Character Discussion Eustass Kid traveling along the same route as Luffy from Dawn Island to Wano

[Mochiman]

Imagine if Kid had started his journey on Dawn Island with Killer and the rest of his crew and visited the same islands as Luffy and faced the same enemies. Where would Kid's journey end?

Part 1:
- Pre-timeskip Kid & crew.
- Starts in Dawn Island and ends in MF.

In case you think he will make it to the end (post-MF):

Part 2:
- Post-timeskip Kid & crew.
- Starts in Sabaody and ends when Kid arrives in Wano.

I think that pre-timeskip Kid would have reached Alabasta but Crocodile would have finished him.

In the case of post-timeskip Kid, his journey would end in DR at the hands of Doflamingo.

 

[ShinichiMugi]

I think it could have ended in Enies Lobby (assuming somehow he fights with the government too for some reason) because he doesnt have Luffy's ability to make allies so in EL he would have lost.

 

[rerere]

Part 1: Skypea cause of Enel DF
Part 2: Doesn't stop

 

[Mochiman]

Part 1: Skypea cause of Enel DF
Part 2: Doesn't stop

In Part 2, what do you think of DR? Doffy's DF seems to me very dangerous against Kid's DF, that is, Doffy could control the Punk Rotten or cut the metal.

 

[rerere]

In Part 2, what do you think of DR? Doffy's DF seems to me very dangerous against Kid's DF, that is, Doffy could control the Punk Rotten or cut the metal.

Since Punk Rotten seems Kidd's correspective of Gear 4 he probably can shrug Parasite off with brute strenght and in general deal the same damage Gear 4 Luffy was capable of (with the advantage of not having the time limit). Doffy could cut the metal yes, but just like he can cut everything else.. and Kidd can build it back
If you mean if Kidd Alliance attacked Dressrosa instead of Luffy Alliance, I say they would've won.

 

[Lukegranders]

Not including skypeia they should clear tbh

 

[MonsterKaido]

Bari

 

[Mochiman]

Since Punk Rotten seems Kidd's correspective of Gear 4 he probably can shrug Parasite off with brute strenght and in general deal the same damage Gear 4 Luffy was capable of (with the advantage of not having the time limit). Doffy could cut the metal yes, but just like he can cut everything else.. and Kidd can build it back
If you mean if Kidd Alliance attacked Dressrosa instead of Luffy Alliance, I say they would've won.

Not including skypeia they should clear tbh

What about WCI and Katakuri?

 

[rerere]

What about WCI and Katakuri?

Kidd has been in WCI and injured a Commander time ago (if my chronological ricostruction is right, during the 1st year of the TS)
I'd like to know more about who did he neutralize, what did he steal and also the context of this 'invasion'

 

[Mochiman]

Kidd has been in WCI and injured a Commander time ago (if my chronological ricostruction is right, during the 1st year of the TS)
I'd like to know more about who did he neutralize, what did he steal and also the context of this 'invasion'

But one thing is to invade WCI and the other is to defeat Katakuri, which I think is impossible for Kid.

 

[rerere]

But one thing is to invade WCI and the other is to defeat Katakuri, which I think is impossible for Kid.

For the impression he gave to me, CoO is the weakest form of Haki in Kidd's cas (may just be my impression tho) and I think Kata, with Marco, is the toughest Commander Kidd could face. Out of the 5 on the rooftop, I can only see Luffy and Law beating Kata atm (not for a matter of strenght but for a matter of skills)
Wouldn't be so sure of Kata winning tho

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Pre ts: stops at Crocodile
Post ts: stops at Doffy

 

[Lukegranders]

What about WCI and Katakuri?

whole cake? If they have their alliance with hawkins and apoo they should make it out he would probably lose to katakuri though but gain better observation

 

[Mochiman]

For the impression he gave to me, CoO is the weakest form of Haki in Kidd's cas (may just be my impression tho) and I think Kata, with Marco, is the toughest Commander Kidd could face. Out of the 5 on the rooftop, I can only see Luffy and Law beating Kata atm (not for a matter of strenght but for a matter of skills)
Wouldn't be so sure of Kata winning tho

Well, OK. I see it completely different. The only one I see at Kata's level is Luffy. I see the rest of them as far below. We can agree to disagree, I guess.

 

[Tai long]

Pre ts he stops at crocodile, since he doesn't know haki

 

[I'mTired]

The question is would Dragon save Kidd from Smoker since I am pretty sure Logia was kinda unbeatable preTS.
If Dragon somehow was there to save Kidd for whatever reason, Crocodile would stop him, can't see Robin would save Kidd because he's not a D.
And if somehow Kidd gets pass Alabasta, Skypiea is his end anyway.

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Kidd would've died to Sir Crocodile in 1st
Kidd would've died to Hody Jones in 2nd
Kidd is trash

 

[wereng99]

The question is would Dragon save Kidd from Smoker since I am pretty sure Logia was kinda unbeatable preTS.
If Dragon somehow was there to save Kidd for whatever reason, Crocodile would stop him, can't see Robin would save Kidd because he's not a D.
And if somehow Kidd gets pass Alabasta, Skypiea is his end anyway.

Aside from Luffy I can't see any other novas captain to get past enel

 

[rerere]

Enel is broken

Post automatically merged: Mar 12, 2021

Kidd would've died to Sir Crocodile in 1st
Kidd would've died to Hody Jones in 2nd
Kidd is trash

Caribou

 

[Mochiman]

Enel is broken

I hope Enel returns. I would like to see the reaction of the WG and the rest of the pirates to a guy who thinks he is God and has such a broken DF.