way to overcome Shanks for Luffy is when someone else beats Shanks and Luffy overcomes the other one, in that Theory Kid.

Teach will probably be the one to have the honour of having one over the red haired pirates and not Kidd... unless of course you think Kidd and Killer can solo all the high tiers in the red haired pirates because I doubt there is another high tier in Kidds crew

 

[Pantheos]

Teach will probably be the one to have the honour of having one over the red haired pirates and not Kidd... unless of course you think Kidd and Killer can solo all the high tiers in the red haired pirates because I doubt there is another high tier in Kidds crew

Right now? Definitely not. In the Future, maybe.

 

[Daisuke Jigen]

Rebecca or Bellamy would be the next crewmember.
Top 5 Judge.
The Vinsmokes had a plan for the wedding.
Sabo’s bounty would be 9.6 billion.

 

[Akuma_Law]

No it's not gonna happen and it's definitely one of the dumbest theories out there.
The Admirals and Yonko are the strongest characters in the series Luffy at EOS will probably be barely at that level together with Zoro.
Jimbei will be the 3rd strongest in the crew and will be around high yonko commander level. Sanji will be 4th strongest and also around high commander level.

No crew in the story ever had and never will have 3 Admiral/Yonko level people within it.

4 Yonko + Crews + Allies = 4 Admirals + Marine HQ + Shichibukai/New Weapon

At the final war the SH pirates will probably fight against he Marines together with the revolutionaries + all of their allies which could possibly even include ppl like Mihawk and Shanks.

Sanji as the mere cook of the strawhats will never ever be at a strength level where he could beat an Admiral in a 1v1 fight cause it would not make any sense for him to ever become that strong. And also he doesn't need to be that strong, he will still be strong regardless.

This "he's a mere cook" didn't become a thing except after the time-skip for some reason lol probably because he didn't have a proper 1vs1 full fight yet, but he will have a fight this arc and he will grow stronger
And he is a PIRATE befor being a cook, in the pirate king crew and third strongest
and some of those top tier pirates had a career and it has nothing to do with powerscaling, like Marco and Law for example who are doctors

Also funny thing Sanji in his introduction literally kicked the shit out of Fullbody for calling him a mere cook lmao he's a fighter same as a cook

 

[Gol D. Roger]

Katakuri is Kaido's son.

 

[scoobie3]

This "he's a mere cook" didn't become a thing except after the time-skip for some reason lol probably because he didn't have a proper 1vs1 full fight yet, but he will have a fight this arc and he will grow stronger
And he is a PIRATE befor being a cook, in the pirate king crew and third strongest
and some of those top tier pirates had a career and it has nothing to do with powerscaling, like Marco and Law for example who are doctors

Also funny thing Sanji in his introduction literally kicked the shit out of Fullbody for calling him a mere cook lmao he's a fighter same as a cook

The reason it seems to you that this only became a thing after the time skip is because the enemies they fought pretimeskip were other pirate crews who were roughly around their level.

An Admiral or a Yonko is not a mere crewmate or organization member. The yonko are literally the strongest pirates in the world being all around the same level and the Admirals are the strongest military power the WG has to offer.

It was established when Aokiji beat all the SHs combined neg diff and Kizaru beat all the SNs combined neg diff, that Admiral level is not something just anyone can reach. Not every supernova is going to reach that level either. At max Luffy, Kidd and Zoro reach that level, that's it.
You think Oda goes from all the SHs getting dumpstered by only one Admiral to Sanji beats an Admiral in a 1v1?? That would be nonsense.

Now that Luffy and Zoro are facing the Yonko it becomes all the more apparent that Sanji is going to fall behind and won't ever reach that level.

Sanji is not a pirate before being a cook.
He started his life being a cook and then became a pirate once he met Luffy.

If you are so sure let's bet... i'd bet any amount of money that Sanji will never beat an Admiral in a 1v1.

 

[Akuma_Law]

The reason it seems to you that this only became a thing after the time skip is because the enemies they fought pretimeskip were other pirate crews and CP9 who were roughly around their level.

An Admiral or a Yonko is not a mere crewmate or organization member. The yonko are literally the strongest pirates in the world all around the same level and the Admirals are the strongest military power the WG has to offer.

It was established when Aokiji beat all the SHs combined neg diff and Kizaru beat all the SNs combined neg diff, that Admiral level is not someone anyone can reach.

Now that they Luffy and Zoro are facing the Yonko it becomes all the more apparent that Sanji is going to fall behind and won't ever reach that level.

Sanji is not a pirate before being a cook.
He started his life being a cook and then became a pirate once he met Luffy.

If you are so sure let's bet... i'd bet any amount of money that Sanji will never be able to beat an Admiral in a 1v1.

Give it up man
This is a Shonen manga, and Sanji is in one of the main characters and there is no way in hell he's gonna have a lesser role as fighter than characters such Franky and Usopp when he is always portrayed to be third in the crew in strength

Also don't compare him with Luffy and Zoro facing the Yonkos because it has nothing to do with this discussion
In fact I think him facing a YC is way better than being there at the moment in team fight.

Also the arc is far from ending and you don't know what is Oda planning with him (you don't know maybe he'll end up in the rooftop later)

 

[scoobie3]

Give it up man
This is a Shonen manga, and Sanji is in one of the main characters and there is no way in hell he's gonna have a lesser role as fighter than characters such Franky and Usopp when he is always portrayed to be third in the crew in strength

Also don't compare him with Luffy and Zoro facing the Yonkos because it has nothing to do with this discussion
In fact I think him facing a YC is way better than being there at the moment in team fight.

Also the arc is far from ending and you don't know what is Oda planning with him (you don't know maybe he'll end up in the rooftop later)

Give up what?

It seems you're obsessed with the idea that Sanji fights an Admiral in a 1v1...

You know i can see him fighting an Admiral together with a few other crewmates like Jimbei and some allies but you will definitely be disappointed if you cling so much to this idea of him becoming so powerful.

I know what Oda is planning with him when it comes to powerscaling, he will take the backseat for the rest of the series, mark my words. Just don't be disappointed about it, cause i warned you now and definitely don't blame Oda for bad writing or whatever just cause he didn't share your opinion.

 

[Zolo]

Crocodile was a woman and Luffy's mom

I actually still believe this

 

[stealthblack]

Judge îs top 5. Who else ruled more land then yonkous? North blue îs Like 25% of the world

 

[Orojackson Refugee]

Kaido oni theory is dumb. There have been clues that his power is related to dragon

 

[kurohime]

Crocodile was a woman and Luffy's mom

This is a thread for dumb theories not evidence based basically proven theories

 

[imacub]

Shanks being bad

 

[Artorias]

Hiyori is Toki

 

[Rekien]

Theres been many, ulti becoming next nakama, Shiryu beating Mihawk, Caesar joining the crew, Zoro is Momo's younger half-brother, etc ....But Oden's spirit inhabits Enma and give Zoro haki is pretty high up there.

 

[Finalbeta]

Hiyori is Toki

Imagine thinking that she is Robin instead. Because some people are so into Zoro x Robin they could of started experiencing hallucinations about the particular ship.

 

[kuzanhandsome]

The raid will fail

 

[Artorias]

Imagine thinking that she is Robin instead. Because some people are so into Zoro x Robin they could of started experiencing hallucinations about the particular ship.

Why Zoro x Robin is a thing in first place ?

 

[Xlaw]

Judge top 5
Rebecca for nakama
Croco by is luffys mother

 

[Finalbeta]

Why Zoro x Robin is a thing in first place ?

I think because people love Robin and want to ship the one they deem as the best SH female with him despite the two don't quite have that much in common.